Once again, the so-called 'right to life' nut cases have proven they have NO regard for human life, else, how can they condone a cold blooded murder such as this one?
Hey- I'm pro-life and this venal act in no way supported by the majority of pro lifers. This is a sad day for his family, the pro-life movement and for the human race in general. Please do not lump all prolifers together!
Hey- I'm pro-life and this venal act in no way supported by the majority of pro lifers. This is a sad day for his family, the pro-life movement and for the human race in general. Please do not lump all prolifers together!
When Barack Obama and every other Democrat is called a murderer and baby killer on this board, it isn't much of a stretch to suggest the anti-choice people condone and even advocate violence and murder.
As a solution, both Pro-life and Pro-choice are unsustainable. Both arguments, being temporal and also binary do not have basis in Truth with a capital "T". That is, depending on your point of view you can argue for either side and be both correct and wrong at the same time. Look at this sad example of Dr. Tiller's murder. A Pro-lifer took the life of a human while trying to defend his/her viewpoint on abortion. Tried to justify the taking of a life to save another life. Isn't he/she now just as guilty? Totally hypocritical and therefore unsustainable. Let's say we outlaw abortion, how will we handle an overcrowded Earth in a few centuries? Who will be chosen to die and who will live when the Earth's resources no longer support our biology? We need to STOP trying to legislate based on binary and temporal arguments and instead look toward the Eternal solutions. The religious should return to their roots where Jesus instructed us to "seek ye first the Kingdom of God." That is, the unarguable Truths which are Eternal. Kind of like the writings of our Constitution and our Bill of Rights. They are written in UNARGUABLE language and their Truths will hold (sustain) until the end of times. Also, the religious should try to remember that Jesus Christ triumphed over death. That is, if you really believe in Jesus Christ than death is not a problem, am I correct? Then we should just accept death within the reality of life as just another stage and forget about the timing. What we are really argueing here is the timing of death and not death in itself. Could it not be that soon to be aborted fetuses only come into this plane of existence in order to teach their parents something about life? And if so, who are we to negate the lesson? The parent(s), having learned their error from a prior abortion, wouldn't they be more receptive and caring of the gift of life in the future?
This murder is the logical end to the faulty absolutist slant that abortion = murder. The murderer, in this case, was responding logically to what he saw as a mass executioner in the doctor.
Since clinic doctors are not being killed across the country, we can assume that the anti-choice contingency does not believe as the murderer did that 1. abortion = murder and 2. an eye for an eye is a biblically sanctioned response to a perceived murder.
I think most right-wingers would say 1 and 2 are both true. In fact they routinely do on this board, but only the abortion clinic murderers walk the walk. I say thank God (Christian or otherwise) for that.
Right, like the person who shot and killed him is any better than him. Please, people need to remember that they are not the almighty, and shall not judge those here one earth!
There is that faction of the 'Pro-Life' group that are fundamentalist extremist, aka, "terrorists", that are equally a threat to our Constitution and American-way of life as any other terrorists.
Fundamentalist, be it Islamic or Christian are still fundamentalists and more than likely violent - and we have no room for either one of them in the United States.
Law Enforcement need to go after these right-winged fanatics just as hard as our military is going after the Taliban.
Finally, I contend that we are all 'pro-life', but some of us believe that it is a woman's right to choose. I don't know of a single-person that approves of unconditional abortion. Most 'pro-choice' advocates would never choose abortion, they simply support the woman's right to choose, specifically, conditional.
The fact is that all you right-to-lifers should get lumped together until you do something about your extremists. You claim to be the protectors of life, but you take life illegally. Whether you like it or not, abortion is legal in this country. It is not murder. Your right-to-lifer friend committed MURDER! Step up, take responsibility and stop hiding behind the "That's not how I feel" cop-out.
Anti-abortion group Operation Rescue = Terrorists....it's our CHOICE, stay the hell out of our business....Operation Rescue should be listed as a Terrorist's Organization
Funny how "right-to-lifers" only care about "certain lives". This man was a living. air breathing human being and he had the right to life. Operation Rescue promotes and instigates these nut jobs to do crimes like this one. Then they denounce it. This is a sad day for the human race.
We have a legal process in this country to deal with people we feel have broken the law. Dr. Tiller was being put through that process. This is not the way to handle him. One person judging a man is not in any way set forth in our Constitution as a State or a Nation. I disagree with Dr. Tillers chosen profession, but he has rights in this State and Country that needed to be observed. We have capital punishment in this state. May the one that gunned down Dr.Tiller find the same fate. As long as a person draws breath, they have the ability to make their lot in life better. This person does not deserve that right. He has lost it by his cowardly act.
The shooter is a criminal plain and simple. There has already been anti-abortion groups denoucing this horrible act. I think this push to lump anyone who is republican as some kind of "right wing" nutcase is a pretty lame example. No one is approving of this gunman's actions and I for one feel he should be considered a domestic terrorist and if found alive, should be given the death penalty. I am a republican, but I also believe in a woman's right. I also believe in owning a weapon. Don't start the political banter on this act. Somewhere someone took matters into his own hands and committed murder. He could have protested the site or even protested the doctor, but he did the coward method and shoots some 67 year old doctor while the man is attending his church. The FBI should have at least assisted him or made some assessments on which groups were becoming more and more violent.
Come on Wayne. How am I, a guy in Michigan, who doesn't think most abortions are a good thing, going to stop an abortion nut case running around Kansas? I think you over estimate our organizational skills. And why in any way would I be responsible for it? No anti-abortion people I know share the twisted murderous logic of this perpetrator.
I don't see what the big deal is to all the abortion proponents. Just consider it an abortion in the 201st trimester. That should make you feel better.
OK, I absolutely don't condone this crime; it is sheer murder. But, I can't reconcile how some of you can be so outraged at the killing of the doctor, but you are not outraged at the killing of defenseless babies. Not only are you not outraged at it, you promote it - in the name of protecting women and their "rights". Let these women just not get pregnant; there are all kinds of means to do that out there you know.
PROLIFERS Murdering People. PROLIFERS Murdering Doctors. To me that is funny! Its simple irony. But really..but it's a hoot..it's a f'in hoot! via Bill Hicks
NBBSBC82, you are right. It was a VERY late term abortion. I mean, the "doctor" could have survived outside his mother's womb, but that would have been hazardous to some peoples' "mental health." Although, I don't think he should have been shot, I think that he should have been injected with saline, hung up-side down, had blunt scissors shoved through the back of his skull and his brain extracted until he died, because that is the LEGAL WAY to commit murder.
When Barack Obama and every other Democrat is called a murderer and baby killer on this board, it isn't much of a stretch to suggest the anti-choice people condone and even advocate violence and murder.
Your huge oversight is that barry and the pro-choice individuals (Not ALL democrats) fail to renounce and call abortion what it is: "MURDER". No need to paint a pretty picture. Have the guts to call it what it is!!!
Be it an un-born child, an abortion Doctor, or a death row inmate!"MURDER" IS "MURDER"!!
"We are shocked at this morning's disturbing news that Mr. Tiller was gunned down. Operation Rescue has worked for years through peaceful, legal means, and through the proper channels to see him brought to justice. We denounce vigilantism and the cowardly act that took place this morning.
Let's see barry renounce abortion the way that the organization above has renounced murder????
This act is horrible. My prayers goes out to the family and to the church members. I am a little confused. Where in the article did it say the suspect was a pro-life activist or he was a right-wing nut or he was faith driven.
For the record I am neither pro-life or pro-choice. I am a believer and supporters of individual rights.
Aren't you jumping to conclusions? Who said pro-lifers condone this type of thing? Absolutley NOT! Who knows if this may have been done by someone with a personal vendetta against this man. Who knows if it could have been done by someone who didn't want his girlfriend/wife, whatever, to get an abortion, or a patient not satisfied with the outcome.
PROLIFERS Murdering People. PROLIFERS Murdering Doctors. To me that is funny! Its simple irony, but really.. it's a hoot..it's a f'in hoot! via Bill Hicks
please Trish, no regard for human life is abortion..the numbers are completely offset..I'm not giving my views on pro-life or abortion.. thus, there are consequences to both actions, which I prefer not to elaborate on...please my dear, had you been aborted, we would of not heard from you.. then we'd not know of life's intricacies..off the wall; if the wages of sin is death, then what did a unborn child do ??....
Okay wing-nuts, let's talk logic... NOT emotion or saber-rattling, just logic.
1) How many references in the bible and just about any other significant historical writing does the beginning of one's life start at birth? All? Really? And how many start at conception? None? Really?
2) How old are you? And that's based on your "life" starting when? At birth? Why not count from conception then?
3) So at what point did you decide that life starts at a different point than the bible and every other social behavior refers to? There must have been some grand revelation, right?After all, this IS your argument, right?
4) So you say your new life starting point is based on science? How is it that you reject every other aspect of science... like evolution... but insist that YOUR interpretation of the evolving science of fetus awareness is the correct one? When was it you changed your OPINION?
5) And finally, the fetus is absolutely and undeniably totally dependent on the mother... until BIRTH. Doesn't it stand to reason, then, that a mother OWNS and must make decisions for and about that fetus until that fetus is BORN... which is when the fetus becomes a child and is independent of the mother... which is when the mother loses her absolute rights over who is now the newly born child.
Look, I'm just saying that you "pro-lifers" have every right to believe what you believe FOR YOURSELVES, but DO NOT have the right to deny the rights of a mother over her fetus. Its logical. It's supported by your own religion. And you are violating other's rights by demanding that EVERYONE follow your beliefs.
AND, BTW, if you wrote any "hate" posts, or spoke to anyone of Tiller or others being murderers, then YOU are the ones that brought this on. There are crazies out there. You all just successfully influenced the wrong one. Think about it.
Once again, the so-called 'right to life' nut cases have proven they have NO regard for human life, else, how can they condone a cold blooded murder such as this one?
You know what stands out to me concerning this situation? The right wingers, who are all too quick to jump on here and criticize anything they can about the state of things in the U.S. these days -- like Sonia Sotomayor's nomination for the Supreme Court, or Barack Obama's response to North Korea -- are unusually silent on this one. What's wrong? The vast majority of the right is vehemently opposed to abortion, so why aren't they celebrating the murder of an abortion doctor? Hasn't Rush Limbaugh given you the go-ahead to cheer this one? Hasn't Dick Cheney said it was a threat to America?
The right wing...(crickets...crickets)...nut cases on this and many other subjects as well...
Yet another example of white christian zealots engaging in acts of domestic terrorism. White christian males have carried out most of the terrorist acts committed in this country and until we start treating them as the terrorists they are, it will not stop. There are so many pro-lifers out there defending their pro-life organizations, but they don't stop to consider what their "Wanted dead or alive" posters really are--calls to activiely engage in terrorism.
Abortion is NOT murder because the Bible clearly states that a person is not living until he has received the breath of life (i.e. been born). Up until that time it is part of the mother's body, no different than her hair, fingernails, or appendix with the exception of the parastical nature of the growing cell cluster. It is a parasitical infection in that it cannot survive outside of the mother's body and the body seeks to treat it as an infection (i.e. to destroy it). You have your beleifs and I have mine, though mine are supported with scripture AND science and your are based on your "feelings". I don't seek to impose my thoughts on you, so please quit trying to impose your dogma on everyone else, too.
Okay wing-nuts, let's talk logic... NOT emotion or saber-rattling, just logic...
Excellent post! For those who want to read the entire post, it's post #1.33. I'd enjoy seeing a right winger try to disagree with the logic. They can't...
okay i see the media has successfully started another baited story against the pro-life movement.... where in this story does it say the killer has been caught or tied to any pro-life movement, why can't the killer be a plain old crazy nutcase.
nobody condones this behavior but why do we always assume its political?
The Pro-Deathers have spoken! Let us all rejoice in this! Pro-Choice or the Pro-Death people are truly racists. They would rather have minority baby's killed in the womb and not deal with these minorities in the future. Ask any white supremacists. Pro-Deathers have done more for their cause (the white supremacists) then they ever could have done for themselves. for instance, black women are 6 to 8 times more likley to have an abortion than white women. Good for you Pro-Choicers!!
I condon his or her behavior for cold blooded murder.....tell me Mr "oh so Righetous" on the left.....how do you justfiy the cold blooded murder of an innocent baby??????????
The souls of Dr. Tiller and his killer will meet again, in one place. The souls of all the aborted fetuses will meet again, in another place. Like the Real Estate agent says, "Location, location, location!"
Left Wing WACKOS, you all are experts with your selective seeing and hearing, what a bunch of morons. Frankly I'm glad that the LEFT WING EXTREMIST JUDGES decide to MAKE law from the bench rather than inturpit it, like legalizing abortion. You can all abort yourselves hahahahaha! "What comes around goes around".
It amazes me how quick the LEFT is to condem someone on the right, but not condem someone on the left. This guy got his due, good ridins! hahahahahah!!!!!!!!!
I will grieve for Mr tiller for about the amount of time he spent mourning the BABIES that could have survied outside of the mother womb. Which we know was not long because there were more babies to MURDER!!!!!
Well I find it interesting he's a usher at church, when at the same time he is performing late term abortions, on live babies in the womb. I do not condone the killing by any means, but one side who condones killing babies, thinks there's no argument over a late term baby abortion, but rises up when another human kills a human being. Like in this case, one human being who killed human beings, was killed by another living human being. This doctor had no feelings about reaching in a womb and pulling a baby with arms and feet out, killing it as he did his deed. Killing is wrong no matter what side of the fence you are on, surely the wackos on both sides of the fence can agree on that.
The Pro-Deathers have spoken! Let us all rejoice in this! Pro-Choice or the Pro-Death people are truly racists. They would rather have minority baby's killed in the womb and not deal with these minorities in the future. Ask any white supremacists. Pro-Deathers have done more for their cause (the white supremacists) then they ever could have done for themselves. for instance, black women are 6 to 8 times more likley to have an abortion than white women. Good for you Pro-Choicers!!
By that I mean you hater liberals.
So the Docs life was aborted - so what?! Someone with a right to choose decided he shouldn't live - how's that any different than abortion, fools?!
I condon his or her behavior for cold blooded murder.....tell me Mr "oh so Righetous" on the left.....how do you justfiy the cold blooded murder of an innocent baby??????????
Left Wing WACKOS, you all are experts with your selective seeing and hearing, what a bunch of morons. Frankly I'm glad that the LEFT WING EXTREMIST JUDGES decide to MAKE law from the bench rather than inturpit it, like legalizing abortion. You can all abort yourselves hahahahaha!
I refer all you right wingers who want to force your religion on everyone (ever heard of "separation of Church and State"?) back to post #1.33 and challenge you to dispute what's said.
No......the Pro-Deathers like to state over and over again that abortion is legal in this country. Just like the killing of Jews was legal in Nazi Germany. The day of reckoning is coming whether libs like to believe it or not. Just take a look around. The balloon is about to burst.
I believe all groups , pro and con lose with this. This situation cannot further either groups position. I find it a sad day for both the pros and cons on the abortion issue.
I don't believe in abortion much less late term, but I do believe we all lost on this one. It can in no way further any of our positions.
Hey- I'm pro-life and this venal act in no way supported by the majority of pro lifers
Yeah right and I am Santa Clause .... Quick trip to your page finds you think Bush was the greatest thing since grits were invented and you are to the right of Limbaugh in a lot of cases. You are probably sitting at your computer grinning from ear to ear and popping a cork.
People who throw stones then do not want to be blamed for the broken glass should stop throwing stones. Anti abotionists are the new terrorists but choose to hide when their efforts come to culmination/
Those who claim that the unborn are just a piece of meat, just a parasite, and there is nothing in the Bible about life beginning at birth need to check out Jerimiah 1: 4-5.
As for this shooting, the man is a criminal and has no support of any pro-life group that I'm aware of, unlike the abortionist and all his supporters. Had it been turned around all the pro-abortionists would've just considered it late term abortion.
Although I disagree with the murder, I do agree that a gun should not have been used, but a pair of scissors and a suction pump as he used for his thousands of killings. He should have gotten to suffer some of the pain he inflicted on totally innocent babies.
what terrible news! my absolute condolences to Tiller's entire family. He is a doctor. A professor of the medical field. A human being with a family and a life. Terrible that some idiot decides that life for a life seems justified. Obviously the killer has to be a man. Since any woman, considerable of women's rights in general, would never go that far.
sorry to say this, but for the most part, this is a woman's right, choice, decision, and hardship. No man can nor will they ever know what it's like to have to go through something like an abortion. Not to say they have some say in it....but it's a woman's personal decision....and sometimes it is to preserve her own life. life is about choices, and that is a God-given right. No matter what religion you stand for.
He is up in heaven.....and I bet he is there with all the little babies that performed the procedure. He will protect, and they will protect him. I believe this whole heartily.
I agree Trish, if you say Pro Life, why would it ever be okay to kill someone. That actually sounds like a double standard and very confusing.
Thou shalt not kill, but then you kill someone! Be it conspirital or however who ever was a part of the discussion or plot, they should all pay for it tenfold!!!
"I refer all you right wingers who want to force your religion on everyone (ever heard of "separation of Church and State"?) back to post #1.33 and challenge you to dispute what's said.
Any takers?"
GOD! gives life and takes it away. We will all answer for what we have done someday. I for one will NEVER VOTE THAT IT IS OK TO KILL AN INOCENT LIFE!
The guy who killed the DR. He will answer for what he has done, as will you who give the aproval to take a life for what ever reason you think is justifable. I feel sorrow for you!
"separation of Church and State" has nothing to do with seperating Church and State as we know it. Seperation of Church and State was souley to keep the government from forcing a religion on us, NOT keeping God and religion out of government.
Most people think it is written in the constitution, due to the constant propaganda of the left. The constitution maintains we have freedom OF religion, that religion we want not one forced on us by a government.
YOU LEFT WINGERS ARE SO EAGER TO HAVE THE GOV RUN EVERYTHING, AND BEFORE BARACK HUSSEIN OBOMA IS OUT OF OFFICE IT WILL. WE WILL BE THE SOCIALIST GOV OF AMERICA AND SOCAILISM WILL REIGN SUPREME. HOPE YOU LIKE DICTATOR OBAMA.
AFTER THAT HAPPENS, YOU WON'T BE ABLE TO BLAME BUSH ANYMORE.
SO KEEP ON ABORTING YOURSELVES, MAYBE YOU'LL MANAGE TO KILL OFF ENOUGH OF YOURSELVES THAT WE CAN STILL SAVE THIS COUNTRY!
Late term abortions as well as abortions I cannot agree with. Yet, I still believe that we all lost with this situation. I think the guy should have been arrested along time ago and and charged. I do believe that Wade vs Roe, does not contemplant late term abortions unless the mother life is in danger. I stand corrected if I am wrong, but 1. I do not believe in abortions, much less late term, but I still think we all lost with what this guy did as well as who killed him. based on what he has been doing I would love to say he got the same treatment that he has been doing, but I can't. freedom of choice to terminate (stickily from the present law or rulings) , I believe do not contemplated late term abortions. But the whole situation I believe has hurt us all.
I'll take you up on it . I am not a pro life based on religion. I am pro life based on pro life, and as a moderate conservative maybe , and that's a big maybe depending on certain situations. but has nothing to do with my religious beliefs. Still say all groups lost with this one . And by the way i also don't believe in the death penalty
To 1.35 -- Please show me in THE Bible where an unborn child is referred to as a "parasitical infection", or where the Bible "clearly states" that a chld is not alive until it receives the "breath of life".
Come on Wayne. How am I, a guy in Michigan, who doesn't think most abortions are a good thing, going to stop an abortion nut case running around Kansas? I think you over estimate our organizational skills. And why in any way would I be responsible for it? No anti-abortion people I know share the twisted murderous logic of this perpetrator.
Are you kidding me? I believe that these "right-to-life" organizations are just as guilty as the murderer, just as if EVERY LAST ONE OF THEM PULLED THAT TRIGGER THIS MORNING ON DR. TILLER. Just as any solicitor would be charged with murder in any murderer-for-hire, or if in the case of an accomplice being killed in the commission of a bank robbery. You would be equally as guilty.
How could Dan-410533 or any of the other "right-to-lifers" give the argument of "because you were not in the vacinity when this murderer murdered Dr. Tiller" that you couldn't possibly be blamed for it. Well hear this. I for one DOES BLAME THE ENTIRE ORGANIZATION FOR THIS MURDER. Anytime you "gin-up" your base, keep in mind that you have no idea of the mindsets, or the mental health of the folks you're "hopping" up with your nonsense. You have no idea how dangerous some of these folks are. While you "say" you wouldn't or did not pull the trigger, you have more than enough proof now that someone less mentally stable will and did pull the trigger.
YES... I HOLD THE ENTIRE ORGANIZATION EQUALLY RESPONSIBLE FOR THIS COLD BLOODED MURDER OF DR. TILLER... IN THE CHURCH OF GOD, while in the service of God. You can't have it both ways. You can't preach saving the life of the unborn, but not even hesitating to take the life of the born, in the name of your cause..... and even much, much worst..... in the name of God!!!
i may be selfish in my position, but I have a daughter that would give anything to adopted a baby and give the mother the rights to see her and pay for everything, but the costs are way out in left field. my oldest sister adopted one 36 years ago and she is beautiful. What I believe is that they have made a business out of adoption where potentially great parents cannot afford to adopted. There are so many out there that would just love to have a child That's why i say it it not religious based in my case.
Prolife "nutters" are the biggest hypocrites. "If they told me it was me or the baby then they can take my life". Ok, Mccain I guess we will never know and take your word for it...NUTTERS.
To much religion dives a person insane, just look at the Arab world. There they stone you to dead, here they shoot you if you are not a believer like they are.
The right to lifers are so adamant about not allowing abortions but when it comes to using tax money for babies born to drug and alcohol addicts who, as adults cannot function in the world and need help, then they're called lazy unproductive drains that don't deserve anything from the government. If you are against abortions because you consider it taking a life, then you need to be consistent and care for that life as long as it exists if it's unable to function, since you put yourself in the position of being responsible for it's existence. You can't have it both ways.
To the religious right the ends always justifies the means, no matter how unethical, illegal, or sinful the means are. Christ would be so ashamed of the things done in His Name.
This is exactly why the Founding Fathers were so opposed to any presence at all of religion in public life or government. This is why they wanted a "solid wall" between church and state. This is why people are more any more turning their face away from hateful forms of "Christianity" and towards non-affiliation.
Being a Christian is a lot easier that many think. You have eleven commandments to follow. Then you have a model of social behavior in Christ's own life to follow. And you have the intelligence to make moral and ethical decisions based on these two precepts.
Once again, the so-called 'right to life' nut cases have proven they have NO regard for human life, else, how can they condone a cold blooded murder such as this one?
It's interesting how they think they are performing justice. Rest assured the abortion doctor is in a better place, but I wonder where these religious nuts who think murdering doctors...where does the Bible say that murderers go. Last time I checked they go to hell. Especially if they shed innocent blood by premediation. Maybe justice can forgive crimes of passion. But justice for killing an innocent abortion doctor in my mind means you go to hell from what I know.
If you think that pro-life is God's philosophy, even in cases of rape and incest, then geesh, I think if you want to make a fight, that fight starts in influencing your state and federal lawmakers. Because not only is murder against God's law, it is also illegal to deprive someone of their right to live in this country without a court trial as per the Bill of Rights.
These idiots are enemies to their country and God. And yet they think they are doing someone a favor with their fanaticism.
Welcome to Religious Extremism... Hypocrisy at its Best.. You even see pro-lifers here in MA harassing even young teen girls who have been raped... I've seen a young girl get her face beat into the sidewalk by a Pro-life religious fanatic... These people are turning into Terrorists.. Not all Pro-lifers are this fanatical but most are in the realms of Radicalism where it can easily turned into something like this..
On the Subject its self... Most pro-lifers fail to even do any critical thinking on the subject.. They have no concept about keeping the human population in control... When does the idea of saving every life become more dangerous to the human race??.. If you think 9 billion people is over crowding and out of control..Imagine how much Raping of the Earth the human Race would do with a population of 15 billion... Pro-lifers are really this stupid.. Eventually they would either be forced to become self hypocrites of their own ideology or accept possible human extinction due to sheer stupidity..
It's bad enough that you can't drive 5 miles without seeing human trash all over the place.. Not to mention a plastic island twice the size of Texas in the Pacific ocean... And Pro-lifers seriously think that more people = sustainable happy life..
Then you have the multi-Billion dollar baby market... Which has more to do with the political war than actually saving a life... Anti-Abortion = Big profits in Adoption agencies, medical agencies, insurance companies, and drug companies..
Then you have what they call back alley abortions as well as trash/toilet babies... Another thing that pro-lifers try to ignore and scoff at as if it wouldn't happen.. Another shiny example of not having the ability to do any critical thinking at all..
And one of the biggest problems ever.. The sheer failure of current agencies to protect children from abusive home placements or even the ability to ensure educational development even in foster care...
If abortions were made illegal there would be NO SYSTEM CAPABLE of HANDLING the sheer numbers of children that would be injected into the already broken system... And where will all the money come from to ensure the needs of all these children? Are you going to pay for it? Are you going to pay for the medical expenses and health care of all the mothers you force to have children?
You are talking 10's of thousands of babies each year.. Maybe even upwards to a million in 10 years or even 10 million after that..Your developing a constant baby boom... And where will all these children going to go.?? Will you enslave the women to care for their own rapists children? What plan do you pro-lifers even have to protect these peoples lives? Do you even care?
What's next.. Pro-lifers making sex laws to enforce their ideology? Prevent people from even talking to each other? Sounds like a Religious Police State in the making...
Your logic escapes me. I understand ones birth takes place on the day their mother gives birth to them. What I don't understand is how this can be interpreted to mean that human life did not exist within the mother's womb prior to the day she gave birth to the child. Logic tells me that when a woman is pregnant she is carrying an unborn child in her womb. Each day of her pregnancy which began at conception the unborn child is growing and developing. When references are made to the birth of individuals in the bible or in historical writings logic tells me that the mothers of these individuals carried them in the womb for a full term pregnancy until the day of their birth. I agree an unborn child is totally dependent on its mother for its existence and I recognize that dependence doesn't end at the moment the child is born. There is life in the womb before the child is born and there is life outside the womb after the birth of the child.
Your logic works for you pal but it doesn't work for me. There are laws on the books where if during the murder of a pregnant woman her unborn child is also killed the killer can face two counts of murder. Where does that fit in your logic wise one.
I suppose you are Pro-Neutral? Which would mean you could care less if a Child dies or if the World has a complete Ecological Collapse that leads to the extiction of the human race becaus pro-lifers have no concept of population control and responsibility... But Hey, Trash babies and back alley abortions under Religious Law seems like a new wonderful world eh?
7 the LORD God formed the man from the dust of the ground and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life, and the man became a living being.
Notice, the man did not become a living being until after he had taken the breath of life. Prior to that time, the man was NOT a living being, it was merely a lump of dust formed in the image of the creator. It's very sad that you have not even read into the second chapter of the first book of your holy text and profess yourself to be like the one you deify. It's even sadder that you would blindly condemn another person based on the ignorance which you seem to so fully possess.
As for the parasitical infection part, that is simple science. If a creature needs to feed off of a host (in this case, the mother) in order to survive, it is considered a parasite. If you cut a fetus out of its mother, it will die, ergo it is a parasite until it has received the breath of life (i.e. come to term and been born), at which time it is considered a baby (i.e. a small human, but without all of the rights accorded to fully developed humans).
Excellent post!I hope your 5-point itemized list gets picked up and published in some national magazines.
It's hard to paint all non-choice individuals with the same brush, but when they insist on calling abortion, stem-cell research, and even condom use murder, they are in fact promoting this abhorent behavior.
Demanding that everyone else conform to their own personal views exhibits an enormous character flaw ... this probably explains why we don't see any anti-abortion people being murdered by pro-choice folks.
lets talk Genesis and the bibles hypocrisy and immorality...
Concerning Religion on this subject.. It's pretty hypocritical to claim immorality.. Especially for a Religioun that claims to be a Religion of "Unconditional Love" and with a deity that is supposed to "Love us ALL"... This religious ideological construct around the concept of a deity is entirely a ideological Hypocrisy.. And yes IT"S NOT JUST THE RELIGIOUS spewing their HATE over this... But the Church is the Primary Funder and the Primary adovcate to spreading and lobbying for anti-Gay/Lesbian Laws... And here is a Prime example of Hate, spite, hypocrisy and extremism by their very own dear lord..!
On religion for example.. Extremism and hate do exist in the literature.. The bible for example has these two versus:
6:7
" 7And the LORD said, I will destroy man whom I have created from the face of the earth; both man, and beast, and the creeping thing, and the fowls of the air; for it repenteth me that I have made them."
Not only is the GOD stating that he "Hates" you, he is also stating that he hates "ALL" living things..That means your dog too Dorthy... And along side the hate and regret he shows complete contempt to massacre in pure genocidal rage of every living thing innocent or not... That is extremism.. That is hate.. This is not "LOVE"
6:17
"And, behold, I, even I, do bring a flood of waters upon the earth, to destroy all flesh, wherein is the breath of life, from under heaven; and every thing that is in the earth shall die."
According to the Bible it seem that GOD is more like a Devil.. A Hitler... Is the Bible the devil in sheep's clothing? How can a "Deity" that is supposed to be a Supernatural Being of Unconditional Love filled with Equal or greater hate than a Terrorist blowing up a Club of teenagers...
IS GOD REALLY IN MANS IMAGE?
You toss in the commandment "Thou Shall Not Kill" And you suddenly feel like you are living on the Island of Dr Monroe! A supposed GOD/Creator that Blames its beasts of creation for any wrongs it may have done.. As if injecting free will and free thought wouldn't have Logically led to something going wrong.. As if giving Man the ability to sin wouldn't result in just that... If man was to be created in his image he should have intelligently designed man with the inability to "SIN".. It would have saved this "GOD" a lot of trouble and a lot of souls from apparently going to hell...
Interestingly, the Beasts of creation on Island of DR Monroe learn that their GOD really is not a GOD at all.. They learn that "FEAR" and "FEAR MONGERING" of the HOUSE OF PAIN (HELL) Was purely a means to Control the Beasts (People)..
The Island of Dr Monroe is an example of science and religion gone wrong when used for power, control, and personal ambitions..
7:4 For yet seven days, and I will cause it to rain upon the earth forty days and forty nights; and every living substance that I have made will I destroy from off the face of the earth.
Has to do with ecological risk.. It has an interesting false merit play on the subject but doesn't necessarily pertain to the subject.. Ecological Risk has little to do with threats of genocide.. I could threaten to wipe out Bolder Gate by blowing up the hoover damn.. It can be considered and Ecological risk but yet done with intent... Those verses do not reflect Ecological Risks because the are not "Warnings".. The context is in clear premeditated threats with motive... To say you hate something and then to destroy it does not equate to Ecological Risk..
How about Favoritism that lead to Cain Slewing his Brother.. two immoral acts in one story.. And god didn't even understand why Cain was Wroth? He had to ask even after obviously disrespecting him in favor for his brothers when he could simply have taken both offering with equal respect... Abel may have not been slewed..Ouch
4:3 And in process of time it came to pass, that Cain brought of the fruit of the ground an offering unto the LORD.
4:4 And Abel, he also brought of the firstlings of his flock and of the fat thereof. And the LORD had respect unto Abel and to his offering:
4:6 And the LORD said unto Cain, Why art thou wroth? and why is thy countenance fallen?
4:7 If thou doest well, shalt thou not be accepted? and if thou doest not well, sin lieth at the door. And unto thee shall be his desire, and thou shalt rule over him.
4:8 And Cain talked with Abel his brother: and it came to pass, when they were in the field, that Cain rose up against Abel his brother, and slew him
Lamech kills a man and claims that since Cain's murderer would be punished sevenfold, whoever murders him will be punished seventy-seven fold.. 4:23-24
So before you Start Casting your Stones of Damnation I suggest you look into your own Ideologies Immoral, hateful, disrespectful, and extremist views... The immorality and hypocrisy is just Sheerly Astounding in this ideology.. And then you wonder why they are out there to ban and spread their fear and hate upon what they view as an immorality...
When does it become a hypocrisy.. If you are true believer then you follow the above immoral concepts and justifiable... You become no better than the Evil you protest..
I don't know about you.. But I can't follow an ideology this immoral, this filled with hate, this "GOD" that hates you so much that he will even kill your Dog too!
I can see a few anti choicers and supposed religiously ethical people showing their callousness for themselves by saying this murder is a 201st trimester abortion!
You aren't giving into faith..or life ...You are entering into un-healthy thought.
ABANDON ALL HOPE YEE WHO ENTER, is your mantra, not, "Do unto others as you would have them do unto you." Your idea isn't "help a person" as Jesus said, it is:
"Punish the wrong doer! ANY wrong doer...EVERY WRONGDOER! FIND THE WRONG DOER!!!! There HAS TO BE A WRONG DOER around here TO PUNISH!!"
Remember, You are assuming the Bible and Genesis to be a FACT and not Fiction based on Faith alone when in fact it is a self admitted book written by man himself and not by a "GOD"... That would logically conclude that the Bible is a human ideological construct around the idea or belief in a god..
This does not mean there is no GOD... That will always remain an unprovable.... Just don't go around claiming the bible is a book of Facts when it clearly is not..
For example:
Many Religious people claim god is Unconditional love that possesses infinite and ultimate Knowledge.. And yet the bible shows repeatedly that GOD even Admits to making mistakes.. Such as creating man to the point of committing world genocide on every living thing...
Or the fact he even has to ask Cain why is wroth after obviously showing no respect for him over his brother... These are human and mortal traits you would not expect to find in an all Knowing supernatural being supposedly not capable of making mistakes... Even I know the correct and logical answer was to show respect to both Able and Cain for what they offered..
Another problem is why is Cain and Able making offerings to a GOD? Is god this egotistical or self righteous that he demands to be worshiped? ... I could literally go on for days about how illogical most of the bible really is...
Most people that read the bible and believe it fail to do any critical thinking what so ever on the material and literature...
What's next.. Pro-lifers making sex laws to enforce their ideology? Prevent people from even talking to each other? Sounds like a Religious Police State in the making...
The pro-lifers don't really even need to make sex laws. Fornication is technically still illegal in most states as a misdemeanor offense, even though it is not enforced. Some states have struck down or are beginning to strike down laws preventing casual sex.
No person that is pro-life has condoned the murder of this murdering doctor. I feel sorry for him and his family. I hope that God has mercy on his soul for the hundreds maybe thousands of murder's he has committed over his lifetime. We pro-life people respect the dignity of all life, unlike you pro-choice people. You believe people should have the choice to murder if they want to, so you should agree with the man who murdered this doctor. Alot of families want to adopt, give the baby to them don't KILL it!! Read the statistics, majority of late term abortions are done on healthy babies! Even if it's going to be handicap is that a reason to kill it? Doesn't it's life have any value? I don't know of too many handicap people out there committing crimes, assulting, murdering, stealing, do you? Seems its us healthy people doing all the bad stuff!
You do not know if that is true.. You only know that no pro-lifer on this site has not condoned this course of action... You fail to realize the differences between those of Personal Opinion, Radicals, and Extremists on the subject... To say no Pro-Lifer condones this course of action is entirely false..
Don't you love how the spout about everyones right to live then this happens? Everyone deserves to live EXCEPT this guy right? When I get to hell for being a pro-choicer I'll save you hypocrites a seat. Try notbeing so self righteous. It must be exhausting.
hey, the low down TRUTH ... you play with FIRE, you will get BURNED...BEWARE: dangerous territory...choose to help people, rather than destroy them..subtle terrorism is for real !! population control is for real..real times, real choices, please think EVERYTHING OUT real hard okay........
omg!! there has been far more killed by liberal left wing environmentalist .unabomber ring a bell hows about obama's good friend ayers. murder is murder be it abortion doctor or a timber industry lobbyist etc. you people are insane get help before you do the same thing these nuts do.Republican and Democrats parties are nothing more than cults.
Natasha you also have to look at the fact that most Religious Pro-Lifers live by a book filled with absolute hypocrisy.. It's is why the Bible and Especially Christians are considered by most to be hypocrites without any attempt to think anything through with logical thinking... Pro-lifers wouldn't realize how anti-life that concept was until man Raped Earth down to it's Molten Core... In fact if they were the last man standing they would probably still not realize how idiotic they are.. This is why religious ideologies are so dangerous... It literally makes people stupid and easily controlled...
Pro-Life is a noble thing.. But Pro-life also means being smart enough to maintain a sustainable population.. Otherwise your whole concept collapses on its self and then you end up killing everyone if not everything...
It is even proven that over crowding infuses violence... Put a large number of people in a small room long enough they will kill eachother.. Make them fight for resources and it would become a massacre.. Same thing with Rats or any animal.. Eventually Extiction soon follows...
Imagine The United States with 2 billion people... Imagine the Trash and polution that would cause.. Hell imagine what would happen to the natural wild life.. America would get stripped bare... Disease and violence would rise.. more people would die vs just simply controlling the population and allowing things like abortions....
In fact making abortion illegal would directly result in huge increases in crime, murder, rape, theft ectra by the sheer increase of rejected children who would thus join or even create gangs... Or simply go on a murderous rampage.... Basically you are creating a baby market to large for even those who can not have babies.. You are creation a Huge propblem that No agency on Earth could ever dream of handling... Those cracks become gaping wholes where children become life long victims of your Stupidity..
You should really read posts before you start ranting at people. I posted a verse (in response to someone's request for documentation of my assertions) indicating that fetuses aren't living creatures until they have the breath of life within them and you attack me as if I was some right-wing pro-life zealot condoning the murder and terrorist action that was perpetrated today...WTF?!? Get a clue, lay of the booze, take your meds (or whatever you need to do to get your drawers out of the bunch they're in) and RELAX!
I was only trying to add to the post vs objecting to it :P... I wasn't directly responding to you.. So I guess it was pointless to do so :/... I also didn't suggest you were "a right winger" Most of that post had to do with other people and not you... WHen I said "you also have to look at" did not imply that You are involved in anything that I had discussed.... Nothing there was an attack on you... So relax :)
Wow, these comments by people like NBBSBC82, Conservatismworks, Michael-1127073, Carlos-1031503, me-321567 and JB-784265 demonstrate just how unbalanced and unhinged these radicals truly are. They believe in God yet they condone murder in a place of worship???? Since you guys are so "pro-life" I was just wondering how many children have you adopted to help with the problem of children who have no family or home?
"I refer all you right wingers who want to force your religion on everyone (ever heard of "separation of Church and State"?) back to post #1.33 and challenge you to dispute what's said.
Any takers?"
GOD! gives life and takes it away. We will all answer for what we have done someday. I for one will NEVER VOTE THAT IT IS OK TO KILL AN INOCENT LIFE!
And on the very first word you once again want to force your religion on people. And as one person stated on this thread, the religious nuts don't object much to the killing of a doctor in the church in which he worshipped!
Try again. Read post #1.33, then try to refute it...
Sorry, I assumed that since you had my name at the top of your post in bold font that your post was directed towards me. My bad. No harm, no foul. I would like to add that you do raise some valid points, most of which are attributable to the role of religion as a tool of statecraft and the fact that people actually wrote the bible rather than some dvine personage. Have a good day, and look luck in your desire to educate the misguided herd creatures who are our brethren.
Not sure where this will end up, but I agree with Mr. Rogers, and note that once again low browed, ignoble people respond out of their diminished capacity to understand these issues.
Abortion supporters like to use the term "pro-choice" when referring to abortion, a system whereby one group of individuals decides if another group of individuals will live or die. But how can abortion principles sensibly be called "pro-choice" when those who do the killing make all the choices and those who do the dying get no choices? This is tantamount to calling the Jewish Holocaust a "pro-choice" exercise. After all, that's what it was for the Germans.
Because Rhonda we don't live in a perfect world.. That choice could mean saving the child from a life far worse than the death its self.. I really don't think you are grasping the magnitude this would cause in society... It's basically building a massive refugee camp of rejected children.. Nearly 50% of rejected children commit suicide or get involved in criminal activity... You would also thus be injecting 10's of thousands of rejects into an already broken system unable to handle the current flow of rejected children or orphans...
Several reviews have been conducted over the years and in all cases said agencies couldn't even find the children they were taking care of..Even when they were in their own facilities.. 300 children in the last 5 years have been sold on illegal baby markets... 45 children had been sold to slavery... 20% have been placed in abusive homes... Nearly,10- 30% commit suicide...
And who is going to pay for all of this Rhonda? If you are going to force labor you should thus be responsible for paying for it.. And that includes the child care, medical, education to insure a stable life in a secure home... I don't think that is a realistic option here... You are talking about taking 1 immoral act and creating 1 massive immoral problem...
And who is going to pay for all of this Rhonda? If you are going to force labor you should thus be responsible for paying for it.. And that includes the child care, medical, education to insure a stable life in a secure home...
The irony is that most of the anti-abortion people tend to favor Republican politics, believing that the Republicans both support their church and oppose abortion, which undoubtedly means that they would oppose the taxes necessary to sustain all those unwanted children...
Terrorists do not get "rights". If they do it needs to be applied the same to the ones being held in GITMO. Terrorists are International and Domestic criminals and both need to be held to the same judicial process.
I cringe when I think that every time an doctor who performs abortions in a clinic is killed, we are one step closer to overturning Roe v. Wade. It's a woman's right to terminate a pregnancy. It's even more so when the child wouldn't be viable and it would only suffer (or die immediately after birth). Do people not think?
Sounds nicer that way doesn't it. Kind of like canceling a credit card....
It's even more so when the child wouldn't be viable and it would only suffer (or die immediately after birth). Do people not think?
Right... because doctors are always so right. Case in point. A couple friend of ours was told that if they allowed their pregnancy to continue the baby would 100% for certain die and the mother would 70% die. The relied on their faith and decided to keep the baby. During the pregnancy, they said the baby was developing down syndrome, deformities in the arms and legs, yet they went on with the pregnancy.
There baby is now 18 months old and is 100% healthy without ANY of the conditions. Oh, the mom is doing fine as well.
Now, I would have respected their choice to not follow through because who can judge people that have to make such difficult decisions. That being said, it was a wonderful experience to see their faith pay and to witness a child most people would have never let be born.
Mr. Rogers: since you are such an asinine right-winger, let me set you straight:
I wrote: It's a woman's right to terminate a pregnancy.
You wrote: Sounds nicer that way doesn't it. Kind of like canceling a credit card....
You are entirely too insane if you think that folks who decide to terminate a pregnancy make such decisions without weighing every consequence. You make it sound as if folks who have to undergo such procedures due to necessity are evil--I find it evil that you seem to think you have a right to judge them. Or me, for that matter, for my beliefs. I do not advocate using pregnancy as birth control--but I do find that a safe, legal abortion is a right women have--and until Roe v. Wade is overturned, that's a fact. So deal with it and stop judging others.
I wrote: It's even more so when the child wouldn't be viable and it would only suffer (or die immediately after birth). Do people not think?
You wrote: Right... because doctors are always so right.
No, doctors aren't always right--but the odds are the odds. Your friends have a healthy baby--I'm happy for them and that's their choice. But so many other parents have to terminate pregnancies because they're developing in the wrong area, thus endagering the woman, the child is deformed or otherwise not well-developed, and you think you have a right to judge those people, let alone doctors?
When you get a medical degree, and decide to help couples and their pregnancies, you can talk. In the meantime, you're just a wacko right-winger who thinks everyone is entitled to your idiot opinion.
And let me tell you something--opinions are like arseholes--everybody's got one. However, I hate to tell you: it just doesn't mean everyone is entitled to yours. So, shove it. And a criminal act like murder is still a crime. It's not justified. And somehow I picture you, and I see someone who lives in the fringes of society, willing to murder someone because you disagree with what they do? You're a wack job alright.
Good point! The doctors are very often wrong. The horror stories are many. Let's face it. We have gotten to the point where we don't want to decide for ourselves. If you knew what I know about doctors, you wouldn't be so inclined to worship them.
who ever did this should be tried in court by a jury of his/her peers, as called for by the Constitution of the United States. No different than any other person who commits murder.
A good post and thoughtful. You give us an example of a problem that happened to turn out well of, but what if it had not? What if the baby was born without a brain or so severely impaired that it could never live without being on life support, perhaps for decades? Of course, this is hypothetical, never the less this happens more often than not.
In olden times Doctors or mid wives would take the still born or severely impaired and kill them because they knew that this child would become a severe handicap to the survival of the family or to the mother. Abortion is not some latter day problem at all. But, it has taken on a religious and political face because of the openness of the issue.
To those who oppose abortion for religious reasons hear the words of Jesus as He replied to the question of whether or not it was lawful to pay the Roman tax, "Give unto Caesar that which is Caesar's, and unto God that which is God's." You are in this world but not of this world. Let the world lookout for itself and work out your own salvation. None of us are above judgement. All things in due time.
In this country abortion is legal. If you are opposed to it, don't do it. You do not have the right to tell another what to do. It is their choice and they will answer for their choice. You can not gain "favor" with God by doing what YOU think He wants you to do. Read your Bible. It's there for YOUR salvation, not for you to "earn" your way into his good grace.
"Nutters". No one likes abortion even prochoice. It is a terriable thing to do but I guess some think they know better..the same ones never forced to make a choice...the same ones that called preggo teens a "tragedy" until Palin's unwed, minor daughter had one.
lkessler.... "And let me tell you something--opinions are like arseholes--everybody's got one. However, I hate to tell you: it just doesn't mean everyone is entitled to yours. ... You're a wack job alright."
Unfortunately, I live in the city where they just arrested this psycho. His name is Scott Roeder. He's been a sicko for quite a while.....
Here's some other info on him:
July 7, Kansas: Scott Roeder is sentenced to sixteen months in state prison for parole violations following a 1996 conviction for having bomb components in his car trunk. Roeder, a sovereign citizen and tax protester, violated his parole by not filing tax returns or providing his social security number to his employer.
Because Newt and Rush told him to do it? You are as Extreme as the person that Murdered this Doctor.. its Extremism on both sides that is the problem in this country
Environmentalist left winger nuts and Liberal commie nuts have killed far more than the right to life nuts
Una bomber ring a bell hows about Obamas buddy William ayers? ETC! So should all left wingers who believe in the same things as them be considered terrorist ?Democrat and Republican parties have turned into dangerous cults.Get help before you end up doing the same thing as these nuts.
The human race, for some odd reason, follows politicos like cattle to a cow bell. Once we all stop making everyone's personal business our own business and keep our own back yards clean we'll experience a much more peaceful world.
The politicos keep kicking these types of issues around because they can get you to vote based on their positions. Quit trying to legislate other people's lives to fit your idea of how life should be. Walk away from this way of thinking and living.
This shooter was so enraged by ideologies and believed that somehow 'the system' would make everyone behave, in the way he wanted, that when that didn't happen he shot this guy.
Leave each other alone people. Let these issues die. Sheesh. Don't react to everything you read in the papers, on the internet, on the news. The information barrage has led us to believe that our own opinion matters on every single issue. They don't matter. In fact they can lead to violence. Get a life of your own and stay out of others' lives.
Let's all hope the individual acted alone. America is a Country of laws that have been developed over our existence. This act was clearly murder in the eyes of the law. Abortion is not murder in the eyes of the law. If you disagree change the laws, but until you do it is murder.
your right Lkessler doctors aren't always right. In fact they are rarely correct but because they went to a liberal college they can say and do what they want and have no accountability.
Try to look up the complaints against a given doctor by patients. Even in the lawfirm were I work we cant even get that kind of information.
I know of two different individuals that should be blind. In fact the doctors told both of them they would be blind. Both recovered fully.
I too have a friend that was told that his wife was going to die after the baby was born in an emergency C section. 5% chance of survival and they intended on letting her die and told him to say goodbye. He chose an alternate action and she is alive and in perfect health. I have had at least two other friends that have recieved great results on their physical, cardiac exams, ect... Both died shortly after leaving the doctors office. Apparently its normal to be healthy and just up and die.
The odds are just numbers some clown generated in a simulated computer program. I have seen doctors wrong more times than right on their assessments of patients. Those odds are posted nowhere. Your opinion is basically worth no value. Quit the name calling.
The doctor is no better than the murderer. For those that like to justify these acts in a religious forum I believe the fact that one of the ten commandments, "thou shalt not kill makes the point quite clear." Doesn't say get knocked up and its okay, doesn't say if it will be difficult to raise a child, doesn't say if you chooose not to carry someone elses child that you don't love. It says thou shalt not kill. This guy was mocking the church by even attending. Personally I think its great that someone has the guts to stand up for what they believe in.
I look at it this way, yes it is a tragedy but Tiller "The Baby Killer" as he was oftenly referred to will now face his creator much faster. It is with God that his judgement now lies and may will view this as justice, all be it, twisted justice!
I think this is not the time to be arguing pro-choice/pro-life issues. A man was shot down in cold blood. I am pro-life, and so that makes me very sad. How ironic that the murderer committed the very act of ending a life, that he claims to be wrong. My sympathy to the family and friends of this victim.
It's a shame those people who claim to worship Jesus can be so judgmental and full of hate to gun someone down at church. How would they like us gunning them down because they think differently than most? What the hell is wrong with these people?
What this animal did is wrong. He should have let God deal with him in due time. This doctor is now dealing with God on the dispicable murders he inflicted on so many helpless babies in their mothers womb. May he be repentant...
"Tiller .....said the issue was about giving women a choice when dealing with technology that can diagnose severe fetal abnormalities before a baby is born."
Sounds very altruistic, except that the article failed to mention that Tiller's reputation was not of terminating "severe fetal abnormalities", but terminating healthy, full term abortions using the Partial Birth procedure, wherein a healthy baby's head is delivered, then the baby is killed by the doctor, and then the rest of the baby (now dead) is delivered. He would apparently perform this procedure on anyone for a fee, without regard for the "health of the mother" or any supposed "fetal abnormalities".
I can't condone what happened to him, but .........
It is with deepest sympathy that I express my condolences to the family and friends of Dr. Tiller. I was introduced to Dr. Tiller in October of 2005 when I had found out that the baby that I was carrying would be born with congenital defects that no medicine or surgery could correct. It was a life changing experience that I will take with me to the end. He saved me, my family, and by unborn fetus a life of agony, anguish, and hardship. It was the most difficult decision I had to make. In addition to myself being at the clinic, there were other women there; not to abort a child that was healthy, but a fetus that was grossly deformed or sick. I would never wish the heartache I had to go through on an enemy but wish that they could catch a glimpse of what it feels like to have to make the decision that I made. There were thousands of letters of gratitude to Dr. Tiller posted throughout the clinic. Dr. Tiller was a professional, sincere, and caring physician that came highly recommended from renowned genetic doctors that I spent countless hours with trying to negotiate the results to painful testing that I endured only to find out the inevitable. There is no reason for a woman to continue a pregnancy that could endanger her life or the life of her unborn fetus. The world has evolved enough to know that women are entitled to make these choices on their own without the added burden of the world coming down on them. Instead of investing all the time it takes to protest, why not take the time to volunteer and counsel women that have had to go through the nightmare of losing a baby or take the time to volunteer and help the children that are abused or the vulnerable that cannot speak for themselves and have been taken advantage of by family members. Why not focus your negative energy on the selfless acts of "church-going" citizens that impregnate their 12 year old nieces or daughters. Choose the battle that is worth fighting, don't make the lives of people that have lived through this experience worse than what it was. I drove 60 straight hours from Toronto, Ontario, Canada to meet Dr. Tiller and don't regret any second of it. I sympathize deeply with the clients scheduled to meet with Dr. Tiller in the future, because he is the only one that was willing to help the people that nobody else would. Something that has stuck with me since meeting Dr. Tiller was that he said "pregnancy doesn't begin with a positive test, it begins with the first thought that you want to have a baby". It couldn't have been a more honest and sincere quote; we had been trying for some time to get pregnant, only to have to give the baby up. What about the staff at the clinic who have to worry about their own fate each day, what about their livelihoods? Are those protestors going to take in those families because they no longer have a job to go to? Pro-life? Isn't that what Dr. Tiller was doing? Grow up.
We still do not know the reason why George Tiller was killed. Nevertheless, the pro-life movement does not favor the killing for any reason! We seek the conversion and not the killing of those whom we hope and pray will be won over by our love and by the love of Jesus as has happened with many former abortion providers and pro-abortionists like Dr. Bernard Nathanson (co-founder of NARAL) and Norma McCorvey (the "Jane Roe" of Roe vs. Wade). For a few examples, see: http://prolifeaction.org/providers/
We as pro-lifers believe that God does not desire the death of the sinner, but that he repent and live (Ezekiel 18:32; 33:11)
We do not fight violence with violence or murder with murder. We are committed to fighting the culture of death through prayer and through education. That has been the constant message of pro-lifer leaders and advocates for decades.
It is wrong for people who oppose pro-lifers to use this as an opportunity to accuse us with the false sweeping generalization that "pro-lifers" are violence. It is a well documented fact that "pro-choicers" commit more acts of violence compared to pro-lifers. http://abortionviolence.com/
Finally, I will keep George Tiller and his family in my thoughts and prayers. My heart is saddened for them as they face this tragedy. May they find joy and peace in the love and forgiveness of our Blessed Lord and Savior Christ Jesus.
This is not an issue of Politics certainly not all Democrats are pro choice and not all Republicans are Pro life. And Murder is wrong and I think everyone here would agree. But, this was a terrible man who did very late term abortions nearly full term pregnancies. I would think the most people would also agree that is wrong also! I am a pro choice person. But I do not think a full term babies should be aborted to me that is murder.
hurrah for the shooter. Hope the dr has a special seat in hell for all the babies he killed.
Hmmm...How Christian of you. Rather than judge him, some who felt he was taking lives would be saddened that his life was taken prematurely... by another human being, who put himself in the place of judgement. How do you know the plans God had for him?
I think the killer should be prosecuted and sent to jail just like any other murderer. I don't believe the government should kill citizens so prison would be my choice. I can't speak for God on any of the important issues, I am not so sure anyone can.
Roy Wilson - most of your post is wrong - late term abortions are illegal without specific medical reasons, so he was not performing them for anyone and everyone who could pay.
I'll bet this seed (and ones on the same topic) will get the most action of any seed this year.
That being said, I am glad to know that Tiller, the serial killer, has been brought to vigilante justice. Yes, the shooter will be tried, likely convicted and punished, but that is because of a "choice" he made. I'm reasonably certain that he weighed the consequences and still chose to abort Tiller's life.
What comes around, goes around. Perhaps this will serve as a deterrent for med students who are wondering if they should provide abortions.
Those of you who think abortion is legal are right, it IS legal. However, it being legal does in no way make killing babies 'right'.
A major question I have is how Tillman has kids and grandkids since his whole livelyhood was based on killing babies. I know if I'd been his child I'd have kept my bedroom door lock, bolted and braced!!!
Actually the killer, no doubt a Christian, was just doing what a good Christian is instructed to do by their leader, a terrorist named Jesus. The bible is in fact a nasty, evil, barbaric work of pure fiction conjured up by a bunch of superstitious bronze-age tribesmen.
Now before anyone objects to this I have proof, sourced from the bible noted below:
If ANYONE can deny the words mentioned below as not being truthful then please have at ‘er. Some of the material comes from the old testament which Jesus fully supported and here is proof of that:
Matthew 5:17" Do not think that I have come to abolish the law or the prophets. I have come not to abolish but to fulfill. Amen, I say to you, until heaven and earth pass away, not the smallest part or the smallest part of a letter will pass from the law, until all things have taken place."
Now that I have that out of the way, people always say “what would Jesus do?” Let's take a look shall we?
Punishment for disrespecting ones parents:
Matthew 15:4 Because God said, 'Honor your father and your mother,' and 'Whoever curses father or mother must certainly be put to death.'
Punishment for working on Sunday:
Exodus 31:15'For six days work may be done, but on the seventh day there is a sabbath of complete rest, holy to the LORD; whoever does any work on the sabbath day shall surely be put to death.
Punishment for those who are the enemy of Jesus:
Luke 19:27 But as for these enemies of mine who did not want me to be king over them—bring them here and slaughter them in my presence (spoken by Jesus).
What to do with young women who have been raped:
Deuteronomy 22:28-29 “If a man is caught in the act of raping a young woman who is not engaged, he must pay fifty pieces of silver to her father. Then he must marry the young woman because he violated her, and he will never be allowed to divorce her.”
Jesus teachings regarding slaves:
Luke 12:47 "And that slave who knew his master's will and did not get ready or act in accord with his will, will receive many lashes”
hey, you play with FIRE, you get BURNED..just thank God, you never became a victim of these atrocities...the sensible solution to all this is; EDUCATION and PREVENTION..it should be remedial in early education, and more progressive as years go by..please, if humanity is smart about this dilemma, we would not have to end up so brutal and unsophisticated about all this..
Violence begets violence. The shooter is a murderer and so is the "doctor" How sad. And so is the fact that in this day and age of hard core sexuality on the tube and sex ed in school, yet abortion and teen pregnancies still continue
I've seen the results of late-term abortions, college students at my old high school would protest with pictures of late-term abortion babies in front of the school cafeteria.
Our local news reported the man arrested has priors for possession of explosives, and said to have ties to some militia group. Where is Homeland Security when you need them? Oh yeah, frisking 80-year-old ladies in wheel chairs at the airport. (I actually have witnessed that twice.)
I remember noticing after 9-11 that our domestic abortion clinic evangelical bombers slowed or stopped the acts of terror. They're baaaaa-aaack. Jesus Camp 101
"Roy Wilson - most of your post is wrong - late term abortions are illegal without specific medical reasons, so he was not performing them for anyone and everyone who could pay."
Dr. Tiller had a reputation for being willing to perform late-term abortions for specious reasons - hence the trial against him.
I am willing to bet that some group that is against abortion is involved. What does it take, some minister to say this man should not live? I am sure that many have already said it to some one at some time. It took them three times, but they finally got him. Flat out premeditated murder!
I condone this behavior however lets talk about a baby that is over 5 months old and this man sucked their brains out so they would die........can we have that discussion or is it too sickening???????
Sam...very truthfully, you do not even deserve a reply, but as you have choose to take verses out of context, and misquote and misinterpret, I have this to say,
Concerning your statement, Matthew 5:17" Do not think that I have come to abolish the law or the prophets. I have come not to abolish but to fulfill. Amen, I say to you, until heaven and earth pass away, not the smallest part or the smallest part of a letter will pass from the law, until all things have taken place."
The law, is the ten commandments, one of which is "Thou shall not kill".
Concerning your out of context misquote, Matthew 15:4 Because God said, 'Honor your father and your mother,' and 'Whoever curses father or mother must certainly be put to death.'
The quote is, "For God commanded 'Honor your father and your mother,' and, 'He who speaks evil of father or mother, let him surely die'. But you say, 'If any one tells his father or his mother, What you would have gained from me is given to God, he need not honor his father.' So for the sake of your tradition, you have made void the word of God. You hypocrites! Well did Isaiah prophesy of you when he said; 'This people honors me with their lips, but their heart is far from me; in vain do they worship me, teaching as doctrines the precepts of men'" Matthew 15; 4-9 Speaking "evil" would be speaking lies, deception, dishonesty...and "let him surely die" refers to spiritual death that person would bring upon himself... not murder. The message Jesus was giving was the hypocrisy that "men's religious rules" sometimes carried within them...and in actuality, those rules (or traditions) were in direct conflict with God's Will and Law (the commandments) for His people.
Concerning your quote, Luke 19:27 But as for these enemies of mine who did not want me to be king over them—bring them here and slaughter them in my presence (spoken by Jesus).
That quote is the end of a parable, (a story used for instructing...to draw a comparison...used to teach a deeper moral or spiritual truth). Thus, it is open for interpretation...and not all Christians understand it to be showing the "nobleman" who speaks the words you quote (and whom is also refered to in the parable as, "a severe man, who take what you did not lay down, and reap what you did not sow"), to be representative of God. Some see this "nobleman", to be representative of those men/women in power, who exploit and mistreat those under their authority.
Concerning your misquote, Luke 12:47 "And that slave who knew his master's will and did not get ready or act in accord with his will, will receive many lashes”
The quote (which is also part of a parable spoken by Jesus), in further context is (Jesus said), "But if that servant says to himself, 'My master is delayed in coming,' and begins to beat the menservants and the maidservants, and to eat and drink and get drunk, the master of that servant will come on a day when he does not expect him and at an hour he does not know, and will punish him, and put him with the unfaithful. And that servant who knew his master's will, but did not make ready or act according to his will, shall recieve a severe beating." Luke 12; 45-47 It is related to the "we reap what we sow" teaching...sin brings suffering upon ourselves and sometimes others...that is due to our poor choices...and that is not God's Will for us.
Since Jesus came to reveal God's Truth, and you have chosen to attempt to attack and defame Him, I am only addressing your comments and scriptual quotes concerning His teachings. You should not open your mouth about things that you have no understanding of, and if you choose not to believe, you do not have to attempt to attack and offend those of us who do.
Yes Dave, they are talking about the late term abortion Doctor. The thing I find interesting is was he was a leader in his church. It just strikes me as odd he would even want to be a member of any organized religion. Most Churches don't believe in abortion, they consider it murder. I don't agree with what he did, just like I don't believe he should have been to be gunned down. That has always been an emotional debate between People who agree with it or not. I think it makes no since to kill someone that your upset with for killing. It's pretty two faced.
I can see were these stupid things go on with both sides you'll always have these morons that go to Soldiers funerals and hold up signs protesting them. They call them baby killers and rapist, it's just wrong and people need to realize just because you don't agree with someone It gives you one right to hurt them physically or mentally.
It's kind of like that Code Pink and how they act like a bunch of morons, I believe in freedom of speech but I don't believe they have a right to invade on a private ceremony. There are so many cicvil ways to show your disapproval.
Where do I begin? You are attempting to do what most Christians who follow this work of fiction are forced to do, reinterpret the teachings of Jesus, modify these instructions so as to make them appear less barbaric.
Let's start with your "let him surely die" ploy. According to the New American Bible the exact wording is: 'Whoever curses father or mother shall die.' But for the sake of fairness, fine, then we'll also take into consideration your version. I ask why would a loving God wish death on someone for simply disagreeing with their parents? Would any of us today wish death as punishment for their child's disobedience? And as for your “spiritual death” ploy, nice one, the only problem is that Matthew 15:4 is specific, it is about punishment according to the will of God – period.
Next in regards to your massively modified interpretation of Luke 19:27 again, the teachings of Jesus are specific here; he wants his enemies murdered in front of him. Deeper moral and spiritual truth?!? Your Arial font generated diarrhea is truly magnificent. You would have had better luck trying to peddle that when Jesus said slaughter he was really talking in code and that “slaughter” was really a secret code to instruct his followers to hand out Twinkies to his enemies.
As for Matthew 5:17 and the ten commandments, thanks for pointing out the fact that the bible is chock full of contradictions, in fact a page cannot be turned without one contradiction or another. The ten commandments; that even though #6 states “Thou shalt not kill, #4 condones the murder of those who would dare work on Sunday.
But most important, why would God, the creator of this Universe with 400+ billions stars & 200 sextillion planets chose one paperback book ($5 buys you the hardback version) as proof of his existence, his will and then (truly ridiculous) allow different versions with different wordings to exist? You would think the all powerful creator of the Universe, of stars, planets, galaxies etc. would be powerful enough to prevent this from happening.
As a solution, both Pro-life and Pro-choice are unsustainable. Both arguments, being temporal and also binary do not have basis in Truth with a capital "T". That is, depending on your point of view you can argue for either side and be both correct and wrong at the same time. Look at this sad example of Dr. Tiller's murder. A Pro-lifer took the life of a human while trying to defend his/her viewpoint on abortion. Tried to justify the taking of a life to save another life. Isn't he/she now just as guilty? Totally hypocritical and therefore unsustainable. Let's say we outlaw abortion, how will we handle an overcrowded Earth in a few centuries? Who will be chosen to die and who will live when the Earth's resources no longer support our biology? We need to STOP trying to legislate based on binary and temporal arguments and instead look toward the Eternal solutions. The religious should return to their roots where Jesus instructed us to "seek ye first the Kingdom of God." That is, the unarguable Truths which are Eternal. Kind of like the writings of our Constitution and our Bill of Rights. They are written in UNARGUABLE language and their Truths will hold (sustain) until the end of times. Also, the religious should try to remember that Jesus Christ triumphed over death. That is, if you really believe in Jesus Christ than death is not a problem, am I correct? Then we should just accept death within the reality of life as just another stage and forget about the timing. What we are really argueing here is the timing of death and not death in itself. Could it not be that soon to be aborted fetuses only come into this plane of existence in order to teach their parents something about life? And if so, who are we to negate the lesson? The parent(s), having learned their error from a prior abortion, wouldn't they be more receptive and caring of the gift of life in the future?
The righteous compassionate conservatives have raised their ugly heads again.
Why does this have to be about politics? Why must the leftist make this a right or left political statement.. This man was killed by someone who had a problem with him and what he did..
It is somewhat disturbing to me that the media is using the phrase "abortion doctor" as though that is all he did -- perform abortions. Don't know if this is true and his website doesn't seem to be working, but I suspect he was operating a full-service women's health clinic, in which case, not only has the killer stopped him performing abortions, but he has stopped him providing ANY healthcare to women.
In my opinion, I hope the FBI investigates every pro life group. And if they find evidence of wrong doing, file charges against them.
And what could we possiably charge these groups with? Some possiable charges could be, Accessory to Murder, Conspiracy, terrorism, Hate Crimes, these are a few suggestions and opinions.
It amazes me that you a lot of you assume that this person is a Christian or even claims to be. Attending church every Sunday doesn't make you a Christian anymore than sleeping in your garage makes you a car... And you quoting the Bible to me is like me picking up a text book on nuclear physics and trying to tell you what it is all about without reading, studying, or taking classes. So I would appreciate not showing your lack of understanding... And let’s talk about the percentage of women who make the "choice" to use abortion as "birth control", to terminate "kill" a perfectly healthy baby because it’s not convenient for their lifestyle...
It amazes me that you a lot of you assume that this person is a Christian or even claims to be. Attending church every Sunday doesn't make you a Christian anymore than sleeping in your garage makes you a car... And you quoting the Bible to me is like me picking up a text book on nuclear physics and trying to tell you what it is all about without reading, studying, or taking classes. So I would appreciate not showing your lack of understanding... And let’s talk about the percentage of women who make the "choice" to use abortion as "birth control", to terminate "kill" a perfectly healthy baby because it’s not convenient for their lifestyle...
What a fantastic Christian. Pro-life groups ought to be proud of the Frankenstein's monster they've helped to create. Of course they'll trip over themselves to put some distance between their fiery language and harrassment of people who disagree with them on an issue that depends less on evidence and fact than each person's internal belief system, but if violence can be blamed on secular video games, movies and TV (e.g. Columbine was Marilyn Manson's fault, etc.), then it seems appropriate to question whether the same standard should apply to right wing sources that deliberately use incendiary images and language to arouse passions. Not to say that they should be censored...just that the next time the holier than thou crowd whines about something stupid like Grand Theft Auto, they should have to answer for incidents like this.
Sam...your first quote in your comment #2.48, says
Matthew 15:4 Because God said, 'Honor your father and your mother,' and 'Whoever curses father or mother must certainly be put to death.'
Then in your second comment, you say...
Let's start with your "let him surely die" ploy. According to the New American Bible the exact wording is: 'Whoever curses father or mother shall die.'
"be put to death" and "shall die" can have very different meanings. My comment's quote of "let him surely die", seems closer to your corrected quote in your response posting of, "shall die", than your original "be put to death". And so, my point...translations are imperfect...we may not have the exact words in English to fully convey the original (language) message's full meaning. We look at the whole...not taking small verses out of context, as you attempt to. Also, when Jesus is telling a parable, He is giving a hidden message, that can have many interpretations and meanings for us, and He is "meeting people where they are at"...in other words, His teachings were put in the context of man's ability to comprehend and understand the message at their present time...within their culture and society of the time.
Regardless of what you choose to believe, and how you may attempt to twist scripture, or call Jesus "a terrorist" and an "assh#le"...the truth is, Jesus never killed anyone, but He gave life and healing to many.I think you are a coward to attempt to use this message board to manipulate and deceive others...and thus try to destroy faith in some reading this, who may not have ever read the scriptures or do not have understanding of the Bible and Jesus message.
What comes around, goes around. Perhaps this will serve as a deterrent for med students who are wondering if they should provide abortions.
Funny, here I was thinking maybe I need to go back to school so I can become an abortionist. Do you think I am afraid of being killed by some uneducated-should-have-been-aborted piece of excrement? I fear the loss of rights over my own body, as well as there not being enough doctors with character who will provide this medical procedure. Yep, medical procedure.
He acknowledged abortion was as socially divisive as slavery or prohibition but said the issue was about giving women a choice when dealing with technology that can diagnose severe fetal abnormalities before a baby is born.
The problem is of course, this is NOT what Tiller was doing. He would do late term abortions for any one coming to him. It was about the money
Obama said he was shocked at the killing and yet he would have prevented any aborted baby that had survived the abortion procedure even the most rudimentary care. Note, he was the only person in the Ill state house that voted that way. He says the same thing Clinton did, make it legal but rare, but this of course is nothing more than a pandering lie by a politician trying to have it both ways.
Hopefully the FCC is paying attention to years of hate speech spewed by Bill O'Reilly in relationship to the murder of Dr. Tiller. The FCC needs to wake up and protect consumers from fraud and abuse and take action against hate mongers like O'Reilly and Limbaugh. O'Reilly should be held accountabile for the murder that he inspired and promoted by his disgusting hate speech......and the FCC should be held accountable for refusing to take action to protect the public from hate speech that ultimately leads to terrorist acts.
The murder of this man at this place of worship is a horrible incident.
I would also like to comment that I am against abortion and only believe in peaceful non-violent observance. An eye for an eye is not the way of GOD. Two wrongs, do not make a right.
I will pray for the Doctor, his family and the shooter. GOD BLESS AMERICA and help us return to your ways and teaching.
don't know if I would call the murderer a terrorist, but he committed first degree murder and should be locked up for life without parole.
With respect to all you picketers out there - YOU DO ABSOLUTELY NOTHING to change anyone's opinion on abortion.
All you do is HARRASS which is illegal too.
To let you know, ROE V WADE WILL NEVER BE OVERTURNED because of me and others like me to believe that the only person who can make a decision on what to with their body IS THAT PERSON and THAT PERSON ALONE.
Karen, AMEN! I agree with you 100% on this in that each person should be able to make decisions concerning their own body.
What if, on this particular Sunday, this Doctor had gone to church to "change his ways" and stop abortions and ask God for forgiveness, but died knowing he wasn't able to clear his conscience?
Who in the world are we to judge the others? Fine if we want to have opinions, but we don't go around killing people. Period.
A murderer kills 1 or 2 people, many times a specific person. A terrorist kills as many as he can randomly.
A murderer still gets due process. Terrorists should not get due process because they are usually not citizens or resident aliens and because they are a threat to all in society.
It is important for you to get your facts straight and not react emotianally, because our Republic is diminished by a lack of logic and common sense.
Treated as a terrorist? Are you kidding me? Do you people say that every murderer should be treated as a terrorist, or only the ones who kill abortion doctors? I don't condone murder in any situation, and his killer should be prosecuted for his crime, but this doctor was a baby killer, plain and simple. He didn't just perform abortions, he killed as many as he could possibly get his hands on....or scalpel/vacuum/forceps in. If anyone was a terrorist, it was Butcher Tiller. Gimme a break.
Just a reminder that it's not about a specific religion, but it's about fundamentalist extremist. Be it Islamic or Christian, our society has no room for these extremists.
The full extent of the law should be applied against these domestic terrorists, just as much as we go after the Taliban.
There's no difference between these so-called "Christian" fundamentalist and those Islamic extremist with strapped on bombs. They are both equally a threat to our American-way of life and our Constitution.
The problem of course, is religion to begin with, but that's a whole new argument.
I didn't see anyone mention the babies rights? The ones that he killed daily. I'm shocked that no one considers that an act of violence. Murder is wrong in any situation, whether is be shooting someone over something you disagree with or taking the life of children; yes, they are alive in the womb....don't forget. Women's rights start with the decision to not concieve if they don't want to deal with all possibilities.
I see all these comments trying to spin this situation one way or the other and just have to wonder. It looks like this killer was a confirmed nut case and his actions are about as meaningful and responsible as you normally see with such a person and only other equally moronic types will try to divine some meaning to his actions.
The miracle here is that Tiller lived as long as he did. Continuing his practice of late term abortions instead of sticking to normal OB/GYN after what had happened in the past is testimony to his own lack of touch with reality...sort of the same mentality as those who seek restraining orders against nutcases and expect to be protected. The thing to be thankful for is that no one else will die as a result of their proximity or association with Tiller...other than this killer who took him down. Let's hope that Kansas has a death penalty and that the ACLU doesn't get him off as insane or underprivileged or get to drag out his execution like they do for all these other losers. Maybe they'll make an exception and back off their own nutcase behavior in view of the fact that this guy took down one of their heroes. Even the darkest cloud can have a silver lining.
Cincinnati Rick, if you can find ANYTHING EVEN THE SLIGHTEST TO BE THANKFUL IN THIS, means there is a fine line between you and this murderer. No matter how anyone feels about abortion, THERE IS NOTING POSITIVE IN ANY WAY, IN THE FARTHEST STRETCH OF THE MOST WARPED IMAGINATION, that can be found in this. if you feel the slightest movement towards that, you should search your own soul.
Hope (Msg. #2.27), that is the most broadly intelligent commentary I think I've ever read on "Newsvine". You give me "hope" for the human race (admittedly, it's a limited hope, given the other 89 posts on this particular thread).
I'm just curious about something. If it's every woman's right to choose whether or not she has an abortion then why is it that men don't have a choice in these matters? If a woman chooses to have a child then the male responsible for making that child with her just has to grin and bear it, so to speak. If a woman has the right then a man should have the right as well to choose whether or not his child is born. With that being said, each "right" is wrong. You can't have your cake and eat it too. This is a huge double standard and it's ridiculous that we even discuss it. The man who shot the doctor needs to be prosecuted and punished. Murder is murder, whether it's commited by a gunman or a doctor claiming to be offering "health services". Doesn't sound too healthy for the unborn child.
By the way, Mr Rogers, I completely agree with you.
Sorry Ron but I have no dog in this fight. I am not anti-abortion. But I do condone the right of those who are to stop it by whatever legal means. And I do understand but not condone that when legal means are not available some will seek vigilante means.
What Tiller was doing knowingly endangered himself and everyone around him. That's his own prerogative where his own safety is concerned but not others. All too often these situations end up with innocent bystanders being killed as well and if you can't be happy that did not occur here, then it is you that has a problem.
That said, we need to put the mad dog down. And hopefully the people who usually obstruct justice will be too tied up in their political correctness to intervene this time. And that would also be something to be grateful for...even if their failure to intervene is for the wrong reasons.
I've read enough of these posts to come to the conclusion that most of the people here are morons. First of all...the real crux of the argument here is when does life actually begin? When is it "murder"? Science has yet to prove this point. Whilst a baby is attached to the mother via an umbilical cord and a placenta, it is in fact, by definition, a parasite. Yes, a parasite. It cannot live without the host. Here is the definition for those who would disagree: "Biology. An organism that grows, feeds, and is sheltered on or in a different organism while contributing nothing to the survival of its host." Aborions are illegal past the point of viability;when the fetus would be able to maintain life on it's own without the host. It is and should remain a woman's right to decide to deliver a baby. Society should have no say on this choice. Now, after the fetus is delivered, then societies laws and conventions do apply. The fetus is now an individual. Dr. Tiller went to trial not because he was performing late term abortions, but because it was thought that he was seeking the mandatory second opinion from another doctor that was an employee of his. A second opinion needs to be obtained by another separate doctor before a late term abortion can be performed. Dr. Tiller was acquitted of these charges. My history...I am a Christian and proud of my faith. I have had two abortions, one when I was young and used poor judgement and the other was a late term abortion when I was married. The fetus was found to be deformed due to X0 syndrome and the chromosomal tests confirmed the case. I chose not to go through with the pregnancy and terminated late. Do I have any regrets or guilt feelings? Not one. It was my choice. When I went to the clinic to have my abortion, I was harassed by protesters, none of whom took me up on my offer to give the fetus to them if they wanted me to go full term...I went on to have four wonderful, healthy children. Dr. Tiller was not a murderer. The person that killed him is. Dr. Tiller probably brought much relief and compassion into the lives of the women and families he helped during a difficult time. The murderer of Dr. Tiller just set back women's rights...
Hope (Msg. #2.27), that is the most broadly intelligent commentary I think I've ever read on "Newsvine". You give me "hope" for the human race (admittedly, it's a limited hope, given the other 89 posts on this particular thread).
Thanks alot oldefarte. Knowing you're out there gives me some hope too. At least there's a couple of people who can think independently of the rabble and dust clouds. I can't help but wonder what's going on behind the scenes when everyone's attention is captured by these 'events.' There are critical things going down and most of us are looking the wrong way.
I personally disagree with abortions, would never seek one. At the same time, I'm not qualified as a meager human being to force another to give birth, and raise their child. After all, all they did was have sex. Birth Control is not 100%.
I have always felt that those who take pro-life to an extreme, have as much of a problem with the act of casual sex, as they do "protecting" the unborn potential life.
Roe v Wade prevented 45- 50,000,000 unwanted births.
That's a powerful fact. To some, "50 million" is the keyword. To me, the keyword is "unwanted".
We get all riled up complaining about the "costs" of 10 million "unwanted" Mexicans (who work their collective arses off) in America. Do the math, what would we do with those 50,000,000 who weren't even wanted by their mother?
If you don't like what Howard Stern says, change the channel. If you are against abortions, don't get one. Isn't life that simple?
First of all it's not pro-life it's ANTI-CHOICE. These people often believe in the death penalty which is actually pro-death.
I myself could say I'm pro-life. I'm all for living, it's pretty great sometimes. I'm all for each individual enjoying their own life. But I would never want to lose or to take away the right to have an abortion to anyone. I would never want anyone to lose their power of free will (to make educated decisions) or for the government to have the power to control our bodies. So I'm a pro-life, pro-choicer. (just try to expand your definitions here, there can't ever be one right answer)
Secondly who is breaking in to medical dumps, digging through biological waste, finding aborted fetuses and taking pictures of them for anti-choice protests? Not a sane person. The kind of person who would bomb a women’s health clinic were there’s a good chance living babies may be present. So killing people is supposed to prove that killing people is wrong? How does that make any sense? (even if you’ve been digging through body parts and used needles all night this can’t be logical)
Taking away the option of abortion for everyone for any reason is taking away a woman’s right to make her own decisions. If you don't trust that women can make educated decisions why are you letting them vote?
Take away women’s reproductive rights and soon we'll be taking away all women’s rights. And why stop there who else can't we trust to think for themselves? Who doesn't deserve to be in control of their lives?
It's a kick in the pants to see so many women supporting the anti-choice movement. Are you going to vote for burquas next?
1 Corinthians 11:6 (New International Version)
6If a woman does not cover her head, she should have her hair cut off; and if it is a disgrace for a woman to have her hair cut or shaved off, she should cover her head.
If you're going to quote the bible to back your opinions up you should at lest follow the whole thing. So why aren't you good God fearing women wearing headscarves?
women should remain silent in the churches. They are not allowed to speak, but must be in submission, as the Law says.
So ladies follow the good book and remain in submission. After all you aren't allowed to speak so just let your religion do it for you.
And dear person where is you compassion for the aborted babies that could have survived given just a few more days in some of the cases? It is not a good thing that the Dr was murdered but that criminal will be caught and brought to justice.
They are not babies until they are born under law get over it. Laws protect all living humans that can live ourtside the wounb. Before that they are just a developing fetus and there is no gurantee they will make it to term.
Hey, I consider myself a liberal. I just believe there is a better way to do things than the way they are being done. I am definitely uncommon, but consider myself a rational human being. I'm a Christian, Democrat, and a pacifist. I don't believe in maintaining abortion clinics. If it weren't for the pure profit in it, they wouldn't exist. The legalization of abortion was an issue with doctors, not the women, because long before it was legal doctors were performing abortions all the time. If they got caught, it meant jail time. If doctors did abortions along with their normal practice, would they be targeted? No, it's only those doctors who run clinics especially for that purpose. And their reason? The money, of course. Do you think that if abortion was a free service of a socialized medical service that there would be any problem like this? Why can't we respect the patient's "right to privacy" when it comes to abortions? If there was any disclosure in any other case everybody would be fired! REMEMBER THE NURSES WHO TOLD ON BRITTANY? WELL?
there is no guarantee you will make it to work every morning. Should someone have the choice of terminating you?
When does life begin?
When did life begin? Was it a single celled amoeba type blob? was that life?
If so, what is the difference, as to what life is, between that first single celled protoplasmic blob and an unborn child? Other than one is studied and hailed as ..."the origin of life..." and the other is tossed into a wastebasket because it is just a mass of tissue. (?)
CJ 66. If people tried to keep up hope in societies throughout the centuries what makes you think profit is the motive?
I don't believe you are who you say you are because profit is not the reason for making churches, spiritualism is.
Profit is not the reason for teaching a neighborhood child to to catch a ball, fun and interest is. Profit is not the reason to have a public swimming pool in the neighborhood, community is. For visiting your sick aunt or mom or dad? Opening the door for someone else? Cooking a meal at your boat club???, profit is not money.
Midwives and doctors help people for one reason only...to help people.
America isn't the world. Abortion is happening around the globe. Look just north of us to Canada. Their social medicare system means their isn't really any profit in abortion. How can anyone think they have thought seriously on an issue when they haven't even thought outside their own borders? The giant landmass above is a giant refutation to your "prfot" motive.
Dr. Tiller believed in a women's right to choose to the point he was willing risk his own life. How many of us have such serious convinctions?
To say he performed abortions was a ridiculous, offensive comment. Dr. Tiller has spent years being threatened, falsely accused, harassed and even previously shot. He has bullet-proof windows in the clinic and a bodyguard.
I live in Wichita. I know of some of the harassment he endured. However he believed in what he was doing. He could have made money as a regular ob/gyn, however he believed that women have the right to choose.
God Bless You, Dr. Tiller. I hope your family finds some comfort in knowing how many of us respected him.
It isnt the womans right. Maybe in some stupid court of law. How about the moral law. That is what this doctor is being held accountable to today and so will everyone else that murders the helpless babies in the womb.
CJ66: It had nothing to do with women going to get back alley abortions?It had nothing to do that women were using coat hangers instead of the proper medical equipment?It had nothing to do with women dying for these reasons?
If it was all for profit then what about prohibition. Alcohol is a huge money maker. Just ask the bootleggers and Joe Kennedy about all the money they made during prohibition. Here you have people passing laws and trying to push their morality on others. How did Prohibition go? Not too well. AL Capone and other gangsters got rich from this. Gang wars erupted all over the country. Americans do not like to be told not to do something because it goes against someone else's morals. Some examples of this are: prohibition, abortion, the war on drugs. Now that we have a war on drugs there is an epidemic in this country. Marijuana was not illegal till the 1920s. LSD was not illegal until the mid-1960s. Hell the CIA used it for mind control experiments. I don't remember reading about huge drug epidemics before these drugs were made illegal. I am not saying drugs should be made illegal. I am just using them as an example of how Americans do not like to be told not to do something because of someone else's morals. Plus drug dealers make huge amounts of money. By your theory then we would make it legal just to all by Hummers.
If you are a conservative then you are against big ggovernment. What is an bigger example of the government interfering in on our privacy than tellinga women what she can or can't do with her body. Hell China did this and told women how many babies they were allowed to have. Do we want it to get to that point? We have to be careful it is a very slippery slope once we allow the government to tell women what they can and can't do with their bodies. If you are a Conservative you probably already know this.
As for the murder of this doctor he should be put in prison. Fundamentilist really are scary.
It's not the women's right to choose what happens to her body? Who's is it then? Yours? Mine? The Governments? Remember we are a society of laws. If you get caught speeding you have to go to that stupid court of law to plead your case. Why should your morals be forced on someone else. There is a reason the church and state was separated. Maybe I don't believe in your religion. Why should laws be passed to support your beliefs. If you are Christian does that mean we should start passing Muslim laws? Jewish laws? Buddhist laws? Hindu laws? Then every group I mentioned above would be upset.
This country goes by the Constitution. According to the Supreme Court abortion is Constitutional. Until you can prove it is unconstitutional then it will stay a law. It has nothing to do with what particular religion you subscribe to. So it was your God that had this doctor killed huh? He seems a very angry and spiteful God. It's funny when I was growing up and going to Sunday school Jesus did not strike me as a mean, vengeful person. Is that how God and Jesus work (or whoever you believe in)? They wait till the man is in their house of worship to take him? A place that is suppose to be peaceful? How about the fundamentalist that bombed other clinics. What about if an innocent mother and her baby were walking by on the side walk and were killed by the bomb. I guess that is all part of your spiteful Gods plan right. Or maybe this was just some whacked out fundamentalist that decided to act out on his own. You know that whole free will thing.
You don't read and someone wrote aand thought this up for you.
Why did Jesus cure the sick and heal the blind?
God wanted them to have this disease and not have a choice? God made that lesion so don't cure it? It would be immoral and furthermore...it could grow up to be a healthy human being?
No lesions don't grow up, woman don't survive late term problems and severe hydrocephalics dont grow brains back.
NOW, Number two: who are you going to shoot because they are not doing what you want?
Number 3: I say your child must be pregnant..it will be immoral if she is NOT pregnant! Do You believe me? I don't believe you either!
JustThinkin - In addition to your comments, Dr. Tiller operated within the law.
phugoid - Dr. Tiller operated within the law. Therefore, he is not a murderer. The U.S. Justice System has provisions to make and modify laws, voted on by society in the best interest of society. The laws are not perfect but continually evolve to better serve society. "Moral law", as you say, should be decreed by who? A group of people or just a select few?
This doctor did Abortions on full term babies most would have survived outside the womb! Kansas procecutors were going to press charges because he was performing Abortions at 8 and 9 Months for reasons like the mother felt depress or said she was stressed. Those are not valid reasons to perform an abortion. Don't get me wrong murdering the doctor was wrong and evil. But this doctor was an evil man I would have prefered he went to jail.
There is nothing in the Constitution that even comes close to saying abortion is right. To get to that point, some judges had to twist several times and then say "Because of 'A', then 'B' is probably intended and because of 'B' then 'C' is intended and because of that abortion is Constitutional." I challenge anyone to show anywhere in any of the Founding Documents or any of the writtings of the Founders where abortion is even mentioned, let alone stated as Constitutional.
Just because a bunch of activist left-wing judges voted to make it legal does not make it right, but it does show how depraved people can get with a bit of power.
There is nothing in the Constitution that says anything about abortion period.
14th admendment:
Section 1. All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside. No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.
9th amendment: The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people.
The issue that the Supreme Court looked at is the right to privacy. Does the government (local or federal) have a right to tell a women what she can or can't do with her body? Does that not interfere with her right to privacy and to make a decision with her doctor? Like I said before if the government can tell a women what she can and can't do with her body what is stopping them from telling her how many children she can have? Or that she can only have a boy or a girl? Where does it end? What happens when a women dies from child birth and the government made abortion illegal or a child is born without a brain and cannot live on it's own. Does that mean that the said women or family can now sue the government for passing these laws? These amendment I listed above pretty much says the government cannot make laws that take away peoples right. If a law was passed banning abortion isn't the government taking a women's right away to choose what she wants to do with her body? Smoking is bad for you. It kills people. Smoking when your pregnant can kill a baby. Does that mean we should pass laws to make cigarettes illegal. Drinking can kill you. Drinking while your pregnant can kill a baby. Does that mean we should pass laws banning alcohol. Driving and getting in an accident can kill you. A pregnant woman could get killed in a car crash does that mean we should make driving illegal? We choose what to do with our bodies everyday. We choose to smoke and take the chance of getting Cancer. We choose to drink and hope not to have complications. We choose to drive and hope we do not get in a car crash. I really hope a pregnant women does not drink or smoke. Why is it any different that we decide that we can tell women what to do with their bodies? A man cannot have a baby. He does not take the risk of dying during birth. Unless you are that women you do not take the chance of dying during birth. If a baby is born without a brain or its organ are outside its body when it is born are you the one that has to go through that? If a women is raped or a victim of incest are you the one that has to carry that baby to term? It is a private choice. No one should be able to tell a women what to do with her body. Just like I should not be able to tell you not to smoke or drink anymore.
You can not tell me that in this country there were 55 million babies that HAD to be terminated! Abortion as birth control is what it should be called. We have killed almost 2 generations for convenience. We are seeing young girls encouraged to abort their babies by their 19 year old boyfriends so that the boyfriend gets rid of the evidence that would cause them to be convicted of rape. I have only known two families who were told by doctors that the babies they were having would die soon after they were born due to birth defects. Both mothers continued the pregnancies. One baby died within 2 hours of birth. The second baby died 30 days after birth. Both were loved and held. Both mothers wanted to give their babies a chance just incase the doctors were wrong. Both are glad they didn't kill their babies. I worked with a young woman who was having a problem with her boyfriend. She was 6 + months pregnant with a little boy. She decided to break up with him and she went to an abortion clinic, paid them $1,200 and aborted the baby. We were all grief stricken-stunned. She wanted to make sure she had a clean break with the boyfriend she said. Two weeks later she realized what she had done and had a nervous breakdown and had to be committed. Point is their is a big difference between a doctor and a abortionist. Hopefully both the abortionist and his killer will have made their peace. We need to educate our young people that STD's, HIVAIDS are much worse then getting pregnant. If you aren't protecting yourself from getting pregnant then you aren't protecting yourself from all these deceases. The pill isn't protection. We need to make sure young women know that they can give that baby to someone. The gift of life! Someone out there wants that baby and it's okay to give that baby away. Don't kill it, don't leave it in a trash dump or a box on the side of the road. Someone wants that baby! We need to provide care for the mothers to be. When there is a problem it should be handled by a doctor not an abortionist with a drive-in clinic. This whole problem wouldn't have happened if abortion wasn't murder and big money!
Yeah I'm sure they do it for the money. They couldn't be any other kind of doctor and make money. Your right we should educate the children. That means teach them the proper way to use a condom and to always use a condom. Not this no sex at all stuff cause guess what that is not working. Kids are having sex anyway.
Hey wac left wing lib.......if a muslim cuts a head off then do all muslims cuts heads off???? If a black person kills another are all black people bad?????
So if a Christian shot this man in cold blood does this mean all Christians are bad????
So we can lump all liberals together right??????
I think Tiller sucked your brains out and you lived. Your BOY obama was shocked and outraged because he is also a baby killer, he voted to kill them once they are out of the womb.......he is an evil person.
They are not babies until they are born under law get over it.SO then why do you charge somoeone who kills a pregnant woman with 2 counts of murder? One for her and one for her unborn CHILD? Laws protect all living humans that can live ourtside the wounb. Before that they are just a developing fetus and there is no gurantee they will make it to Hey kid your argument does not hold water.. I feel nothing for the loss of this man.. He was who he was and that is that.. I had to laugh at obama who was outraged outraged I tell you over this.,.. LOL hey pal get outraged over your country getting the shaft. Get outraged over the price of gas and oil going up over 50 cents in 2 months. Get outraged over things that matter, Like this country going into bankruptcy itself..
I think someone as intelligent and far-thinking as Jefferson envisioned a legal system that was adaptable, not one locked in a literal-minded vise by the social constructs, mores, or even technology of his day.
"All men are created equal" doesn't mention women, either, but we as philosophical human beings take it to mean all human beings and therefore that women deserve the same rights, such as the right to vote, which they didn't actually receive until 1920! Would you argue that we shouldn't interpret that founding document in that fashion?
BTW, assault weapons aren't mentioned in the Constitution but right-wing activists (to borrow your left-wing phrase) seem to think they are covered by "the right to keep and bear arms." Funny, how one person's "juducal activism" is another person's common sense.
Dave, thanks for the compliment. I am a liberal. I am PRO CHOICE and proud.
It's going to be political because a)this topic is a hot topic politically and, b) everything is political.
The right (GOP)) of course doesn't want this to be political because it shows what nutcases are running around in that party. With all the happy peppy people dancing on this doctor's grave, you guys will go nowhere politically. Go back to your churches and leave the government alone.
And don't talk to me about paying for abortions with your precious tax dollars. I pay for a war in Iraq which i dont support. Until you tell me how not to pay for that, comments like that have no merit.
After stating during his campaign that he wouldn’t support late term abortions for women with mere “mental distress,” Obama has appointed someone who is arguable the highest profile, late term abortion advocate in the entire U.S., Kansas Governor Kathleen Sebelius to Health and Human Services Secretary of all positions.
-
“I have repeatedly said that I think it’s entirely appropriate for states to restrict or even prohibit late-term abortions as long as there is a strict, well-defined exception for the health of the mother. Now, I don’t think that “mental distress” qualifies as the health of the mother. I think it has to be a serious physical issue that arises in pregnancy, where there are real, significant problems to the mother carrying that child to term. Otherwise, as long as there is such a medical exception in place, I think we can prohibit late-term abortions.” - Barack Obama
-
You see Gov. Sebelius, even threw a party for the infamous Tiller the Baby Killer (George Tiller) as a show of support for abortionists and to thank Tiller for his sizable blood money donations to her campaign. You see, Tiller the Baby Killer isn’t just your run of the mill abortionist. He is responsible for perhaps thousands of Late and Near Term abortions. His efforts are so well known that women will travel world to come see the ‘physician’ that will pluck the dead remains of a fully developed baby at 9 months, simply because the mother complains that she is a little depressed. Yep, when you read Obama’s quote above about Near Term abortions for ”mental distress,” he is speaking almost directly about Tiller the Baby Killer.
Can you quote me the actual law that backs up your statement. I don't believe there is a law. Merely a Supreme court ruling. The truth is abortion is only "legal" because it's not specifically "illegal". Congress has abrogated their responsibility for making laws (one way or the other) to the Supreme Court because 1) The Supremes do not have to stand for re-election, and 2) Congress does.
This logic confuses me. Some folks out there oppose abortion because they think it's murder (late term or not)....apparently their answer to the problem is murder. Seems a bit hypocritical to me....but I dunno.
killing in the name of god is what sick, demented, delusional criminals do, with rightous indignation...screw your god if he condones this type of violence...killing is killing
God was invented on the battle field to give men a reason to kill each other. What is god's punishment for the innocent women, elders and children, who die in Iraq, Afghanistan, Syria, and Pakistan, when our drones target terrorists and jets follow up with missiles... collateral damage? 9-11 was done in the name of god...this is no different, just a different version of god.
Rather, love your enemies, help them, and lend to them without expecting to get anything back. Then you will have a great reward. You will be the children of the Most High God. After all, he is kind to unthankful and evil people. Be merciful as your Father is merciful.
Matt. 7:1 "Do not judge, or you too will be judged."
The Lord is weeping........and the devil is in control of the right wingnuts and their "church". These people.......are domestic terriorists........
Aryan Nation and their Church of Christ..................is just a DEVIL WORSHIPPING CHURCH. The Lord Jesus Christ........was the most inclusive man......he loved everything and everybody.............He said not to judge......less you be judged!
Why do these crazies........try and play GOD! What a person does is between them and GOD.
God is sickened by this more than we are... why do you think he gave us way to escape this never ending cycle of hate. Hating God does not solve this problem. Learning to live a God centered life is the first step. We all need work there.
The difference is the court found Dr. Tiller "not guilty" and he was operating within the law. The people harrassing him and the murderer that killed him were not.
You think it was all right for somebody to end his life because he helped women who were likely being killed by their fetuses anyway? FYI, this is why late-term abortions are typically performed. Congratulations. Stay classy.
Go ahead and cling to your guns, religion, and your backwards beliefs you white trash POS redneck!! Don't you have a megachurch gathering to be attending? F off!!
the logic you are confused by when it comes to the right. is the same logic that confuses me when it comes to the left. the left say's they want to save lives in iraq and stop the war, yet they kill millions of baby's in abortion clinics daily. the hiporisy is much much worse.
Technically, it's just another late-term abortion. What's the big deal? Dr. Tiller would be proud. Well said jcd- I don't think I'll be weeping for him either.
As there is a good likelihood there isn't a god, this is a civil act of murder. Trying to justify it as doing god's will is akin to Hitler saying disposing of the Jews was the work of the lord. This murderer has put his face on the anti-abortion banner, like it or not, and the so-called pro-life movement will suffer greatly for his act.
To murder a man in the church no less demonstrates a much more significant problem than whatever that man was doing. I do realize that this act is not representative of the majority of people that were against him but it does show how anger turns into hate quickly and is dangerous.
seems that if you live by the sword, you ,,,,,,, ! murder was his line of work and thats how he went out, its wrong on both accounts but its hard to feel sorry for him.
Bob, you stop reading at the old testament. The new one said turn the other cheek. "Christians" like you are the reason I go mountain biking on Sunday mornings.
There are lots of legalized things that are immoral, corrupt and rerpehensible in this country: Everything listed below used to be a crime a few decades ago.
Abortion is legalized murder of an innocent baby.
Your credit card company can legally charge any interest rate they want on your credit cards.
Lobbying is legalized bribary.
Having your car towed away for being illegally parked and charged rates that far exceed the normal towing rates to have your car released is legalized extortion.
Do you see the irony? Someone murdered the doctot to save lives of unborn children. You can apply the same logic to justify stem dell research. That is, killing one person to save the loves of many. Christianity isn't a beautiful religion, it's a mental disorder!
Kierra.......Christ must be weeping. These right wingnuts........belong to the church of the devil. My Lord Jesus Christ.....said : Judge not lest ye be Judged!
My Lord........wants me to come to HIM to be judged. "Right Wing Christian Churches"....are taking the Lord's purpose away. They have become the American Taliban............period!!
Marcia: The people who did this, contrary to what some of the hate-filled apologists would have us believe, are right-wing fundamentalist terrorists who label themselves with the ironic "pro-life" name. They are home grown terrorists who are absolutely the epitome of American Taliban. I agree with you on that.
However, until this country stops condoning religious ignorance, there will be no ridding ourselves of such fundamentalist nutcases. Even the doctor himself was attending a Christian church. Promoting and tolerating religion is not the answer to religious terrorism regardless of which religion they use to condone acts of terrorism.
When are we going to notice that all, ALL, terrorists use a god to justify their actions? There are those in this very forum who say it's okay if you just think about it as a late-term abortion yet they are perfectly willing to incite violence while calling late-term abortion evil. Do they even see that their argument is not only circular and illogical it is hypocrisy at its most vile? No, they don't because just aren't that bright. Sad.
Ok, So why do I need to wear a seat belt? Isn't it my body, my choice? Motorcycle helmets the same thing. Somebody just thinks they know better for me then I do.
yeah montana @ 7.2, the only bright people are those who believe like you, think like you, vote like you, and golly gee, probably look like you too, right?
no room for any difference of opinion.
who are the hate-monger, wing nuts?
who was the first to start striking out with hate filled speech.
hate-speech? does that fall under the "hate crimes" legislation? oh, thats right that only applies to someone who may be considered a conservative or Christian right?
Mrtvol...
The difference is the women take responsibility for themselves....we have to wear seat belts and helmets so ems and other service don't have to clean up your brains off the road..
Mary, I am talking choice, not consequences here. If you want to talk consequences- Abortion = death. Me not wearing a helmet does not mean that I die today. Even if I wreck, it does not mean I die today.
It should be MY choice to wear seat belts or helmets. It is personal freedom. How can you erode one person's freedoms and fight for another?
My wearing a seat belt or a helmet does not make you safer going down the street. Me obeying a stop sign does. Pass laws that protect me from you, or you from me, do not pass laws that protect me from myself, you from yourself. If you want to put 30 piercings in your eyebrow, good for you. I don't like it, but it is your choice.
A woman will always have a choice, as does a man. To have sex in the first place. To wear a condom, take the pill, spermicides, pull-out, any number of safe guards against getting with child in the first place. Getting pregnant is a consequences of those choices. As contraception, I am against abortion. In the event of rape or life threatening harm to the mother, I understand. I am sorry if you think that all kids should be perfect when born. They are not and never will be. Bad things happen to good people every now and again. It is what builds their character.
Note: Just because I don't like abortion does not mean that I will dictate to you that you can't get one. I don't like it, but it is your choice.
the government, god and other humans, have no right to decide what a woman does inside her own womb..."Woman's right to choose", is the law. All you religious freaks are using god to justify your own opinions. You think your belief makes you better.
So David,You've just justified murder.So your objection to abortion is moral vanity?Which,in my opinion sums up all religion. Hell is only for those who believe in it.
So if a woman drinks and spontaneously aborts not even knowing she was pregnant is a murderer? I don't condone late term abortions, but saying it's murder is just a way to provoke violence and condone these kinds of activities. Love the fetus, hate the adult.
How many innocent human being did this doctor kill?
It was not an unborn child it was an nonviable hunk of flesh that had no chance of surviving or living a normal life. That's why the procedure was being done.
Late term abortions are not done on healthy fetus'. Get a grip on your knowledge and common sense about the issues. Stop letting unreasonable emotions that don't even pertain to the situation run away with you.
None, you fool. You don't even know the circumstance of the procedures he performed. Many late-term abortions are done because the fetus is so damaged that any quality of life they may ever hope for would be nothing you would wish for anyone to experience even in your mythical hell. Late-term abortions, contrary to the hype by the hypocritical "pro-life" terrorists, are not performed for the purpose of birth control. I hope one day someone you love will be faced with this decision.
Unless "David" has become a femine name, you'll never have to make this decision for yourself. May it be your wife, sister or lover then. A pox upon your ignorance and a hex on your house. I'm not superstitious, but if you are you can believe that I'm a witch and just cast a spell on you. Boo!
WCE: You need to Google the responses to that stupid tripe, "The Silent Scream." It's put together to impress the brainless. Apparently it's working.
Joman you are truly being foolish I used to think that late term abortions were not performed but they are and He was one of the more prolific cases. You could go into his office and get an abortion the day of your presumed labor. Get a grip you have been lied to by the media that only tells have truths about anything. I am saddened that he was murdered but that is over now!!!!!! I gave it as much thought as he did snuffing the life out of our future.
Horrors such as this will happen with Gingrich, Rove, Limbaugh, and all the other right wing radicals begin to "fire" folks up.
STOP, stop it now. It must stop. What they are doing is way too close to yelling "fire" in a theatre and NOT freedom of speech. It's hate speech, absolutely
Good old GOP won't tell them to stop, so they are partially to fault for this man's death, no matter the side you believe in. Is this what "pro-life" is about? If the main leaders of the GOP had a backbone they could stop this
"When fascism comes to America, it will be wrapped in the flag and carrying the cross." -- Sinclair Lewis
I listen to Limbaugh fairly regulary...sometimes I'm even a bit right of him. I do not, however, condone this murder in any fashion. Your attempt to politicize an act of terroism is offensive. Let's pray for healing, especially for the Tillman family.
Spewing hate toward the conservatives does not help.
My brother-in-law works at Pelican Bay Prison in California...........He says.....The Aryan Brotherhood........listens to Rush Limbaugh and cheer and scream Yes! Yes! at everything he says. And there is a newletter called Storm Watch.....that is mailed to these wacko's..........and he says Rush Limbaugh sends monies to this neo-nazi newsletter to help support it. We have terrorist.........right here in the U.S.A. Right Wing = The American Taliban!
Why is there no regulation for radio and television like there is for newspapers?
When a newspaper prints something untrue they have to print a retraction, but people can get on the TV and radio and say things that they know are not true or that they don't care are not true and it's OK???
Bear Fan: Fascism is here in the form of Obama? No, that would be socialism, remember? John McCain even said so. The rightwing has become so confused they don't know the difference. Fascism was George W. Bush's forte. Fascists are far right, socialists are far left. Obama is neither.
What was it when Bush took over AIG? Socialism, Fascism, or something in between? You really need to pull your dittoheads out of Rush's butt and try to jumpstart your brains, if you have any left that haven't turned to mush from listening to the mindnumbing nonsense gushing from the rightwing terrormongers' pieholes.
Lu404506 What you are talking about is ccensorship and I am completely against it. By letting a complete idiot like Rush say whatever he wants is the only way I can say whatever I want. The first amendment protects us all and we all have to be smart enough to recognize an idiot like Rush when we hear one.
Oh, so now this guy is the poster child for the pro-life movement??? Get a grip!! That's like calling the deceased the poster child for the pro-death movement, when in reality the majority of doctors whom perform abortions would'nt even consider doing a late term abortion.
Such typical left wing crap. Any speech you disagree with you immediately label hate speech and seek to silence. It all about shouting down the right for you... THe speech of the right is nothing compared with the hate filled venom that flows from the left. Look at the hateful, mean, and spiteful things that were heaped upon Miss CA recently for honestly (and tactfully) answering a question regarding her opinion on marriage. Now THAT was hate speech.
What are you talking about? Have you not forgotten all the hate from the left over the last 8 years? Who were you asking to quiet then? What liberal leaders? Just because we stand for different things, does not mean we hate. The actions of one crazy man does not mean that any and all pro-life people are haters or terrorists, ready to kill like he did. Please give me a break. Being passionate about something you believe does not necessarily mean that one is full of hate.
I almost totally agree with your sentiments! I saw the headlines on this report by MSNBC and was blown away!
The writer and editor here in this article have been condemning the doctor and making it up that he should have been shot!!! This article was billboarding "controversial" and "abortionist"!! Instead of "heinous act" and "terrorist"!
Who was going to help these women needing late help, MSNBC?
So MSNBC would you say you would report Former President Kennedy's killing as "Controversial, non-Baptist polititian gets himself shot while freewheeling down public thoroughfare with top down!...Downtown traffic held up for hours!! Police costs drain coffers" ??? MSNBC headlines are now softening up because of so many replies deploring this murder? Done in a church?? (another church murder being ...what 18 weeks in a row?)
I don't know. But the for profit media is so into whipping up everything in the wrong direction it upsets me!!! It is like they have no values!
DON"T get me wrong! I don't want you,msnbc, out of reporting but you don't have to act like Newt Gingrich or rush Limbaugh or the other wackos looking to promote murders!
The controversy on this man is from the anti's point of view on this doctor NOT the courts, the legal medical profession or ordinary folk!
Thank you for all the insults and derision. It must be nice having a conversation with you in person.
Fascism is when the government directs what the private sector does. Socialism is when the government takes it over. GM will become a socialist experiment is the short term but the long term solution as it stands now will make its relationship much more fascist in nature. Believe me, W's moves left me just as concerned as BHO's. None of it will help in the long run. Capitalism has died a quick, painless death.
It sure would be nice to just have a conversation.
thats should be that's, a contraction of "that is"
Since you have joined two independent clauses together, you should either add a coordinating conjunction between them or replace the comma after your first predicate with a semicolon or period.
left wing is a single adjective modifying establishment, and thus requires a hyphen: left-wing.
Since the weekend is all but over, your assignment for the coming week is to avoid lecturing others on their need for an education until you can demonstrate that you have one at all.
Bob,people don't follow the "left wing" they simply exercise there freedom of thought and find it best represented by other liberals.Liberal! As in lberated ! As in Free!Conservatives are followers of pablum much like religious pablum.They generally subscribe to such mob thought because they're cowardly and dull.Like zombies.Like you.
You're all a bunch of idiots. Do you not realize that to the rest of the world, the term liberal is equal to the meaing of conservative ideology in the U.S., and the liberal ideology of the U.S. is called social democracy elsewhere? Don't play semantics, the words have absolutely nothing to do with it here and are just inflammatory labels.
Another justified killing in the name of god. Do you see the irony? Killing one person to save the lives of many. That logic can now be justified for stem cell research. As I believe: Christianity isn't a beautiful religion, it's a mental disorder!
You sound like some very hurt, bitter people. I'm sorry for the misconceptions you've been led to believe. Grouping together a large group of people and stero-typing them ins't helpful or honest. I am very opposed to the killing of unborn children but I would never condone what happened this morning.
Actually, Christianity as taught by Jesus is very rare. You aren't criticizing real Christians. You are criticizing all those who pretend to be Christians. No, I wouldn't have killed that man, but I think he signed his own death warrant.
My Dad was a doctor who performed abortions. That doesn't make me exactly a neutral bystander. But I will say, I think abortion is being pushed on women because it is a lucrative practice, there are people who want to use aborted fetuses for experimentation and exploitation. It is still the bottom line we are talking about here. I feel women are being just used badly by doctors and a lot of other people.
If we really practiced Christianity(love thy neighbor as thyself) we wouldn't even be discussing this, would we? If everybody kept the commandments, there would be no need for abortions.
Why aren't Christians (and other delusional factions) intelligent enough to realize there are more pressing issues than abortion?? Do you really want people who don't want a child to then be responsible for the physical, mental and emotional well being on that child? Do you not understand that the world is disgustingly overpopulated and there are millions of children starving to death and dying of preventable illness every day?? Why do you worry about abortion when in the parts of the world there are children wandering around orphaned from AIDS and other illnesses, walking skeletons who will surely join the millions of dead children soon? Get off you f-ing asses and do something to help them, instead of bitching about pro-life and hating Bono. Until you accomplish feeding and nurturing the children that are actually on the planet and have the capacity to process suffering, hold off on worrying about a mere potential for life.
No, I wouldn't have killed that man, but I think he signed his own death warrant.
Oh, I see. Real Christians wouldn't kill him, but instead would let his murderer off the hook because, heck, he signed his own death warrant.
But I will say, I think abortion is being pushed on women because it is a lucrative practice
Fake religious "pregnancy crisis centers" are even more lucrative, as they allow preachers to preach medical lies and religious bigotries under the guise of medical aid.
But I will say, I think abortion is being pushed on women because it is a lucrative practice, there are people who want to use aborted fetuses for experimentation and exploitation.
Hahaha, really? Abroted fetuses are used for "experimentation and exploitation"? I'd love to see you support that tripe with evidence.
I feel women are being just used badly by doctors and a lot of other people.
We get it. You have daddy issues. However, it's laughable to think that abortion doctors are somehow magically coercing women off the street into abortions they don't want.
If we really practiced Christianity(love thy neighbor as thyself) we wouldn't even be discussing this, would we? If everybody kept the commandments, there would be no need for abortions.
And if everybody kept the commandments, the US would be a theocracy.
I didn't say the man who murdered the doctor should "get off the hook". I think they caught him, already, didn't they? And, of course, he will stand trial and get whatever the court deals out. I just said that the doctor was putting himself in a position to be killed. "He signed his own death warrant." He was injured years earlier by anti-abortionists, and his clinic was bombed. A prudent man would have gotten out of the business.
Just need to point out that I've been to a few crisis pregnancy centers and they are not lucrative. (see above comment) None of those volunteers are making any kind of money. They are always low on funds and materials and to accuse them of being in it for the money is absurd.
I just said that the doctor was putting himself in a position to be killed. "He signed his own death warrant." He was injured years earlier by anti-abortionists, and his clinic was bombed. A prudent man would have gotten out of the business.
Right, because everyone should simply bow to terrorism.
Bill O'Reilly and his ilk have a lot to answer for. O'Reilly kept calling him "Tiller the Baby Killer" on his TV show, which was libel...and he didn't seem to know or care that people might believe him. I just wonder what he will have to say about it now on his show. And then I wonder what he say when the doctor's family sues him.
And as for the people on this site who are justifying the shooting...well, all I can say is that you are not doing your cause any good...because you are making all anti-abortion activists sound like homocidal maniacs.
Thank you bear fan, for at least trying to convince these haters that the vast majority of pro-lifers (myself included) find this act to be just as apalling as late-term abortion.
What Tiller was getting rid of was not a baby. It was nonviable. Late term abortions are not done on healthy fetus'. He was cleared of any wrong doing, and he was harassed and abused by radical crazy pro-lifers that have no common sense.
Tiller was indeed a baby killer, and O'Reilly's statements are not libel (look up the definition). I am pro-choice when it comes to early pregnancy, rape, incest, life of mother, and birth defects. However, late-term abortions are performed when the baby is capable of living outside the womb. That said, murdering Tiller is abhorrent, and sets back the pro-life cause by rallying pro-late-term-abortion supporters to their cause. Likewise, the Iraq war was unjustified, killing civilians unintentionally is still killing them.
"Bear Fan" never said "vast majority"
I will admit though that he did make some of the more reasonable and compassionate appeals...
however, it is always interesting to me when people find it so easy to use "haters" against people who merely disagree with "your" point of view......as opposed to those who truly challenge those who spew hate...
Bear Fan
would you agree there is a difference between "Hate Speech" and one voicing ones opinion?
Although I like to comment on many topics, I stay away from the Abortion issue as I take the viewpoint that is considered "naive" by many, that it is a Womans Body and she has the right to choose.
I am saddened by this event, first for the family, but also because it will detract and distract from the true issue, which seems we have not made any progress on in decades.
I also hope when the killer is found that he/she is just a loner who has no affilitations or ties with any active Pro Life group. That whatever statement they felt they needed to make was a singular action.
This will become a heated vine, I trust many/most will take Bear Fans approach.
O'reilly and Limbaugh are proven hypocrits who obviously think they are morally superior even when they make 'mistakes' that they would crucify others for. Don't doubt for a minute that O'Reilly would be pro-choice if he was in a bind that could hurt him financially. He's already shown himself to be a pervert, mpsogynist, and incapable of controlling himself beyond the level of a two year old child.
I know he never said "vast majority", but I AM saying it. Also I am not branding those who respectfully disagree with me as haters, only those who use violent, offensive, and hateful language when doing so.
JoMan-
I should have been more clear; I wasn't referring to any specific act of his but the idea of late-term abortion in general.
Outdoorlover - no problem I was just making a gerneral statement about the truth of late term abortions. People are calling them "babies" and they are horribly deformed and nonviable. It is very sad.
NU Wildcat fan - You are wrong - It is illegal to preform a late term abortion on a healthy fetus. See link below on that facts and what late term abortions are for, and for worse circumstances. Stop being swayed by false emotional stories of healthy bouncing babies that don't exist - these late term abortion babies don't have brains, limbs or intestines, or the mother's life is in danger. Get the facts. You choose between your fetus or spouse if you want - that should be the families choice!
NO ONE Pro life would condone this behavior...murder is murder....and the nut case that did this should be prosecuted for a horrible crime.
But murder is murder and this "Dr" Tiller knew exactly what that was. Hundreds of babies were murdered by his hands and the God who created him will be his judge..
Pro choice is a sugar coated name for murder and slaughter of the innocent.....late term fetuses if born can live and grow to becoming healthy HUMAN beings......I know I'm a neo-natal nurse ...
While I dont condone murder on any level.....at least Dr Tiller had a life ..
He choose to take away that right from hundreds of babies...
NO ONE Pro life would condone this behavior...murder is murder...
(!?!) Ah, have you read this thread?! Not only do many of your compatriots, if I may sully the name patriot so, condone this crime: many are celebrating it! For that matter, you yourself went on to say in the very same missive:
But murder is murder and this "Dr" Tiller knew exactly what that was. Hundreds of babies were murdered by his hands and the God who created him will be his judge...
Now, maybe it's because I'm a Liberal and given to liberal interpretations... but to my thinking you've just gone ahead and rationalised- nay, condoned!- this assassination yourself.
JoMan - The article you cite states the law in Massachusetts. In Kansas, the law is different. According to Dr. Tiller's own statistics, about 75% of his late-term abortions were in healthy fetuses when the life of the woman, rape, incest, etc. were not issues. Often, the "medical" reason for the procedure was the mental health of the woman. To me, this means the abortion was done out of convenience. If the abortion is done before the baby is viable outside the womb (i.e. after 24 weeks), that's much different than in early pregnancy.
To O'Reilly critics, yes he's got a big ego and is full of himself, but how many of you actually watch his show and listen to what he actually says? Don't twist his words. The liberal left want free speech, except when it comes to conservative opinions.
My concern with everyone blasting Limbaugh is they are attempting to connect a person they do not like to an event he has nothing to do with...I am a fairly regular listener of his and have yet to hear him "order" his listeners to kill anyone. I consider that hateful and well as deceitful. We all have the right to free speech. We have the right to stand for life. We do not have the right to take it. Tiller's murder sickens me... especially if we find out the murderer is pro-life.
What we need to do is pray for healing...for the nation and Tiller's family
How many watch the OReilly show you ask....more then MSNBC....but much less then WWE or SpongeBob Sqaure Pants.....and half of who watched Jon/Kate Plus 8.......
as a side note - no ones needs to twist OReillys words - he does a pretty good job on his own, along with Rush, Hannity, Newt, Coulter, Beck - splitting the Republican Party even further.
"George Tiller was a mass-murderer. We grieve for him that he did not have time to properly prepare his soul to face God. I am more concerned that the Obama Administration will use Tiller's killing to intimidate pro-lifers into surrendering our most effective rhetoric and actions. Abortion is still murder. And we still must call abortion by its proper name; murder.
Those men and women who slaughter the unborn are murderers according to the Law of God. We must continue to expose them in our communities and peacefully protest them at their offices and homes, and yes, even their churches." (emphasis added)
Ohh thats rich.. Blame O Reilly and anyone else.. Have you listened to OLBERMAN and MADDCOW on MSNBC? The loud mouth and the dike who think their opinions are the only ones that matter all the while they have ratings lower than a re run of Gilligans Island..
"And it came to pass, that at midnight the LORD smote all the firstborn in the land of Egypt, from the firstborn of Pharaoh that sat on his throne unto the firstborn of the captive that was in the dungeon; and all the firstborn of cattle. And Pharaoh rose up in the night, he, and all his servants, and all the Egyptians; and there was a great cry in Egypt; for there was not a house where there was not one dead." Exodus 12:29-30.
Pharaoh called this upon his own people.. God was only doing what the Pharaoh had asked him to do..
If it weren't for the pure profit in it, they wouldn't exist. - CJ66
Before it was legal, the profit was even higher -- it was being made by a smaller pool of legitimate providers in states where it was legal or, closer to home, by illegal practitioners, providing in many cases dangerous and unregulated services.
As to your claim that they wouldn't exist w/o profit motive, I think you'll find that non-profit women's health clinics also do abortions -- because, for those of us who belive in women's individual rights, abortion is one of the health options a woman should have.
You people play on words, that is what an abortionist is, a child murder!! Killing the most innocent of human life...before it has a chance to know it's rights. Could have been you aborted would that be all good and what you would have wanted. For your own mother to not even give you a chance to have a life.
Oh, I'm such a geek for history; author Cristina Page has a warning:
History has another disturbing lesson for us. The escalation of anti-abortion rhetoric plays a direct role in instigating violence. When anti-abortion groups ratchet up the rhetoric, they know exactly what they're doing and the results it will have. Even if they maintain deniability, as Operation Rescue recently did saying, in effect, we wanted Tiller gone, but didn't want him murdered, they have inflamed the rhetoric. And suddenly people Like Dr. Tiller's murderer become inspired. (emphasis mine)
This once again proves that Christianity is a doctrinal license to kill. The murderer is no doubt one of those Christian fanatics who believes he has performed a Divine service. In reality, he or she is nothing but a worthless and despicable murderer.
I feel for people of reason who must live among these fools who, just like the Islamic fanatics, seek to drag the country into their Medieval way of looking at the world.
They use their religion to justify murdering these doctors and hating other people who just want to live and love peacefully.
There's nothing in their Bible proscribing abortion, btw. As far as Scripture is concerned, life begins when the first breath is taken. All of these Christian hate groups and leaders know how to speak for G-d. They certainly know how to lie, torture, murder and start illegal wars.
In actuality, there are a number of pacifist Christian groups who do not think Christianity is a license to kill. I am a pro-life Christian. Pro-life, which means not killing people.
You are right about the Hebrew Bible and the New Testament, as well, not proscribing abortion as such, but I think the ethos of the Bible does call it strongly into question. The earliest Catechism of the church, the Didache, does proscribe abortion.
The Bible does mention several times (most notably in the Psalms) how God sees us and knows us while we are in the womb. It very clearly teaches that unborn babies are human beings who are important and loved by God. Now, if you chose to not belive in and follow the Bible, that is your choice. But claiming to follow Christ means that you cannot support abortion any more than any other form of homicide.
Oh please, we have christians who are gung ho for torture of the so called enemy and support war like it's their favorite hobby. Yet it's these same christians that harp the loudest about abortion. I went to church with these inconsistent feel good agenda pushers for years.
The christians who do support non-violence in all ways are few and far between and hide it when they are in their churches, while the pastor is preaching political right-wing aggressive agendas
Why do you stereotype ALL Christians? It's like stereotyping ALL Muslims or ALL Jews. I would say that the vast majority of all religions is peaceful, and that only a few radicals hijack religion for their selfish agendas. And don't tell me that ALL atheists are peaceful.
Tiller is wrong for killing fetuses that could survive outside the womb (as if women couldn't make decisions earlier in pregnancy). Tiller's killer is wrong and should be prosecuted (life in prison, minimum).
Of course Christianity condones abortion. Their god himself killed many a baby after it was born, which could be called late-term abortion, I suppose. Since god didn't have the technology to kill babies before they were born in those days, he had to kill them in infancy.
"And it came to pass, that at midnight the LORD smote all the firstborn in the land of Egypt, from the firstborn of Pharaoh that sat on his throne unto the firstborn of the captive that was in the dungeon; and all the firstborn of cattle. And Pharaoh rose up in the night, he, and all his servants, and all the Egyptians; and there was a great cry in Egypt; for there was not a house where there was not one dead." Exodus 12:29-30.
Why do you point the finger at Christians? There are many non-believers who think abortion is the wrong way to deal with things. The truth is that most fetuses that are aborted are perfectly healthy. There is good evidence that the infant in the womb knows what is happening and really does feel pain. Hey, what if there is such a thing as reincarnation?(I happen to believe there is) Would you want to come back as a fetus that will be aborted? Just what does anyone really KNOW?
Of course Christianity condones abortion. Their god himself killed many a baby after it was born, which could be called late-term abortion, I suppose. Since god didn't have the technology to kill babies before they were born in those days, he had to kill them in infancy.
It was Pharaoh who spoke the curse. There are steep consequences for defying God that can last generations. It is no different today.
Also, sure God in the OT seems a bit harsh and often times doesn't gel with your 21st century reasoning, but get this. If there was a God, and he was infinitely more superior than man, what are the odds He would make perfect "since" to us and our way of thinking?
Why do you stereotype ALL Christians? It's like stereotyping ALL Muslims or ALL Jews. I would say that the vast majority of all religions is peaceful, and that only a few radicals hijack religion for their selfish agendas.
Pro-lifers are the most radical and violent of the christians I know of. They are political and radical, and that leads them far more than what God says to do. It's very easy to stereotype them and they give me no reason not to. Can you give me a reason not to?
CJ66 - The truth is that most fetuses that are aborted are perfectly healthy
You are speaking of short term abortion here, not long term, and so far that is legal and a woman's rightful choice. God willing it will stay that way, or there will be more crime and deaths because of it.
I don't see lumping all Christians into one group. There are some who sit down and talk about all the issues, and I think one of those is the promotion of war and military service. Talk about brainwashed!For God and my country I'm going to believe every lie I'm told by the greedy swine running the government and go kill hundreds of thousands of innocent civilians in some foreign war that hasn't got anything to do with protecting US from ANYTHING?
This country is filled with blind hate and divisive politics. Every couple years our country gets caught up in hate. spewing baseless and sterotypical claims about people who do not agree with your point of view.
I find it amazing how much democrats and republicans, religious people and rationalist agree on. Yet, they focus on issues like abortion, like gun control, like God to divide people.
If our country would take all the energy that is spent on hate mongering and use it to better our country, our planet, and our lives, we would all be much better off. Fighting with people who's views are not going to change is a waste of energy. We would be better off accepting other people's differences and focusing on what makes us the same.
Also, sure God in the OT seems a bit harsh and often times doesn't gel with your 21st century reasoning, but get this. If there was a God, and he was infinitely more superior than man, what are the odds He would make perfect "since" to us and our way of thinking?
Interesting: God was a royal douchebag because he's way, way smarter than you.
You know, abortion was around in Jesus's day; women have found ways to end pregnancies for millenium... if not through surgery, through herbs, teas, roots, etc.
You say years ago doctors and midwives would take still born or severely disabled babies and kill them. Um, do you know what a still born baby is? They are born dead, you cannot kill a stillborn baby.
Secondly, who are we to judge that a baby with disabilities or deformaties are not worthy of living? I am not some holy roller bible thumper, but I believe if the child wasn't meant to be on this earth, he/she would have died in the womb....you pro-choice people say we shouldn't judge those who chose to have an abortion, but who are you to judge if a baby lives or dies?
My dad's girlfriend's daughter has cerebral palsy....by the definition of disabilities, she probably would be a candidate for abortion by most of you. She is legally blind, is 37 years old but had the mental capacity of a 7 year old, has no impulse control and has to have a sitter if left alone for longer than an hour or two. But does she enjoy life? You better believe she does. She has happy times and sad and mad times just like everyone else, she loves country music and spending time with family. Who is anyone but God to judge whether or not she would have a quality life?
Yes she is a handful and I am certain there are times that her mom is very stressed out and wishes her daughter didn't have this disability. But she loves her daughter and wouldn't trade her for the world. It's rough, but those are the cards she was dealt and she lives her life and takes care of her daughter as best she can. I am sure she sometimes wishes she had a healthy daughter, but for every difficulty she deals with her, there is someone out there who is worse off.
When are you pro-choice people going to get out of your delusioned world and admit the truth. Yes, SOME abortions are due to health problems for the baby or mother, but MOST of the time when someone gets an abortion, it's because they simply do not want the child....they are an inconvenience to their life and they can't be bothered with a baby. So don't stand there and defend it saying it's needed for medical reasons, because everyone knows the majority of abortions are for people's own selfish reasons.
And this crap about trying this guy as a domestic terrorists kills me. I won't defend what he did because murder is murder.....two wrongs don't make a right. But people kill people everyday for some crazy reason or another and they are never justified unless it's self defense. This man is a murderer, he deserves to be tried as such....he is no worse and no better than any other person who has killed someone, so get off your high horse about this domestic terrorist crap.
During the last election campaign, McCain (much to my surprise) did state, point blank, that people who bomb abortion clinics and threaten, harrass, or murder doctors and nurses who work in reproductive health facilities ARE in fact terrorists. I got a hoot out of the look on Palin's face, who is just as crazy as the nutjob in Kansas, because she does feel that it is justifiable homicide. Of course this is one of the few things I like about McCain. According to the definition of terrorism (attempting to invoke social or political change through acts of violence) Roeder is a terrorist as surely as Eric Randall Rudolph, Timothy McVeigh, and all of the rest of the right-wing, ultra-conservative white male christian terrorists out there.
well, obamanationites fire up the doctors to kill the babies so I guess its the same on both sides of the spectrum,,PERHAPS THIS EXPERIMENT IN FREE SPEECH SHOULD END SO THE LIBERALS CAN JUST "DO IT" because when it comes to killing the libs know their chit
Even if you do not agree with the man's work, he was a human being and also a human life. Killing for disagreement is not ok. Can I shoot my neighbor that does not agree with my views? We need to agree that all life is important. It is a shame that someone has done this, it only makes the abortion opponents look bad.
NO ONE Pro life would condone this behavior...murder is murder....and the nut case that did this should be prosecuted for a horrible crime.
But murder is murder and this "Dr" Tiller knew exactly what that was. Hundreds of babies were murdered by his hands and the God who created him will be his judge..
Pro choice is a sugar coated name for murder and slaughter of the innocent.....late term fetuses if born can live and grow to becoming healthy HUMAN beings......I know I'm a neo-natal nurse ...
While I dont condone murder on any level.....at least Dr Tiller had a life ..
He choose to take away that right from hundreds of babies
If a baby is not a baby, only a fetus until born, why was scott peterson charged and condemmed for killing his wife AND BABY, and they said BABY not fetus. so apparently it's only a baby when it suits you.when you can see a BABY on a sonagram and hear its heart beat, i think that would be called a baby even tho its still in the mothers body. CAN'T HAVE IT BOTH WAYS.
One "Wacko" does not represent those who are anti-abortion. I don't know where you get your information from, but you are way off base. Those who would want "radio" talk show hosts silenced, are looking to be silenced, themselves (remember Freedom of Speech, guaranteed by the Constitution, which also protects YOUR right to say what you like?) It amazes me, that so much is being made by men on this site, over a "womans right to abortion" when they don't have to ask a soul if they can have a vasectomy performed on themselves.
Those males, who have never carried a baby, but are great a "making them" and leaving the entire burden on the woman, have no room to even say a word about abortion. Were it not for their promiscuity, and lack of precaution, while they "enjoy themselves" women would not have to seek abortion at all. Remember, both sexes are equally responsible for creating a new life, yet it's always the woman who either has to have her tubes tied, or undergo abortion, or use birth control, while men believe it is their "right" to enjoy as much sex as they can cram into a lifetime, without any thought (and there are some of them out there, who are decent, and moral, who share in the raising of a child they helped to create, but they are few, in today's society) of the consequences of their lack of restraint or respect.
So, until the men out there, who are guilty of casual sex, "get it" we will continue to have unwanted pregnancies. More women need to learn to use the word " NO" so that they excercise their right to CHOICE, then we won't be keeping these doctors in business, they will have to "retrain" into some other specialty, in order to earn a living, and the endless murdering or unborn babies, may slow down, or come to a halt. It's all about THINKING, people, before you act. Common sense, and discipline, whether you are Religious or not. Period.
Maybe the one that killed him is one of those aborted fetuses that was reincarnated? Who knows? I believe in karma, or "what goes around, comes around", or "you get what you got coming to you", or, and this is my favorite, "Nobody gets away with anything!" Oh, and that's what the Bible really teaches us. So think about it.
"Nobody gets away with anything!" Oh, and that's what the Bible really teaches us.
Actually, the Bible teaches either (depending on what kind of Christian you are): 1. forgiveness and fairness, or 2. God will f--- you up if you don't listen to everything he says.
Men, such as Bob, who will never face the agony of an unplanned pregnancy have no right to sit in judgment on women....and the few doctors left who will assist them. By his incoherent rants he demonstrates that he's on the lunatic fringe.
This doctor didn't just perform abortions, he performed them late term and when the babies were born alive he sucked their brains out to kill them. This is a barbaric act. I do not agree with his murder - his judgement is not up to us but God. And I am sure God's judgement will be far worse than than anything man could do to him.
As far as unplanned pregnancy - women need to realize that any time they have sex there is a chance they may become pregnant even with birth control. Therefore they need to take responsibility for their actions. Rape and incest are a very small percentage of unplanned pregnancies. There is no moral excuse for murdering an unborn baby!
YOU flowerlady, are an ignorant judgmental bigmouth
I found out at 22 weeks that my child had only a brainstem. Do you even understand what that means???? Look it up. I found a clinic in Fla, but if it had been one week later in the pregnancy, I would have gone to Dr. Tiller. I have friends whose child had Turner Syndrome. (again, Google it) Dr. Tiller was the most compassionate man that ever lived. He understood what it does to a woman to be carrying a child that is wanted and loved, yet does not have a chance at any life. Due to people like you, a woman in this position is treated worse then you would treat your dog. You know NOTHING of the circumstances and NOTHING of the heartbreak that comes with it.
You opinions are your right. it is NOT your right, however, to impose your beliefs on me, or anyone else. Get off your bible, and actually read some facts for a change.
It is against the law to kill a viable baby. Late-term abortions are only allowed in cases where the baby is brain dead and/or so severely malformed that it would not survive after birth. The alternative would be forcing the mother to carry to term & then suffer the pain of labor, all for a baby that would either be stillborn or would die soon after birth.
In cases where the baby is viable but the pregnancy must end prematurely to save the mother's life (such as uterine bleeding or severely high blood pressure), emergency C-sections are performed to save both mother & baby.
It is a key component of Roe v. Wade that abortions in the third trimester are very strictly limited to cases in which there are severe health issues. They are NOT allowed in cases in which a mother simply decides that she doesn't want to have a child.
Dawn, as a physician, I understand where you are coming from. But most ultrasounds done for anatomy are obtained around 18 weeks gestation, giving the woman 6 weeks to make a decision. But the majority of late-term abortions are not done for birth defects (e.g. Turner's, anencephaly, Down's), rape, incest, life of mother, etc. If the baby can live a healthy life outside the womb (e.g. 24 weeks and later), I oppose these late-term abortions. Likewise, I hope they catch Tiller's killer and prosecute, life in prison.
Not true. At 16 weeks my U/S was normal. At 20 weeks my BP went up. At 21 weeks my level 2 U/S showed some echogenic fetal bowel. At 22 weeks I had an amnio. My peri was pro-life, and he knew that if my child had any of the issues he suspected I would terminate. So he refused to discuss it with me until 24 weeks. (after the legal limit in Fla) After I spoke to my OB, he got me in with a friend who went over everything. They not only gave me my diagnosis, they got together the 3" thick file I needed to get a legal termination. hydroencephaly, spina biffida, nothing but a brain stem, the list went on,
A majority of late term abortions are performed where for any other reason? Not in the US. ONLY the life of the mother and the viability of the fetus are considered after 18 weeks. Late term abortion only consists of 18% of all legal abortions.
And the doctor I went to most of these fanatics would have loved. He treated me worse then an animal, charged me $3600 cash up front, my husband and I were the only one permitted to be there. Her grandmother and great grandmother never got to see her. I was not allowed to bury her. But when these fanatics run the country, doctors that will help women like me are very few and far between. Bullet proof glass, vests, etc. I was left in the parking lot throwing up for hours after the procedure was started. I was not allowed to stay inside until after 7PM.
If these religious right wing nutcases would just realize that it's NONE OF THEIR BUSINESS........
None of them have any idea what it's like to have a nurse hold your hand and cry with you wishing she could do something to end the pain I was in. They wouldn't stop it if I went into labor, but they couldn't help me end the pregnancy, even though they knew I was doing the right thing. Instead I had to go to a clinic three days later.
Why in the world would anyone abort a fetus with Turner's Syndrome? They are not born human blobs. They are functioning members of society when given appropriate care and treatment. Same goes for Down's Syndrome.
In society's narcissistic drive for perfection, we are increasingly using abortion to insure perfect offspring. This sounds suspiciously like eugenics, one of whose proponents was Margaret Sanger, founder of Planned Parenthood.
What's next? Do we abort if we know the child will develop juvenile diabetes? Epilepsy? And eventually, if it is not the preferred gender?
I'm so sorry you had to go through this experience. I wonder how many of the so-called "pro-lifers" on this vine have any compassion for you? The doctor who didn't give you the choice should have been prosecuted and put in jail for the pain and suffering he caused you.
When are we going to start feeling compassion for people who already exist and stop the crocodile tears for the nonexistent? It's so easy for them to love someone who only had the potential of existence than it is to love those of us who do exist. Funny, that. Their god isn't any better, either.
"And that prophet, or that dreamer of dreams, shall be put to death; because he hath spoken to turn you away from the LORD your God...If thy brother, the son of thy mother, or thy son, or thy daughter, or the wife of thy bosom, or thy friend, which is as thine own soul, entice thee secretly, saying, Let us go and serve other gods, which thou hast not known, thou, nor thy fathers ... Thou shalt not consent unto him, nor hearken unto him; neither shall thine eye pity him, neither shalt thou spare, neither shalt thou conceal him: But thou shalt surely kill him; thine hand shall be first upon him to put him to death, and afterwards the hand of all the people." Deuteronomy 13:5-6, 8-9
The Christian god is telling his followers to kill people who don't believe that he's the only god. The god of the Islamic believers orders them to kill anyone who doesn't believe in him, too. Wouldn't it be nice to put them all in a room together and let them follow the orders if their respective gods?
A lot of the reason why women "suffer" from an "unplanned" pregnancy is because we have so many false mores in this country. If everybody would just learn to play the hand they are dealt, we would all be happier. And no one should judge the "unwed" mother or make life hard for the kid who hasn't got a father.
A lot of the reason why women "suffer" from an "unplanned" pregnancy is because we have so many false mores in this country. If everybody would just learn to play the hand they are dealt, we would all be happier.
Ah yes, if only pregnant women would just suck it up and deal, they'd be happier.
A lot of the reason why women "suffer" from an "unplanned" pregnancy is because we have so many false mores in this country. (emphasis added)
I hate- well, love- to quibble with folks' spelling, but shouldn't mores be spelled Moors, as in "those big black Moors are so seductive and so very potent that they just knock everybody up and then they just go their way"?
...uh, I am an intelligent human being. I, like other humans, will not 'just deal with it' if there are alternative choices I prefer, of which an intelligent human being will seek.
Dawn, I'm sorry for your horrific experience. And your OB doctor should not have withheld info from you. Physicians like myself are supposed to present all options, and let the patient decide. That's what I do. I also would not have done your ultrasound until 18 weeks (16 weeks is too early to be entirely accurate). I really only have an objection to abortions done on healthy fetuses for "convenience" after they are viable outside the womb (24 weeks gestation).
Dawn- Give me a break with all your excuses of why its okay to kill your baby. You people started aborting babies long before ultrasound or any other types of scans were invented. The fact of the matter is abortion is a matter of convenience. There wouldn't be a need for pro-lifers if the rights of the unborn were respected. Of course, if there's no one around to MAKE you respect them, you'll just toss their little corpses in the trash. In other words, you guys started it. All the killing is on the heads of those who abort innocent babies.
unplanned pregnancies happen because some pro abortion women are really to stupid to pre-plan theirsexual liasons properly. Do these women go brain dead the minute they spread their legs and let the male of the species penetrate them ? The women bares all the responsibility in a pregnancy if does not take the necessary precautions. What the hell is wrong with beingro-life. If all these people who are anti-pro-life would do us all a favor and just jump off a tall building then we would all believe what they are saying. Hollacaust, abortion, hollacaust, abortion some one explain to me the difference. You reap what you sow.
Dawn I am so sorry for all of your pain. Bless you. I know the emotional hell you must have endured. Please don't give any credence to the judgemental ignorant posts from people that don't have a clue to the reality of someone that was in your position or the procedure. I cringe when anti-choice people try and make their opinions hold more weight by making the actual procedure far more barbaric then it actually is.
As far as Dr. Tiller and his family they are all in my prayers. He provided a much needed and appreciated service to women and their families.
My concern is for the safety of the other abortion providers. They are constantly being harassed and threatened by a sick side of humanity.
I find the statements about this career choice being lucrative...laughable. Did you know that the health professionals in this area make about half of what others do? Why do they work in this field? Because of their belief in the right for women to choose. They are the hero's, they are willing to go to work each day knowing some nutbag could have them in their gun sites.
I have driven through Kansas and for miles and miles there is anti-choice billboards regurgitating garbage, sign after sign.
As far as all the Christians spewing their judgements and hate and quoting scriptures you need to go back to your bibles. There are quotes to back up the thought that until a fetus takes its first breath it is not yet alive. There are also quotes where women and children were ordered to be murdered.
Bottom line if you don't believe in having an abortion (anti-choice) don't get one and don't have premarital sex......MEN!
I am PROCHOICE which equates to PROLIFE in my book.
Murder is also a choice. Pro-choice=Pro-murder. You can dress it up with all the euphamisms you want. When you stop murdering the most innocent and helpless of all people on the planet, the pro-lifers will thankfully fade into the sunset of a new world. Think about something besides yourselves for once in your life. This cycle of pathetic selfishness must end. Boo-hoo, I'm an unfit mother. Boo-hoo, I'm not ready to give up my personal time. Boo-hoo, the child will be better off dead. Just listen to yourselves. Disgraceful, pathetic.
pro- life ? yeah right ! these crazy christians are every bit as dangerous as the radical islamists. and they are so certain that they are right , that they will kill just whom ever they need too to prove it . fortunately for the rest of us most of them are to weak and cowardly to act out the sickness in their hearts and minds
NO ONE Pro life would condone this behavior...murder is murder....and the nut case that did this should be prosecuted for a horrible crime.
But murder is murder and this "Dr" Tiller knew exactly what that was. Hundreds of babies were murdered by his hands and the God who created him will be his judge..
Pro choice is a sugar coated name for murder and slaughter of the innocent.....late term fetuses if born can live and grow to becoming healthy HUMAN beings......I know I'm a neo-natal nurse ...
While I dont condone murder on any level.....at least Dr Tiller had a life ..
He choose to take away that right from hundreds of babies
I respect you for your choice of helping people as a nurse BUT you did not read these messages nor the article.
WHO is going to help these women that have embryos and fetuses with no brains? Why test for problems if you can't abort?
My sister, for instance has a 17 fear old with 1/3 of a brain (internal hydrosyphalic) and did NOT get amniosyntesis done becuse of some religious whacked neo new age belief it hurts a fetus to get amnio. (she was ACTUALLY terrified of being religiously ostrasized for things being wrong) Now she complains how she goes no where and her back hurts from lugging her 140 pound baby around. My sister got 4.4 gpa in nursing school and has a 154 IQ but her religion kept her from getting help. Funny she complains none of the church goers will help either.
You know, if Christ would not have healed the leper or given the blind back their sight those people could have "lived and grown up to be healthy human beings".
You are not responsible for my sister's actions nor choices. I hope you all the talents in the world Bridget! Really!
oh it was a cowardly act that was as sinful as the doctors daily killings, it just that HOW CAN SOMEONE FEEL BAD HE WAS KILLED AND NOT CARE THAT BABIES ARE KILLED EVERYDAY? seems like selective application of their sense of outrage.
The difference is the court found Dr. Tiller "not guilty" and he was operating within the law. The people harrassing him and the murderer that killed him were not.
That's not the issue, sir. ("HOW CAN SOMEONE FEEL BAD HE WAS KILLED AND NOT CARE THAT BABIES ARE KILLED EVERYDAY?") We live in a land of laws. Those laws describe, among other things, what is held as criminal action and the way to address those actions. The person who killed Tillman acted as a criminal. Tillman's actions, were within current the definition of legal. If we , as a society governed by laws, change the laws to criminalize Tillman's actions, then going forward, those who perform those actions will be considered criminals. I'm not advocating (here) for change or status quo. I'm pointing out the difference between government and anarchy. It is a clear-cut issue and one cannot be on both sides at the same time.
It appears from your posts that you have divined the nation's feeling or lack of feeling about Tillman's murder. My opinion is that most Americans would "feel bad " for anyone who contemplated having an abortion and would also "feel bad" for the family members of someone who was murdered. That said, the current laws are clear; feelings are not legislated.
Maybe our laws should better reflect our feelings. Lots of laws are written that are "bad laws", and most are eventually repealed. Abortion laws may have a flaw in them, but it isn't likely that people will ever want to go skulking off to a back alley abortionist again. That's why it is legal, and likely to remain so. If we should do anything about abortion, it should be to make sure that we maintain attitudes that allow people to make real choices, and not be pressured into something. I understand that most women who choose abortion eventually regret that choice, and if they had it to do over, would have chosen otherwise. Abortion has become all too "fashionable". It is not really a solution to any problems associated with a normal healthy pregnancy.
Laws do not reflect feelings, or they shouldn't, for a good reason - we're irrational beings in the short term and our capacity for attrocities is endless.
I'm pro legalized abortions - because I believe that having a child without means or support is a great recipe for poverty, ignorance, illness, and crime. I also believe that there are very few women who walk into an abortion thinking that they are out for a Sunday picnic, and boy, just wait until the girls down at the office hear you did over the weekend - won't they be envious!
If you want fewer abortions, then educate young people about their bodies, sex, and provide easy, cheap or free access to birth control - spice it up with a solid education and a good foundation in critical thinking and philosophy and WAH-LAH!
A brand new generation of people who will very carefully think out their actions and the consequences that follow, utilize proper health care, and DON'T OFTEN GET ABORTIONS.
Actually CJ, research has found almost no women 'regret' their abortions, and wouldn't change a thing if they could go back. I've never heard it as 'fashionable'....WHERE are you getting this information???
Whoever killed him needs to die a horrible death. They had no right. I wish people would get off of their 'holier than thou' trips. Who appointed you??? I hope Karma gets whoever it is and those who think like them. So sad for this Dr and his wife. People just need to mind their own business and get a life and stop trying to control everyone else's.
Diddo. Sad that this doctor was murdered. Who ever killed him had no right to kill another human being. Even if it was out of hate and anger. This was premeditated murder which can carry the death penalty. Hope who ever did this, gets caught soon.
Tiller is wrong for killing babies that could lead healthy lives outside the womb. Tiller's killer is wrong for killing Tiller. Society should not kill Tiller's killer because that is wrong too.
Tiller did not kill babies that could "lead healthy lives outside the womb." You don't know anything about late-term abortions or the decisions women who get them are faced with at all. You claim to be a doctor? I'd like to see that medical degree. Did it come from Jerry Falwell's Liberty University, perhaps? Are you the doctor who didn't tell that woman about her baby's disorder until it was almost too late for her to obtain an abortion?
At least as a pro-lifer you're against the death penalty. That's a new one for your type.
MontanaAtheist, it is likely that tiller killed any baby he could make a buck off. he reminds me of the BTK Killer who was hiding in the church for many years too. eeeeeek!
Montana Atheist - as a physician it is my duty to be honest with patients and present all information, not hide things from patients. I never withheld info from a patient. There is propaganda on both sides, but on multiple different news channels (including liberal MSNBC, I have heard that about 75% of Tiller's late-term abortions are for reasons other than birth defects, health of the mother, rape, incest, etc. I wouldn't have a problem if these were the only reasons.
Again, it is against the law to abort a viable baby, for ANY reason.
"Viable" would mean: Able to sustain life outside the womb without life support. That would not include babies that requires lifelong support (tubes for feeding, breathing, elimination, etc.).
And no, it is not up to outside people (and/or the govenment) to tell a family that they must bring such a child into the world, and then spend millions (their own insurance money or your tax dollars) sustaining a child that has little chance of a meaningful life.
Why should other people (or the government) have any role in this kind of private family decision?
Can we round up all the newly "saved" babies and drop 'em off at your house for you to take care of and pay for? If you could shell out for the pregnancy vitamins and expectant mother yoga classes to ensure a healthy baby for all those unhappy moms who didn't want to go through that in the first place, that would be great. Thanks.
NO ONE Pro life would condone this behavior...murder is murder....and the nut case that did this should be prosecuted for a horrible crime.
But murder is murder and this "Dr" Tiller knew exactly what that was. Hundreds of babies were murdered by his hands and the God who created him will be his judge..
Pro choice is a sugar coated name for murder and slaughter of the innocent.....late term fetuses if born can live and grow to becoming healthy HUMAN beings......I know I'm a neo-natal nurse ...
While I dont condone murder on any level.....at least Dr Tiller had a life ..
He choose to take away that right from hundreds of babies
Its called ......you ready? BIRTH CONTROL.......don't GET pregnant to begin with UNLESS you are READY and ABLE (ever how you determine that, financially, mentally, ect) to deal with a baby.....AND/OR the possibility it may not be a "perfect" pregnancy or birth.
Also...whether "for abortion" or "against it".....there is NO NEED to wait up till the baby in nearly BORN to abort.....WHICH is what this doctor would do.....that is just immoral and sick. You will never see a list of all the babies he KILLED in the newspapers....but you will see this story....how....some nutcase went off and killed the doctor. People go "off" and kill people daily....even INNOCENT people they don't even know.....there are "nuts" everywhere. The guy who killed this doctor may or may not even have "an issue" with him....some of these "nuts" just want to go down in history books or something, who knows? I don't advocate killing anyone.....but the doctor WAS WHO HE WAS.....and that IS a "baby killer" and worse than that....one who would kill them full term. THERE IS NO EXCUSE FOR THAT.
Condolenscences go out to friends and family of the doctor.....but there are "consequences" for everything we do in life.....there are "choices" that we make.....and some are NOT "good ones"......killing full term babies is one of those EXTREMES....and this doctor "went there". That incited alot of hate and anger, he knew that......he chose to continue doing it.....from that point forward......it was a "job hazard" as far as I am concerned. You knew the "risks"....you knew what you were doing "was wrong" (I am assuming you had to, since you were killed in church?) and yet.....you CHOSE to continue.
From that point I can only sit here thinking....more or less.....you died "doing what you believed in, felt was right, or loved".......just as they say when a skydiver or something meets their deaths.....hard to feel sorry for anyone like that. The families ect , yes....them personally, no.
Condolenscences go out to friends and family of the doctor.....but there are "consequences" for everything we do in life.....there are "choices" that we make.....and some are NOT "good ones"......
SO you are saying the man should be shot and it was because he went to church.
Memo to me: I will NEVER help another human being and I wil NEVER go to church because char in ohio judges that is risky behavior and I should get shot for it.
DavePeroia - The law says different. If you don't agree with the law, there are channels to change laws. Murdering a doctor is not the answer.
AmericanLiberty - All war, for reasons other than true defense, is murder. But you are straying away from the topic. This is about the murder of a doctor that was working within the law, not Nazis.
Oh Dave you sanctimonious piece of crap....are you willing to take on the care of those babies that aren't aborted??? Let me guess and predict that you are one of those people that don't acknowledge them once they come out of the womb. You are probably one of the most vociferous individuals in protesting any kind of aid for them...heaven forbid that your taxes would be increased!!!
Hitler created his own laws to serve his purposes, which were internationally recognized as crimes against humanity. But this isn't about Hitler. This is about murdering a doctor that operated within the law.
Late-term abortions (not "full term" as you said) were legally performed in cases of birth defects, rape and when the health of the mother was at risk. You can call it what you want but the law calls it legal. If you feel abortion is wrong, don't have one. If you don't agree with the law, there are channels to change laws but murdering the doctor is definitely wrong and illegal.
Judgement is coming, and imminent, most assuredly... and those who are most self-assured of their standing are those who will be most shocked and dismayed, and just plain surprisedat the verdict they face.
Behold, I come as a thief in the night...
Don't say you haven't been warned, you sanctimonious and self-righteous unfaithful (infidel) ones.
" face the agony of an unplanned pregnancy " WTF? please spare me your agony, you clearly are a person who has had an abortion trying to justify your actions to humans, GOD will be the one you will need to convince that your " face the agony of an unplanned pregnancy" justified the death of your child.
If people like you would get a vasectomy, then there would be no problem with the agony of an unplanned pregancy. I guess I have to ask you, WTF? Who died and left you in charge? The brainwashers called religion?
Hi. I'd like to introduce you to the idea that not everybody in the world is a Christian or believes in god. You can think whatever you want, I suppose, but if you live your life in a "moral" way, what the hell do you care about what the rest of us do? Your sanctimonious attitude only serves to make YOU feel better, it doesn't do the rest of the world any @!$%#ing good. Shut up.
Bob is not capable of empathy, but does believe that he has the right and the direction from God to make my decisions about my body for me. The only way to prevent "unplanned pregnancies" is abstinence. Maybe the men who think they should be able to make this decision for us should try abstinence. Problem solved.
"Stop judging, and you will not be judged. Stop condemning, and you will not be condemned. Forgive, and you will be forgiven."
Oh, please. Use of 'god' in this issue is absurd. 60-80% of fertilized eggs don't implant; one-third of those naturally abort. That makes your ""god"" the biggest abortionist around. It clearly shows their value to the divine.
That's right Bob...God will be the one to decide...not you! Lose the god-complex because that job is taken. You will never face the complex situation of having an unplanned pregnancy and should not presume to understand. I am pro-life AND pro-choice simply because my beliefs have no part in the debate. Our constitution guarantees the right to privacy and that is the issue upon which Roe V Wade was decided. Reversing Roe V Wade will not stop abortions. Killing doctors who perform abortions will not stop abortions. When my 13 year-old daughter was raped by a neighbor, we were faced with the most horrible decision imaginable. My daughter had a very serious medical condition that, had she carried the fetus to term, would have killed her. What choice would you make? And, is it any business of yours what choice we, her parents, made?
Bob and Flowerlady. The both of you are total idiots. I had a late term abortion and I would do it again. I found I out I was carrying a "lethal dwarf" a horrible genetic mutation where the baby( very deformed) would have died during birth or quickly afterwards. Why in hell should I be forced to continue to carry to term to appease people like you? Women take abortion very seriously. We are not stupid! You are so black and white and are truly clueless about why a woman would get a late term abortion.
montanagirl - The people that don't understand about late term abortions are caught up in political and radical religious retoric. We can't expect any logical thought from them, or any true compassion.
Your compassion and understanding is real - theirs is just a front or a hobby to make themselves look important. Kind of like belonging to a country club.
Liberals make me sick. I'm a union electrician and a reg. dem. But life has to start somewhere, who are we to decide at what point in human developement we can or connot kill them. Any abortion IS murder, and if the law will not prosecute and give justice to the babies then we should. This animal got what he deserved.
Didn't mean to spark such a nerve, but enough is enough! Abortions have been going on since the beginning of time and will continue until the end of time. I think these 'God complex' brain washed people come along and suddenly feel the fricken urge to tell the rest of the world what they "need" to be doing and how they "need" to be acting. Most of the time, it is someone who doesn't have all the facts, only knows what someone else has put in their head and surely couldn't imagine thinking for themselves. I don't agree with everything that others do, but maybe through education, etc. then people can have the brains to figure it out for themselves.
Meanwhile, let God do his work and you keep your damn day job, that is if you are lucky enough to have one!
The earliest Catechism of the church, the Didache, does proscribe abortion.
Catechisms are doctrines of Man, an interpretation of the Bible, not the Bible itself. Of course, no one's actually READ the Bible except for the small number of folks that can actually read archaic Hebrew and Aramaic.
All of this we're debating is based on a translation of a translation of a translation of a translation of a book written in the Bronze/Iron Age (nod to Bill Maher). And it was men of that age that decided which ancient writings would be included in the "Bible" and which would not. I wonder what's in the "deleted scenes"....
Have some fun with this notion: go to Babelfish and translate the phrase "I love you" from English to French, French to German, etc through 4 or 5 different languages. Then translate that result back to English. It's a hoot.
Yet some Christian extremists are comfortable with killing those they disgree with based on their interpretations of this translation. And many mainstream Christians are comfortable with passing laws restricting the rights of women they don't know and will never be involved with based on THEIR interpretations of this translation. Because of course the BELIEVE in their interpretations of this translation, they have FAITH, and faith trumps all reason and logic.
With the exception of publically funded abortions (and that's a subject we SHOULD have a debate on), abortion is the business of the individuals involved, and whatever god(s) they choose to believe/disbelieve in. AND NO ONE ELSE'S! If you believe abortion is wrong (as do I):
A. Don't get one
B. Teach your children it's wrong
And leave it at that! Keep your nose out of other people's business, like my folks taught me!
For crying out loud, don't we have more important concerns as a nation?
Once again, they do this in the name of the Lord! Did you read the 10 Commandments one of which says "Thou shalt not Kill." And in the Drs. place of worship no less. This is one of the reasons, that those of us, that are prochoice, not proabortion, will never hook up with you anti abortion nutcases. To take the life of a Physician, is no less wrong than taking the life of a embryo. I will never understand their reasoning, oh forgot, they do not reason, they hate!!!!
Murder is never condoned, that is why ppl. try to save the unborn, who never got a chance to breathe. How can you justify your anger for the doctor, yet dismiss his victims. He was shot in both arms in 1991 yet he was willing to die, to continue to kill. I know I know, the debate is still out there about when a baby becomes a baby. But you believe in fairytales if you think that most abortions are for deformed children. That is a lie.
If a mother gives birth in her bathtub and then drowns her baby, she is charged with murder. If a doctor performs an abortion on a baby 9 months along, even on the day it is to be born, it is considered okay. And according to Obama, it the baby survives that abortion attempt, then it is okay to set it aside, until he or she dies.
Next, will come the holocaust of the elderly, as well. People say that we have to many humans on earth. They praise abortion for the extermination of silence humans, next inconvenient group targeted to die, will be grandma and then us as we age, after all it is good for society if we don't have the cost of the elderly. See what logic and reasoning can do?
It is better to protect the sanctity of life, no matter how small.
But life has to start somewhere, who are we to decide at what point in human developement we can or connot kill them.
So any woman who miscarries should be charged with manslaughter, right?
After all, your "if we don't know for sure, then life has to start where I say it starts" schtick puts criminal prosecution of killing at "anything after conception."
Once again, "Compassionate Conservatives" care only about a blob of cells.
Actual people exist to be murdered when they don't agree with Conservatives, subject to diminished welfare state spending, or sent overseas to fight illegal wars...preferably if they are brown and poor.
Is it finally clear why the world is sick of the conservative, American Taliban?
NO ONE Pro life would condone this behavior...murder is murder....and the nut case that did this should be prosecuted for a horrible crime.
But murder is murder and this "Dr" Tiller knew exactly what that was. Hundreds of babies were murdered by his hands and the God who created him will be his judge..
Pro choice is a sugar coated name for murder and slaughter of the innocent.....late term fetuses if born can live and grow to becoming healthy HUMAN beings......I know I'm a neo-natal nurse ...
While I dont condone murder on any level.....at least Dr Tiller had a life ..
He choose to take away that right from hundreds of babies
Politics makes strange bedfellows, but the union between Conservatives: who staunchly believe that Government should stay the hell out of our lives as much as possible, and Right-to-Lifers: who believe that Government should FORCE unwilling mothers to harbor and sustain a life within their flesh for the nine months of their pregnancy, that union between two opposing extremes is the strangest to me of all.
My view is simple. Abortion is wrong but it is not illegal. We have to make a clear distinction between what is wrong and what is illegal.
Meanwhile the law itself traditionally believes that life begins when a human being draws its first breath. Just as reasonable is to believe that a baby is protected by the law from the moment the placenta is separated from the mother's blood supply. The law can go no further than that without infringing on the constitutional rights of the mother.
Clearly there is a grey area which occurs in the birthing room where post-partum babies may be allowed to die, purportedly because they are not viable as human beings. Yet, this is the same reason that Mike Tyson's 4 year old baby was legally separated from her life support system, because she was no longer viable as a human being. Physicians, as professionals, are trusted to make this call every day throughout the nations. The opportunity for abuse exists for a 80 year old just as it does for an 8 second year old. To a physician the area of decision is not a grey area at all. We trust them, with only a few exceptions to make this call. Where they breach this trust they should have to answer for it and that is as it should be.
But it appears to me that this grey area is not the real bone of contention here. It is clear to all supporters of choice that the activist foes of abortion, (as opposed to those who simply believe it is wrong,) are really seeking for an ultimate ban on abortions of all kinds. This is clearly an extremist view and unsupportable because of the tremendous advances in medical technology which are now able to achieve much that is possible but pragmatically unsustainable for mass applications. The so called Octo-Mom is a case in point.
This is why although I vehemently believe that all abortion is wrong, and although I pray forgiveness that my youthful unwillingness to accept responsibility for my actions did once result in my condoning such an act, I still cannot support legislation banning all abortions. There are many sins which cannot be sanctioned by the law and I believe that abortion is one of them.
nick-1132575...... Since your radical philosophy is inconsistent with any religion I know of, it must be based on something else. Maybe, however, it is merely your own convoluted idea of vigilante justice. There are already a number of "freemen" behind bars. I'm sure there's room for you should you, also, decide to take the law into your own hands. Isn't it interesting that those who loudly trumpet their concern for life are the ones most willing to take it?
You did get something in your post right. You are indeed "sick".
You mean like the garbage where the fetuses are thrown ?
You support abortion, what's the difference when it's done? Opps, I forgot, you set the rules on when the termination takes place to justify your guilt. If somebody were to do to your pets what these abortion hacks do to the fetus, you would be screaming about it.
Are you talking about those fetuses from the litter-makers? You know, those fetuses we weren't allowed to use for stem cell research by Prez Bush? Those were the fetuses that are created so infertile good Christians can have their "own" baby instead of utilizing adoption. You know those "good" Christians? The ones whose god chose to make infertile and so they need science to help them make a baby (or 8) and throw away the fetuses they didn't want in the process.
Old, you're not just old, you've got dementia if you can't see the double-standard in your statements. Of course you can't. You poor man. Maybe I shouldn't presume you're a man just because you sound so ignorant on this topic. But I think the odds are with that bet. Anyone care to bet if Old409 is a man or a woman?
Your very statement proves that you have no value for human life. You would have made a great concentration camp guard. If you need a job I hear the Taliban is looking for a few good men.
Once again, the so-called 'right to life' nut cases have proven they have NO regard for human life, else, how can they condone a cold blooded murder such as this one?
Hey- I'm pro-life and this venal act in no way supported by the majority of pro lifers. This is a sad day for his family, the pro-life movement and for the human race in general. Please do not lump all prolifers together!
When Barack Obama and every other Democrat is called a murderer and baby killer on this board, it isn't much of a stretch to suggest the anti-choice people condone and even advocate violence and murder.
'right to life' nut case, is the operative phrase, crazy ass people
Wow, what a shining example of Christ's love.
Once again, I am ashamed to admit I'm from Kansas.
As a solution, both Pro-life and Pro-choice are unsustainable. Both arguments, being temporal and also binary do not have basis in Truth with a capital "T". That is, depending on your point of view you can argue for either side and be both correct and wrong at the same time. Look at this sad example of Dr. Tiller's murder. A Pro-lifer took the life of a human while trying to defend his/her viewpoint on abortion. Tried to justify the taking of a life to save another life. Isn't he/she now just as guilty? Totally hypocritical and therefore unsustainable. Let's say we outlaw abortion, how will we handle an overcrowded Earth in a few centuries? Who will be chosen to die and who will live when the Earth's resources no longer support our biology? We need to STOP trying to legislate based on binary and temporal arguments and instead look toward the Eternal solutions. The religious should return to their roots where Jesus instructed us to "seek ye first the Kingdom of God." That is, the unarguable Truths which are Eternal. Kind of like the writings of our Constitution and our Bill of Rights. They are written in UNARGUABLE language and their Truths will hold (sustain) until the end of times. Also, the religious should try to remember that Jesus Christ triumphed over death. That is, if you really believe in Jesus Christ than death is not a problem, am I correct? Then we should just accept death within the reality of life as just another stage and forget about the timing. What we are really argueing here is the timing of death and not death in itself. Could it not be that soon to be aborted fetuses only come into this plane of existence in order to teach their parents something about life? And if so, who are we to negate the lesson? The parent(s), having learned their error from a prior abortion, wouldn't they be more receptive and caring of the gift of life in the future?
Some idealogue with a firm belief in his version of sanctimonious behavior and God with a gun in his hand.
This murder is the logical end to the faulty absolutist slant that abortion = murder. The murderer, in this case, was responding logically to what he saw as a mass executioner in the doctor.
Since clinic doctors are not being killed across the country, we can assume that the anti-choice contingency does not believe as the murderer did that 1. abortion = murder and 2. an eye for an eye is a biblically sanctioned response to a perceived murder.
I think most right-wingers would say 1 and 2 are both true. In fact they routinely do on this board, but only the abortion clinic murderers walk the walk. I say thank God (Christian or otherwise) for that.
Right, like the person who shot and killed him is any better than him. Please, people need to remember that they are not the almighty, and shall not judge those here one earth!
There is that faction of the 'Pro-Life' group that are fundamentalist extremist, aka, "terrorists", that are equally a threat to our Constitution and American-way of life as any other terrorists.
Fundamentalist, be it Islamic or Christian are still fundamentalists and more than likely violent - and we have no room for either one of them in the United States.
Law Enforcement need to go after these right-winged fanatics just as hard as our military is going after the Taliban.
Finally, I contend that we are all 'pro-life', but some of us believe that it is a woman's right to choose. I don't know of a single-person that approves of unconditional abortion. Most 'pro-choice' advocates would never choose abortion, they simply support the woman's right to choose, specifically, conditional.
Nicely put Peter!
obama would call this a late term abortion and wouldn't even send in the doctor to save him. You cannot have it both ways obama supporters.
The fact is that all you right-to-lifers should get lumped together until you do something about your extremists. You claim to be the protectors of life, but you take life illegally. Whether you like it or not, abortion is legal in this country. It is not murder. Your right-to-lifer friend committed MURDER! Step up, take responsibility and stop hiding behind the "That's not how I feel" cop-out.
Anti-abortion group Operation Rescue = Terrorists....it's our CHOICE, stay the hell out of our business....Operation Rescue should be listed as a Terrorist's Organization
HRDawg, Short and sweet, nice.
Funny how "right-to-lifers" only care about "certain lives". This man was a living. air breathing human being and he had the right to life. Operation Rescue promotes and instigates these nut jobs to do crimes like this one. Then they denounce it. This is a sad day for the human race.
We have a legal process in this country to deal with people we feel have broken the law. Dr. Tiller was being put through that process. This is not the way to handle him. One person judging a man is not in any way set forth in our Constitution as a State or a Nation. I disagree with Dr. Tillers chosen profession, but he has rights in this State and Country that needed to be observed. We have capital punishment in this state. May the one that gunned down Dr.Tiller find the same fate. As long as a person draws breath, they have the ability to make their lot in life better. This person does not deserve that right. He has lost it by his cowardly act.
Kansas native and Pro-life.
My sympathies to Dr. Tillers family.
The shooter is a criminal plain and simple. There has already been anti-abortion groups denoucing this horrible act. I think this push to lump anyone who is republican as some kind of "right wing" nutcase is a pretty lame example. No one is approving of this gunman's actions and I for one feel he should be considered a domestic terrorist and if found alive, should be given the death penalty. I am a republican, but I also believe in a woman's right. I also believe in owning a weapon. Don't start the political banter on this act. Somewhere someone took matters into his own hands and committed murder. He could have protested the site or even protested the doctor, but he did the coward method and shoots some 67 year old doctor while the man is attending his church. The FBI should have at least assisted him or made some assessments on which groups were becoming more and more violent.
Come on Wayne. How am I, a guy in Michigan, who doesn't think most abortions are a good thing, going to stop an abortion nut case running around Kansas? I think you over estimate our organizational skills. And why in any way would I be responsible for it? No anti-abortion people I know share the twisted murderous logic of this perpetrator.
I don't see what the big deal is to all the abortion proponents. Just consider it an abortion in the 201st trimester. That should make you feel better.
OK, I absolutely don't condone this crime; it is sheer murder. But, I can't reconcile how some of you can be so outraged at the killing of the doctor, but you are not outraged at the killing of defenseless babies. Not only are you not outraged at it, you promote it - in the name of protecting women and their "rights". Let these women just not get pregnant; there are all kinds of means to do that out there you know.
PROLIFERS Murdering People. PROLIFERS Murdering Doctors. To me that is funny! Its simple irony. But really..but it's a hoot..it's a f'in hoot! via Bill Hicks
NBBSBC82, you are right. It was a VERY late term abortion. I mean, the "doctor" could have survived outside his mother's womb, but that would have been hazardous to some peoples' "mental health." Although, I don't think he should have been shot, I think that he should have been injected with saline, hung up-side down, had blunt scissors shoved through the back of his skull and his brain extracted until he died, because that is the LEGAL WAY to commit murder.
schwannomin:
Your huge oversight is that barry and the pro-choice individuals (Not ALL democrats) fail to renounce and call abortion what it is: "MURDER". No need to paint a pretty picture. Have the guts to call it what it is!!!
Be it an un-born child, an abortion Doctor, or a death row inmate!"MURDER" IS "MURDER"!!
Let's see barry renounce abortion the way that the organization above has renounced murder????
This act is horrible. My prayers goes out to the family and to the church members. I am a little confused. Where in the article did it say the suspect was a pro-life activist or he was a right-wing nut or he was faith driven.
For the record I am neither pro-life or pro-choice. I am a believer and supporters of individual rights.
Operation Rescue = A continuing criminal enterprise.
Aren't you jumping to conclusions? Who said pro-lifers condone this type of thing? Absolutley NOT! Who knows if this may have been done by someone with a personal vendetta against this man. Who knows if it could have been done by someone who didn't want his girlfriend/wife, whatever, to get an abortion, or a patient not satisfied with the outcome.
PROLIFERS Murdering People. PROLIFERS Murdering Doctors. To me that is funny! Its simple irony, but really.. it's a hoot..it's a f'in hoot! via Bill Hicks
When will the world get with it?
This murder cannot be compared to the 64,000 partial birth abortions he has performed. you are the nut and the hypocirte. not the pro-life movement.
please Trish, no regard for human life is abortion..the numbers are completely offset..I'm not giving my views on pro-life or abortion.. thus, there are consequences to both actions, which I prefer not to elaborate on...please my dear, had you been aborted, we would of not heard from you.. then we'd not know of life's intricacies..off the wall; if the wages of sin is death, then what did a unborn child do ??....
Okay wing-nuts, let's talk logic... NOT emotion or saber-rattling, just logic.
1) How many references in the bible and just about any other significant historical writing does the beginning of one's life start at birth? All? Really? And how many start at conception? None? Really?
2) How old are you? And that's based on your "life" starting when? At birth? Why not count from conception then?
3) So at what point did you decide that life starts at a different point than the bible and every other social behavior refers to? There must have been some grand revelation, right?After all, this IS your argument, right?
4) So you say your new life starting point is based on science? How is it that you reject every other aspect of science... like evolution... but insist that YOUR interpretation of the evolving science of fetus awareness is the correct one? When was it you changed your OPINION?
5) And finally, the fetus is absolutely and undeniably totally dependent on the mother... until BIRTH. Doesn't it stand to reason, then, that a mother OWNS and must make decisions for and about that fetus until that fetus is BORN... which is when the fetus becomes a child and is independent of the mother... which is when the mother loses her absolute rights over who is now the newly born child.
Look, I'm just saying that you "pro-lifers" have every right to believe what you believe FOR YOURSELVES, but DO NOT have the right to deny the rights of a mother over her fetus. Its logical. It's supported by your own religion. And you are violating other's rights by demanding that EVERYONE follow your beliefs.
AND, BTW, if you wrote any "hate" posts, or spoke to anyone of Tiller or others being murderers, then YOU are the ones that brought this on. There are crazies out there. You all just successfully influenced the wrong one. Think about it.
You know what stands out to me concerning this situation? The right wingers, who are all too quick to jump on here and criticize anything they can about the state of things in the U.S. these days -- like Sonia Sotomayor's nomination for the Supreme Court, or Barack Obama's response to North Korea -- are unusually silent on this one. What's wrong? The vast majority of the right is vehemently opposed to abortion, so why aren't they celebrating the murder of an abortion doctor? Hasn't Rush Limbaugh given you the go-ahead to cheer this one? Hasn't Dick Cheney said it was a threat to America?
The right wing...(crickets...crickets)...nut cases on this and many other subjects as well...
Yet another example of white christian zealots engaging in acts of domestic terrorism. White christian males have carried out most of the terrorist acts committed in this country and until we start treating them as the terrorists they are, it will not stop. There are so many pro-lifers out there defending their pro-life organizations, but they don't stop to consider what their "Wanted dead or alive" posters really are--calls to activiely engage in terrorism.
Abortion is NOT murder because the Bible clearly states that a person is not living until he has received the breath of life (i.e. been born). Up until that time it is part of the mother's body, no different than her hair, fingernails, or appendix with the exception of the parastical nature of the growing cell cluster. It is a parasitical infection in that it cannot survive outside of the mother's body and the body seeks to treat it as an infection (i.e. to destroy it). You have your beleifs and I have mine, though mine are supported with scripture AND science and your are based on your "feelings". I don't seek to impose my thoughts on you, so please quit trying to impose your dogma on everyone else, too.
Excellent post! For those who want to read the entire post, it's post #1.33. I'd enjoy seeing a right winger try to disagree with the logic. They can't...
okay i see the media has successfully started another baited story against the pro-life movement.... where in this story does it say the killer has been caught or tied to any pro-life movement, why can't the killer be a plain old crazy nutcase.
nobody condones this behavior but why do we always assume its political?
The Pro-Deathers have spoken! Let us all rejoice in this! Pro-Choice or the Pro-Death people are truly racists. They would rather have minority baby's killed in the womb and not deal with these minorities in the future. Ask any white supremacists. Pro-Deathers have done more for their cause (the white supremacists) then they ever could have done for themselves. for instance, black women are 6 to 8 times more likley to have an abortion than white women. Good for you Pro-Choicers!!
By that I mean you hater liberals.
So the Docs life was aborted - so what?! Someone with a right to choose decided he shouldn't live - how's that any different than abortion, fools?!
I condon his or her behavior for cold blooded murder.....tell me Mr "oh so Righetous" on the left.....how do you justfiy the cold blooded murder of an innocent baby??????????
Thats how christians spread the word of jesus. With bullets. I am glad to be an agnostic.
A sad day for our society. When will this madness stop?
The souls of Dr. Tiller and his killer will meet again, in one place. The souls of all the aborted fetuses will meet again, in another place. Like the Real Estate agent says, "Location, location, location!"
Left Wing WACKOS, you all are experts with your selective seeing and hearing, what a bunch of morons. Frankly I'm glad that the LEFT WING EXTREMIST JUDGES decide to MAKE law from the bench rather than inturpit it, like legalizing abortion. You can all abort yourselves hahahahaha! "What comes around goes around".
It amazes me how quick the LEFT is to condem someone on the right, but not condem someone on the left. This guy got his due, good ridins! hahahahahah!!!!!!!!!
I will grieve for Mr tiller for about the amount of time he spent mourning the BABIES that could have survied outside of the mother womb. Which we know was not long because there were more babies to MURDER!!!!!
Well I find it interesting he's a usher at church, when at the same time he is performing late term abortions, on live babies in the womb. I do not condone the killing by any means, but one side who condones killing babies, thinks there's no argument over a late term baby abortion, but rises up when another human kills a human being. Like in this case, one human being who killed human beings, was killed by another living human being. This doctor had no feelings about reaching in a womb and pulling a baby with arms and feet out, killing it as he did his deed. Killing is wrong no matter what side of the fence you are on, surely the wackos on both sides of the fence can agree on that.
I refer all you right wingers who want to force your religion on everyone (ever heard of "separation of Church and State"?) back to post #1.33 and challenge you to dispute what's said.
Any takers?
No......the Pro-Deathers like to state over and over again that abortion is legal in this country. Just like the killing of Jews was legal in Nazi Germany. The day of reckoning is coming whether libs like to believe it or not. Just take a look around. The balloon is about to burst.
I believe all groups , pro and con lose with this. This situation cannot further either groups position. I find it a sad day for both the pros and cons on the abortion issue.
I don't believe in abortion much less late term, but I do believe we all lost on this one. It can in no way further any of our positions.
Because it is so much easier to generalize someone when frustrated by a lack of understanding.
Pro-lifers see abortion as killing an innocent baby. Let me ask you this:
Would you use lethal force to stop a killer from harming a 1 month old? How bout a 2 week old? 1 day old? 1 minute old?
Choicers believe it is a civil rights issue, and in many ways it is. What greater civil right is there than the "right" to live?
Hey- I'm pro-life and this venal act in no way supported by the majority of pro lifers
Yeah right and I am Santa Clause .... Quick trip to your page finds you think Bush was the greatest thing since grits were invented and you are to the right of Limbaugh in a lot of cases. You are probably sitting at your computer grinning from ear to ear and popping a cork.
People who throw stones then do not want to be blamed for the broken glass should stop throwing stones. Anti abotionists are the new terrorists but choose to hide when their efforts come to culmination/
Those who claim that the unborn are just a piece of meat, just a parasite, and there is nothing in the Bible about life beginning at birth need to check out Jerimiah 1: 4-5.
As for this shooting, the man is a criminal and has no support of any pro-life group that I'm aware of, unlike the abortionist and all his supporters. Had it been turned around all the pro-abortionists would've just considered it late term abortion.
Although I disagree with the murder, I do agree that a gun should not have been used, but a pair of scissors and a suction pump as he used for his thousands of killings. He should have gotten to suffer some of the pain he inflicted on totally innocent babies.
Total agreement. These idiot libs who hide behind the law are just a bunch of hipocrits.
01/20/13...........Are we there yet?
what terrible news! my absolute condolences to Tiller's entire family. He is a doctor. A professor of the medical field. A human being with a family and a life. Terrible that some idiot decides that life for a life seems justified. Obviously the killer has to be a man. Since any woman, considerable of women's rights in general, would never go that far.
sorry to say this, but for the most part, this is a woman's right, choice, decision, and hardship. No man can nor will they ever know what it's like to have to go through something like an abortion. Not to say they have some say in it....but it's a woman's personal decision....and sometimes it is to preserve her own life. life is about choices, and that is a God-given right. No matter what religion you stand for.
He is up in heaven.....and I bet he is there with all the little babies that performed the procedure. He will protect, and they will protect him. I believe this whole heartily.
I agree Trish, if you say Pro Life, why would it ever be okay to kill someone. That actually sounds like a double standard and very confusing.
Thou shalt not kill, but then you kill someone! Be it conspirital or however who ever was a part of the discussion or plot, they should all pay for it tenfold!!!
"I refer all you right wingers who want to force your religion on everyone (ever heard of "separation of Church and State"?) back to post #1.33 and challenge you to dispute what's said.
Any takers?"
GOD! gives life and takes it away. We will all answer for what we have done someday. I for one will NEVER VOTE THAT IT IS OK TO KILL AN INOCENT LIFE!
The guy who killed the DR. He will answer for what he has done, as will you who give the aproval to take a life for what ever reason you think is justifable. I feel sorrow for you!
"separation of Church and State" has nothing to do with seperating Church and State as we know it. Seperation of Church and State was souley to keep the government from forcing a religion on us, NOT keeping God and religion out of government.
Most people think it is written in the constitution, due to the constant propaganda of the left. The constitution maintains we have freedom OF religion, that religion we want not one forced on us by a government.
YOU LEFT WINGERS ARE SO EAGER TO HAVE THE GOV RUN EVERYTHING, AND BEFORE BARACK HUSSEIN OBOMA IS OUT OF OFFICE IT WILL. WE WILL BE THE SOCIALIST GOV OF AMERICA AND SOCAILISM WILL REIGN SUPREME. HOPE YOU LIKE DICTATOR OBAMA.
AFTER THAT HAPPENS, YOU WON'T BE ABLE TO BLAME BUSH ANYMORE.
SO KEEP ON ABORTING YOURSELVES, MAYBE YOU'LL MANAGE TO KILL OFF ENOUGH OF YOURSELVES THAT WE CAN STILL SAVE THIS COUNTRY!
Late term abortions as well as abortions I cannot agree with. Yet, I still believe that we all lost with this situation. I think the guy should have been arrested along time ago and and charged. I do believe that Wade vs Roe, does not contemplant late term abortions unless the mother life is in danger. I stand corrected if I am wrong, but 1. I do not believe in abortions, much less late term, but I still think we all lost with what this guy did as well as who killed him. based on what he has been doing I would love to say he got the same treatment that he has been doing, but I can't. freedom of choice to terminate (stickily from the present law or rulings) , I believe do not contemplated late term abortions. But the whole situation I believe has hurt us all.
Michael-1127073
I'll take you up on it . I am not a pro life based on religion. I am pro life based on pro life, and as a moderate conservative maybe , and that's a big maybe depending on certain situations. but has nothing to do with my religious beliefs. Still say all groups lost with this one . And by the way i also don't believe in the death penalty
.
I like my church. Your church doesn't count. Beauty, ay?
To 1.35 -- Please show me in THE Bible where an unborn child is referred to as a "parasitical infection", or where the Bible "clearly states" that a chld is not alive until it receives the "breath of life".
Said Dan-410533:
Are you kidding me? I believe that these "right-to-life" organizations are just as guilty as the murderer, just as if EVERY LAST ONE OF THEM PULLED THAT TRIGGER THIS MORNING ON DR. TILLER. Just as any solicitor would be charged with murder in any murderer-for-hire, or if in the case of an accomplice being killed in the commission of a bank robbery. You would be equally as guilty.
How could Dan-410533 or any of the other "right-to-lifers" give the argument of "because you were not in the vacinity when this murderer murdered Dr. Tiller" that you couldn't possibly be blamed for it. Well hear this. I for one DOES BLAME THE ENTIRE ORGANIZATION FOR THIS MURDER. Anytime you "gin-up" your base, keep in mind that you have no idea of the mindsets, or the mental health of the folks you're "hopping" up with your nonsense. You have no idea how dangerous some of these folks are. While you "say" you wouldn't or did not pull the trigger, you have more than enough proof now that someone less mentally stable will and did pull the trigger.
YES... I HOLD THE ENTIRE ORGANIZATION EQUALLY RESPONSIBLE FOR THIS COLD BLOODED MURDER OF DR. TILLER... IN THE CHURCH OF GOD, while in the service of God. You can't have it both ways. You can't preach saving the life of the unborn, but not even hesitating to take the life of the born, in the name of your cause..... and even much, much worst..... in the name of God!!!
i may be selfish in my position, but I have a daughter that would give anything to adopted a baby and give the mother the rights to see her and pay for everything, but the costs are way out in left field. my oldest sister adopted one 36 years ago and she is beautiful. What I believe is that they have made a business out of adoption where potentially great parents cannot afford to adopted. There are so many out there that would just love to have a child That's why i say it it not religious based in my case.
Trish, who is condoning this?
And, can you share with me your inside information as to who is guilty of this crime?
As of 23 minutes ago there was no one confessing, no one arrested, no group taking responsibility.
What if it was a compassionate left-wing nut case who's daughter died after Tiller performed a late-term abortion on her?
Why not wait, instead of inciting hatred and being divisive, and see who is responsible.
Regardless, it is murder, and like any other murder should be tried in court.
You know, habeus corpus and all that rights stuff.
Prolife "nutters" are the biggest hypocrites. "If they told me it was me or the baby then they can take my life". Ok, Mccain I guess we will never know and take your word for it...NUTTERS.
To much religion dives a person insane, just look at the Arab world. There they stone you to dead, here they shoot you if you are not a believer like they are.
Galatians 6: 7 says it all.
Who has condoned this? What are you smoking?
Trish...........What do they say, Goes around comes around! He stopped all those little beating hearts and somebody stopped his!
The right to lifers are so adamant about not allowing abortions but when it comes to using tax money for babies born to drug and alcohol addicts who, as adults cannot function in the world and need help, then they're called lazy unproductive drains that don't deserve anything from the government. If you are against abortions because you consider it taking a life, then you need to be consistent and care for that life as long as it exists if it's unable to function, since you put yourself in the position of being responsible for it's existence. You can't have it both ways.
To the religious right the ends always justifies the means, no matter how unethical, illegal, or sinful the means are. Christ would be so ashamed of the things done in His Name.
This is exactly why the Founding Fathers were so opposed to any presence at all of religion in public life or government. This is why they wanted a "solid wall" between church and state. This is why people are more any more turning their face away from hateful forms of "Christianity" and towards non-affiliation.
Being a Christian is a lot easier that many think. You have eleven commandments to follow. Then you have a model of social behavior in Christ's own life to follow. And you have the intelligence to make moral and ethical decisions based on these two precepts.
It's interesting how they think they are performing justice. Rest assured the abortion doctor is in a better place, but I wonder where these religious nuts who think murdering doctors...where does the Bible say that murderers go. Last time I checked they go to hell. Especially if they shed innocent blood by premediation. Maybe justice can forgive crimes of passion. But justice for killing an innocent abortion doctor in my mind means you go to hell from what I know.
If you think that pro-life is God's philosophy, even in cases of rape and incest, then geesh, I think if you want to make a fight, that fight starts in influencing your state and federal lawmakers. Because not only is murder against God's law, it is also illegal to deprive someone of their right to live in this country without a court trial as per the Bill of Rights.
These idiots are enemies to their country and God. And yet they think they are doing someone a favor with their fanaticism.
Welcome to Religious Extremism... Hypocrisy at its Best.. You even see pro-lifers here in MA harassing even young teen girls who have been raped... I've seen a young girl get her face beat into the sidewalk by a Pro-life religious fanatic... These people are turning into Terrorists.. Not all Pro-lifers are this fanatical but most are in the realms of Radicalism where it can easily turned into something like this..
On the Subject its self... Most pro-lifers fail to even do any critical thinking on the subject.. They have no concept about keeping the human population in control... When does the idea of saving every life become more dangerous to the human race??.. If you think 9 billion people is over crowding and out of control..Imagine how much Raping of the Earth the human Race would do with a population of 15 billion... Pro-lifers are really this stupid.. Eventually they would either be forced to become self hypocrites of their own ideology or accept possible human extinction due to sheer stupidity..
It's bad enough that you can't drive 5 miles without seeing human trash all over the place.. Not to mention a plastic island twice the size of Texas in the Pacific ocean... And Pro-lifers seriously think that more people = sustainable happy life..
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Pacific_Garbage_Patch
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Then you have the multi-Billion dollar baby market... Which has more to do with the political war than actually saving a life... Anti-Abortion = Big profits in Adoption agencies, medical agencies, insurance companies, and drug companies..
Plus the illegal baby markets..
http://www.hinduonnet.com/fline/fl2211/stories/20050603006700400.htm
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Then you have what they call back alley abortions as well as trash/toilet babies... Another thing that pro-lifers try to ignore and scoff at as if it wouldn't happen.. Another shiny example of not having the ability to do any critical thinking at all..
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
And one of the biggest problems ever.. The sheer failure of current agencies to protect children from abusive home placements or even the ability to ensure educational development even in foster care...
If abortions were made illegal there would be NO SYSTEM CAPABLE of HANDLING the sheer numbers of children that would be injected into the already broken system... And where will all the money come from to ensure the needs of all these children? Are you going to pay for it? Are you going to pay for the medical expenses and health care of all the mothers you force to have children?
You are talking 10's of thousands of babies each year.. Maybe even upwards to a million in 10 years or even 10 million after that..Your developing a constant baby boom... And where will all these children going to go.?? Will you enslave the women to care for their own rapists children? What plan do you pro-lifers even have to protect these peoples lives? Do you even care?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
What's next.. Pro-lifers making sex laws to enforce their ideology? Prevent people from even talking to each other? Sounds like a Religious Police State in the making...
The pro-lifers are no better than the pro-choicers.
There is NO WAY that this murder can be justified. And to kill a man in Church, that is lower than low!
I don't see any of you commenting on this
ONLY THREE CLINICS!!!!!!!
Hey, would all you right-wing nutbags please moved to Texas and secede from the rest of us. You're NOT wanted in this country, PLEASE GET OUTA here.
Take your stupid Christianity with ya.
REDNECKS - just say NO.
LMarcT #1.33
Your logic escapes me. I understand ones birth takes place on the day their mother gives birth to them. What I don't understand is how this can be interpreted to mean that human life did not exist within the mother's womb prior to the day she gave birth to the child. Logic tells me that when a woman is pregnant she is carrying an unborn child in her womb. Each day of her pregnancy which began at conception the unborn child is growing and developing. When references are made to the birth of individuals in the bible or in historical writings logic tells me that the mothers of these individuals carried them in the womb for a full term pregnancy until the day of their birth. I agree an unborn child is totally dependent on its mother for its existence and I recognize that dependence doesn't end at the moment the child is born. There is life in the womb before the child is born and there is life outside the womb after the birth of the child.
Your logic works for you pal but it doesn't work for me. There are laws on the books where if during the murder of a pregnant woman her unborn child is also killed the killer can face two counts of murder. Where does that fit in your logic wise one.
Auteur 1536,
I suppose you are Pro-Neutral? Which would mean you could care less if a Child dies or if the World has a complete Ecological Collapse that leads to the extiction of the human race becaus pro-lifers have no concept of population control and responsibility... But Hey, Trash babies and back alley abortions under Religious Law seems like a new wonderful world eh?
khollo4:
One very good verse is in Genesis, chapter 2:
7 the LORD God formed the man from the dust of the ground and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life, and the man became a living being.
Notice, the man did not become a living being until after he had taken the breath of life. Prior to that time, the man was NOT a living being, it was merely a lump of dust formed in the image of the creator. It's very sad that you have not even read into the second chapter of the first book of your holy text and profess yourself to be like the one you deify. It's even sadder that you would blindly condemn another person based on the ignorance which you seem to so fully possess.
As for the parasitical infection part, that is simple science. If a creature needs to feed off of a host (in this case, the mother) in order to survive, it is considered a parasite. If you cut a fetus out of its mother, it will die, ergo it is a parasite until it has received the breath of life (i.e. come to term and been born), at which time it is considered a baby (i.e. a small human, but without all of the rights accorded to fully developed humans).
LMarcT
Excellent post! I hope your 5-point itemized list gets picked up and published in some national magazines.
It's hard to paint all non-choice individuals with the same brush, but when they insist on calling abortion, stem-cell research, and even condom use murder, they are in fact promoting this abhorent behavior.
Demanding that everyone else conform to their own personal views exhibits an enormous character flaw ... this probably explains why we don't see any anti-abortion people being murdered by pro-choice folks.
thecryingprophet,
lets talk Genesis and the bibles hypocrisy and immorality...
Concerning Religion on this subject.. It's pretty hypocritical to claim immorality.. Especially for a Religioun that claims to be a Religion of "Unconditional Love" and with a deity that is supposed to "Love us ALL"... This religious ideological construct around the concept of a deity is entirely a ideological Hypocrisy.. And yes IT"S NOT JUST THE RELIGIOUS spewing their HATE over this... But the Church is the Primary Funder and the Primary adovcate to spreading and lobbying for anti-Gay/Lesbian Laws... And here is a Prime example of Hate, spite, hypocrisy and extremism by their very own dear lord..!
On religion for example.. Extremism and hate do exist in the literature.. The bible for example has these two versus:
6:7
" 7And the LORD said, I will destroy man whom I have created from the face of the earth; both man, and beast, and the creeping thing, and the fowls of the air; for it repenteth me that I have made them."
Not only is the GOD stating that he "Hates" you, he is also stating that he hates "ALL" living things..That means your dog too Dorthy... And along side the hate and regret he shows complete contempt to massacre in pure genocidal rage of every living thing innocent or not... That is extremism.. That is hate.. This is not "LOVE"
6:17
"And, behold, I, even I, do bring a flood of waters upon the earth, to destroy all flesh, wherein is the breath of life, from under heaven; and every thing that is in the earth shall die."
According to the Bible it seem that GOD is more like a Devil.. A Hitler... Is the Bible the devil in sheep's clothing? How can a "Deity" that is supposed to be a Supernatural Being of Unconditional Love filled with Equal or greater hate than a Terrorist blowing up a Club of teenagers...
IS GOD REALLY IN MANS IMAGE?
You toss in the commandment "Thou Shall Not Kill" And you suddenly feel like you are living on the Island of Dr Monroe! A supposed GOD/Creator that Blames its beasts of creation for any wrongs it may have done.. As if injecting free will and free thought wouldn't have Logically led to something going wrong.. As if giving Man the ability to sin wouldn't result in just that... If man was to be created in his image he should have intelligently designed man with the inability to "SIN".. It would have saved this "GOD" a lot of trouble and a lot of souls from apparently going to hell...
Interestingly, the Beasts of creation on Island of DR Monroe learn that their GOD really is not a GOD at all.. They learn that "FEAR" and "FEAR MONGERING" of the HOUSE OF PAIN (HELL) Was purely a means to Control the Beasts (People)..
The Island of Dr Monroe is an example of science and religion gone wrong when used for power, control, and personal ambitions..
WAS MAN REALLY CREATED IN GODS IMAGE?
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
More genocidal thoughts from your dear Lord:
7:4 For yet seven days, and I will cause it to rain upon the earth forty days and forty nights; and every living substance that I have made will I destroy from off the face of the earth.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Some gave me this little number to explain this
"straining the gnat, and swallowing the camel"?
Has to do with ecological risk.. It has an interesting false merit play on the subject but doesn't necessarily pertain to the subject.. Ecological Risk has little to do with threats of genocide.. I could threaten to wipe out Bolder Gate by blowing up the hoover damn.. It can be considered and Ecological risk but yet done with intent... Those verses do not reflect Ecological Risks because the are not "Warnings".. The context is in clear premeditated threats with motive... To say you hate something and then to destroy it does not equate to Ecological Risk..
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
How about Favoritism that lead to Cain Slewing his Brother.. two immoral acts in one story.. And god didn't even understand why Cain was Wroth? He had to ask even after obviously disrespecting him in favor for his brothers when he could simply have taken both offering with equal respect... Abel may have not been slewed..Ouch
4:3 And in process of time it came to pass, that Cain brought of the fruit of the ground an offering unto the LORD.
4:4 And Abel, he also brought of the firstlings of his flock and of the fat thereof. And the LORD had respect unto Abel and to his offering:
4:6 And the LORD said unto Cain, Why art thou wroth? and why is thy countenance fallen?
4:7 If thou doest well, shalt thou not be accepted? and if thou doest not well, sin lieth at the door. And unto thee shall be his desire, and thou shalt rule over him.
4:8 And Cain talked with Abel his brother: and it came to pass, when they were in the field, that Cain rose up against Abel his brother, and slew him
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Self serving/protective hypocritical logic..
Lamech kills a man and claims that since Cain's murderer would be punished sevenfold, whoever murders him will be punished seventy-seven fold.. 4:23-24
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
So before you Start Casting your Stones of Damnation I suggest you look into your own Ideologies Immoral, hateful, disrespectful, and extremist views... The immorality and hypocrisy is just Sheerly Astounding in this ideology.. And then you wonder why they are out there to ban and spread their fear and hate upon what they view as an immorality...
When does it become a hypocrisy.. If you are true believer then you follow the above immoral concepts and justifiable... You become no better than the Evil you protest..
I don't know about you.. But I can't follow an ideology this immoral, this filled with hate, this "GOD" that hates you so much that he will even kill your Dog too!
I can see a few anti choicers and supposed religiously ethical people showing their callousness for themselves by saying this murder is a 201st trimester abortion!
You aren't giving into faith..or life ...You are entering into un-healthy thought.
ABANDON ALL HOPE YEE WHO ENTER, is your mantra, not, "Do unto others as you would have them do unto you." Your idea isn't "help a person" as Jesus said, it is:
"Punish the wrong doer! ANY wrong doer...EVERY WRONGDOER! FIND THE WRONG DOER!!!! There HAS TO BE A WRONG DOER around here TO PUNISH!!"
Take a breath.....another one........
Remember, You are assuming the Bible and Genesis to be a FACT and not Fiction based on Faith alone when in fact it is a self admitted book written by man himself and not by a "GOD"... That would logically conclude that the Bible is a human ideological construct around the idea or belief in a god..
This does not mean there is no GOD... That will always remain an unprovable.... Just don't go around claiming the bible is a book of Facts when it clearly is not..
For example:
Many Religious people claim god is Unconditional love that possesses infinite and ultimate Knowledge.. And yet the bible shows repeatedly that GOD even Admits to making mistakes.. Such as creating man to the point of committing world genocide on every living thing...
Or the fact he even has to ask Cain why is wroth after obviously showing no respect for him over his brother... These are human and mortal traits you would not expect to find in an all Knowing supernatural being supposedly not capable of making mistakes... Even I know the correct and logical answer was to show respect to both Able and Cain for what they offered..
Another problem is why is Cain and Able making offerings to a GOD? Is god this egotistical or self righteous that he demands to be worshiped? ... I could literally go on for days about how illogical most of the bible really is...
Most people that read the bible and believe it fail to do any critical thinking what so ever on the material and literature...
The pro-lifers don't really even need to make sex laws. Fornication is technically still illegal in most states as a misdemeanor offense, even though it is not enforced. Some states have struck down or are beginning to strike down laws preventing casual sex.
No person that is pro-life has condoned the murder of this murdering doctor. I feel sorry for him and his family. I hope that God has mercy on his soul for the hundreds maybe thousands of murder's he has committed over his lifetime. We pro-life people respect the dignity of all life, unlike you pro-choice people. You believe people should have the choice to murder if they want to, so you should agree with the man who murdered this doctor. Alot of families want to adopt, give the baby to them don't KILL it!! Read the statistics, majority of late term abortions are done on healthy babies! Even if it's going to be handicap is that a reason to kill it? Doesn't it's life have any value? I don't know of too many handicap people out there committing crimes, assulting, murdering, stealing, do you? Seems its us healthy people doing all the bad stuff!
I agree, he had as much of a right-to-live as the thousands of babies he killed.
jbird-557056,
You do not know if that is true.. You only know that no pro-lifer on this site has not condoned this course of action... You fail to realize the differences between those of Personal Opinion, Radicals, and Extremists on the subject... To say no Pro-Lifer condones this course of action is entirely false..
Don't you love how the spout about everyones right to live then this happens? Everyone deserves to live EXCEPT this guy right? When I get to hell for being a pro-choicer I'll save you hypocrites a seat. Try notbeing so self righteous. It must be exhausting.
hey, the low down TRUTH ... you play with FIRE, you will get BURNED...BEWARE: dangerous territory...choose to help people, rather than destroy them..subtle terrorism is for real !! population control is for real..real times, real choices, please think EVERYTHING OUT real hard okay........
omg!! there has been far more killed by liberal left wing environmentalist .unabomber ring a bell hows about obama's good friend ayers. murder is murder be it abortion doctor or a timber industry lobbyist etc. you people are insane get help before you do the same thing these nuts do.Republican and Democrats parties are nothing more than cults.
Natasha you also have to look at the fact that most Religious Pro-Lifers live by a book filled with absolute hypocrisy.. It's is why the Bible and Especially Christians are considered by most to be hypocrites without any attempt to think anything through with logical thinking... Pro-lifers wouldn't realize how anti-life that concept was until man Raped Earth down to it's Molten Core... In fact if they were the last man standing they would probably still not realize how idiotic they are.. This is why religious ideologies are so dangerous... It literally makes people stupid and easily controlled...
Pro-Life is a noble thing.. But Pro-life also means being smart enough to maintain a sustainable population.. Otherwise your whole concept collapses on its self and then you end up killing everyone if not everything...
It is even proven that over crowding infuses violence... Put a large number of people in a small room long enough they will kill eachother.. Make them fight for resources and it would become a massacre.. Same thing with Rats or any animal.. Eventually Extiction soon follows...
Imagine The United States with 2 billion people... Imagine the Trash and polution that would cause.. Hell imagine what would happen to the natural wild life.. America would get stripped bare... Disease and violence would rise.. more people would die vs just simply controlling the population and allowing things like abortions....
In fact making abortion illegal would directly result in huge increases in crime, murder, rape, theft ectra by the sheer increase of rejected children who would thus join or even create gangs... Or simply go on a murderous rampage.... Basically you are creating a baby market to large for even those who can not have babies.. You are creation a Huge propblem that No agency on Earth could ever dream of handling... Those cracks become gaping wholes where children become life long victims of your Stupidity..
SniprKlr:
You should really read posts before you start ranting at people. I posted a verse (in response to someone's request for documentation of my assertions) indicating that fetuses aren't living creatures until they have the breath of life within them and you attack me as if I was some right-wing pro-life zealot condoning the murder and terrorist action that was perpetrated today...WTF?!? Get a clue, lay of the booze, take your meds (or whatever you need to do to get your drawers out of the bunch they're in) and RELAX!
I was only trying to add to the post vs objecting to it :P... I wasn't directly responding to you.. So I guess it was pointless to do so :/... I also didn't suggest you were "a right winger" Most of that post had to do with other people and not you... WHen I said "you also have to look at" did not imply that You are involved in anything that I had discussed.... Nothing there was an attack on you... So relax :)
Wow, these comments by people like NBBSBC82, Conservatismworks, Michael-1127073, Carlos-1031503, me-321567 and JB-784265 demonstrate just how unbalanced and unhinged these radicals truly are. They believe in God yet they condone murder in a place of worship???? Since you guys are so "pro-life" I was just wondering how many children have you adopted to help with the problem of children who have no family or home?
And on the very first word you once again want to force your religion on people. And as one person stated on this thread, the religious nuts don't object much to the killing of a doctor in the church in which he worshipped!
Try again. Read post #1.33, then try to refute it...
Sniprklr:
Sorry, I assumed that since you had my name at the top of your post in bold font that your post was directed towards me. My bad. No harm, no foul. I would like to add that you do raise some valid points, most of which are attributable to the role of religion as a tool of statecraft and the fact that people actually wrote the bible rather than some dvine personage. Have a good day, and look luck in your desire to educate the misguided herd creatures who are our brethren.
Not sure where this will end up, but I agree with Mr. Rogers, and note that once again low browed, ignoble people respond out of their diminished capacity to understand these issues.
Say on, Mr. Rogers. It's only truth, yeah?
Abortion supporters like to use the term "pro-choice" when referring to abortion, a system whereby one group of individuals decides if another group of individuals will live or die. But how can abortion principles sensibly be called "pro-choice" when those who do the killing make all the choices and those who do the dying get no choices? This is tantamount to calling the Jewish Holocaust a "pro-choice" exercise. After all, that's what it was for the Germans.
Because Rhonda we don't live in a perfect world.. That choice could mean saving the child from a life far worse than the death its self.. I really don't think you are grasping the magnitude this would cause in society... It's basically building a massive refugee camp of rejected children.. Nearly 50% of rejected children commit suicide or get involved in criminal activity... You would also thus be injecting 10's of thousands of rejects into an already broken system unable to handle the current flow of rejected children or orphans...
Several reviews have been conducted over the years and in all cases said agencies couldn't even find the children they were taking care of..Even when they were in their own facilities.. 300 children in the last 5 years have been sold on illegal baby markets... 45 children had been sold to slavery... 20% have been placed in abusive homes... Nearly,10- 30% commit suicide...
And who is going to pay for all of this Rhonda? If you are going to force labor you should thus be responsible for paying for it.. And that includes the child care, medical, education to insure a stable life in a secure home... I don't think that is a realistic option here... You are talking about taking 1 immoral act and creating 1 massive immoral problem...
The irony is that most of the anti-abortion people tend to favor Republican politics, believing that the Republicans both support their church and oppose abortion, which undoubtedly means that they would oppose the taxes necessary to sustain all those unwanted children...
Whoever did this is a domestic terrorist and needs to be tried and treated as such.
Agreed!
Philosophically speaking, everything is political.
He should be treated as a demostic terrrorist scum bag..
Ship him to gitmo!
Terrorists do not get "rights". If they do it needs to be applied the same to the ones being held in GITMO. Terrorists are International and Domestic criminals and both need to be held to the same judicial process.
I cringe when I think that every time an doctor who performs abortions in a clinic is killed, we are one step closer to overturning Roe v. Wade. It's a woman's right to terminate a pregnancy. It's even more so when the child wouldn't be viable and it would only suffer (or die immediately after birth). Do people not think?
No he needs to be tried as a murderer and executed as all murderers should be. Do we agree?
Per Mr. Obama you can use that word anymore, shame on you! But again, one murder was executed, why not kill the other one too. Good point.
Sounds nicer that way doesn't it. Kind of like canceling a credit card....
Right... because doctors are always so right. Case in point. A couple friend of ours was told that if they allowed their pregnancy to continue the baby would 100% for certain die and the mother would 70% die. The relied on their faith and decided to keep the baby. During the pregnancy, they said the baby was developing down syndrome, deformities in the arms and legs, yet they went on with the pregnancy.
There baby is now 18 months old and is 100% healthy without ANY of the conditions. Oh, the mom is doing fine as well.
Now, I would have respected their choice to not follow through because who can judge people that have to make such difficult decisions. That being said, it was a wonderful experience to see their faith pay and to witness a child most people would have never let be born.
mr rogers.....be quiet
Mr. Rogers: since you are such an asinine right-winger, let me set you straight:
You are entirely too insane if you think that folks who decide to terminate a pregnancy make such decisions without weighing every consequence. You make it sound as if folks who have to undergo such procedures due to necessity are evil--I find it evil that you seem to think you have a right to judge them. Or me, for that matter, for my beliefs. I do not advocate using pregnancy as birth control--but I do find that a safe, legal abortion is a right women have--and until Roe v. Wade is overturned, that's a fact. So deal with it and stop judging others.
No, doctors aren't always right--but the odds are the odds. Your friends have a healthy baby--I'm happy for them and that's their choice. But so many other parents have to terminate pregnancies because they're developing in the wrong area, thus endagering the woman, the child is deformed or otherwise not well-developed, and you think you have a right to judge those people, let alone doctors?
When you get a medical degree, and decide to help couples and their pregnancies, you can talk. In the meantime, you're just a wacko right-winger who thinks everyone is entitled to your idiot opinion.
And let me tell you something--opinions are like arseholes--everybody's got one. However, I hate to tell you: it just doesn't mean everyone is entitled to yours. So, shove it. And a criminal act like murder is still a crime. It's not justified. And somehow I picture you, and I see someone who lives in the fringes of society, willing to murder someone because you disagree with what they do? You're a wack job alright.
Good point! The doctors are very often wrong. The horror stories are many. Let's face it. We have gotten to the point where we don't want to decide for ourselves. If you knew what I know about doctors, you wouldn't be so inclined to worship them.
who ever did this should be tried in court by a jury of his/her peers, as called for by the Constitution of the United States. No different than any other person who commits murder.
Mr. Rodgers
A good post and thoughtful. You give us an example of a problem that happened to turn out well of, but what if it had not? What if the baby was born without a brain or so severely impaired that it could never live without being on life support, perhaps for decades? Of course, this is hypothetical, never the less this happens more often than not.
In olden times Doctors or mid wives would take the still born or severely impaired and kill them because they knew that this child would become a severe handicap to the survival of the family or to the mother. Abortion is not some latter day problem at all. But, it has taken on a religious and political face because of the openness of the issue.
To those who oppose abortion for religious reasons hear the words of Jesus as He replied to the question of whether or not it was lawful to pay the Roman tax, "Give unto Caesar that which is Caesar's, and unto God that which is God's." You are in this world but not of this world. Let the world lookout for itself and work out your own salvation. None of us are above judgement. All things in due time.
In this country abortion is legal. If you are opposed to it, don't do it. You do not have the right to tell another what to do. It is their choice and they will answer for their choice. You can not gain "favor" with God by doing what YOU think He wants you to do. Read your Bible. It's there for YOUR salvation, not for you to "earn" your way into his good grace.
Dear Mr Rogers, first you say:
Then you say, in the very same post:
Now which is it? Are you judging or are you not?
Lkessler, well said. I don't think I'll even post anything else on this board. I definitely couldn't say it any better than that.....right on.
Mr. Rogers.
"Nutters". No one likes abortion even prochoice. It is a terriable thing to do but I guess some think they know better..the same ones never forced to make a choice...the same ones that called preggo teens a "tragedy" until Palin's unwed, minor daughter had one.
lkessler.... "And let me tell you something--opinions are like arseholes--everybody's got one. However, I hate to tell you: it just doesn't mean everyone is entitled to yours. ... You're a wack job alright."
Yet, everyone is entitled to your opinion???
I disagree. He shouldn't be considered a domestic terrorist, he should be treated just like any other accused murderer - no better, no worse.
How many full term babies did he kill with the "partial birth abortion" procedure.
While I don't condone what happened to him, I certainly would not be able to condone what he did either. Galatians 6: 7.
The pro-life strikes again. So overwhelmed with the concept of "pro-life", they murder.
I don't believe in Jesus, God, Budda, Allah, the Easter Bunny, Santa Claus, or the tooth fairy...
But, isn't, "thous shall not kill", one of their Top Ten?
Unfortunately, I live in the city where they just arrested this psycho. His name is Scott Roeder. He's been a sicko for quite a while.....
Here's some other info on him:
July 7, Kansas: Scott Roeder is sentenced to sixteen months in state prison for parole violations following a 1996 conviction for having bomb components in his car trunk. Roeder, a sovereign citizen and tax protester, violated his parole by not filing tax returns or providing his social security number to his employer.
Because Newt and Rush told him to do it? You are as Extreme as the person that Murdered this Doctor.. its Extremism on both sides that is the problem in this country
OMG!
Environmentalist left winger nuts and Liberal commie nuts have killed far more than the right to life nuts
Una bomber ring a bell hows about Obamas buddy William ayers? ETC! So should all left wingers who believe in the same things as them be considered terrorist ?Democrat and Republican parties have turned into dangerous cults.Get help before you end up doing the same thing as these nuts.
I'm just glad that this Doctor's "quality" health care for women wasn't available to my mother.
The human race, for some odd reason, follows politicos like cattle to a cow bell. Once we all stop making everyone's personal business our own business and keep our own back yards clean we'll experience a much more peaceful world.
The politicos keep kicking these types of issues around because they can get you to vote based on their positions. Quit trying to legislate other people's lives to fit your idea of how life should be. Walk away from this way of thinking and living.
This shooter was so enraged by ideologies and believed that somehow 'the system' would make everyone behave, in the way he wanted, that when that didn't happen he shot this guy.
Leave each other alone people. Let these issues die. Sheesh. Don't react to everything you read in the papers, on the internet, on the news. The information barrage has led us to believe that our own opinion matters on every single issue. They don't matter. In fact they can lead to violence. Get a life of your own and stay out of others' lives.
Let's all hope the individual acted alone. America is a Country of laws that have been developed over our existence. This act was clearly murder in the eyes of the law. Abortion is not murder in the eyes of the law. If you disagree change the laws, but until you do it is murder.
Murder is murder no matter how it is committed.
Of course, Obambi is outraged. He probably wanted him for Head of the Health and Human Services. After all they shared the same views on abortion.
your right Lkessler doctors aren't always right. In fact they are rarely correct but because they went to a liberal college they can say and do what they want and have no accountability.
Try to look up the complaints against a given doctor by patients. Even in the lawfirm were I work we cant even get that kind of information.
I know of two different individuals that should be blind. In fact the doctors told both of them they would be blind. Both recovered fully.
I too have a friend that was told that his wife was going to die after the baby was born in an emergency C section. 5% chance of survival and they intended on letting her die and told him to say goodbye. He chose an alternate action and she is alive and in perfect health. I have had at least two other friends that have recieved great results on their physical, cardiac exams, ect... Both died shortly after leaving the doctors office. Apparently its normal to be healthy and just up and die.
The odds are just numbers some clown generated in a simulated computer program. I have seen doctors wrong more times than right on their assessments of patients. Those odds are posted nowhere. Your opinion is basically worth no value. Quit the name calling.
The doctor is no better than the murderer. For those that like to justify these acts in a religious forum I believe the fact that one of the ten commandments, "thou shalt not kill makes the point quite clear." Doesn't say get knocked up and its okay, doesn't say if it will be difficult to raise a child, doesn't say if you chooose not to carry someone elses child that you don't love. It says thou shalt not kill. This guy was mocking the church by even attending. Personally I think its great that someone has the guts to stand up for what they believe in.
In fact they are rarely correct but because they went to a liberal college they can say and do what they want and have no accountability.
Where do you get your information?
I look at it this way, yes it is a tragedy but Tiller "The Baby Killer" as he was oftenly referred to will now face his creator much faster. It is with God that his judgement now lies and may will view this as justice, all be it, twisted justice!
Mr rogers, would you please try and stay out of my panties. And just keep you hand on your own, please.
I think this is not the time to be arguing pro-choice/pro-life issues. A man was shot down in cold blood. I am pro-life, and so that makes me very sad. How ironic that the murderer committed the very act of ending a life, that he claims to be wrong. My sympathy to the family and friends of this victim.
It's a shame those people who claim to worship Jesus
can be so judgmental and full of hate to gun someone
down at church. How would they like us gunning them
down because they think differently than most? What
the hell is wrong with these people?
What this animal did is wrong. He should have let God deal with him in due time. This doctor is now dealing with God on the dispicable murders he inflicted on so many helpless babies in their mothers womb. May he be repentant...
hurrah for the shooter. Hope the dr has a special seat in hell for all the babies he killed.
"Tiller .....said the issue was about giving women a choice when dealing with technology that can diagnose severe fetal abnormalities before a baby is born."
Sounds very altruistic, except that the article failed to mention that Tiller's reputation was not of terminating "severe fetal abnormalities", but terminating healthy, full term abortions using the Partial Birth procedure, wherein a healthy baby's head is delivered, then the baby is killed by the doctor, and then the rest of the baby (now dead) is delivered. He would apparently perform this procedure on anyone for a fee, without regard for the "health of the mother" or any supposed "fetal abnormalities".
I can't condone what happened to him, but .........
It is with deepest sympathy that I express my condolences to the family and friends of Dr. Tiller. I was introduced to Dr. Tiller in October of 2005 when I had found out that the baby that I was carrying would be born with congenital defects that no medicine or surgery could correct. It was a life changing experience that I will take with me to the end. He saved me, my family, and by unborn fetus a life of agony, anguish, and hardship. It was the most difficult decision I had to make. In addition to myself being at the clinic, there were other women there; not to abort a child that was healthy, but a fetus that was grossly deformed or sick. I would never wish the heartache I had to go through on an enemy but wish that they could catch a glimpse of what it feels like to have to make the decision that I made. There were thousands of letters of gratitude to Dr. Tiller posted throughout the clinic. Dr. Tiller was a professional, sincere, and caring physician that came highly recommended from renowned genetic doctors that I spent countless hours with trying to negotiate the results to painful testing that I endured only to find out the inevitable. There is no reason for a woman to continue a pregnancy that could endanger her life or the life of her unborn fetus. The world has evolved enough to know that women are entitled to make these choices on their own without the added burden of the world coming down on them. Instead of investing all the time it takes to protest, why not take the time to volunteer and counsel women that have had to go through the nightmare of losing a baby or take the time to volunteer and help the children that are abused or the vulnerable that cannot speak for themselves and have been taken advantage of by family members. Why not focus your negative energy on the selfless acts of "church-going" citizens that impregnate their 12 year old nieces or daughters. Choose the battle that is worth fighting, don't make the lives of people that have lived through this experience worse than what it was. I drove 60 straight hours from Toronto, Ontario, Canada to meet Dr. Tiller and don't regret any second of it. I sympathize deeply with the clients scheduled to meet with Dr. Tiller in the future, because he is the only one that was willing to help the people that nobody else would. Something that has stuck with me since meeting Dr. Tiller was that he said "pregnancy doesn't begin with a positive test, it begins with the first thought that you want to have a baby". It couldn't have been a more honest and sincere quote; we had been trying for some time to get pregnant, only to have to give the baby up. What about the staff at the clinic who have to worry about their own fate each day, what about their livelihoods? Are those protestors going to take in those families because they no longer have a job to go to? Pro-life? Isn't that what Dr. Tiller was doing? Grow up.
I've scanned the vine and this is the best comment I have seen so far on this:
Anthony Colasanto | May 31, 2009 2:24 PM | Reply
We still do not know the reason why George Tiller was killed. Nevertheless, the pro-life movement does not favor the killing for any reason! We seek the conversion and not the killing of those whom we hope and pray will be won over by our love and by the love of Jesus as has happened with many former abortion providers and pro-abortionists like Dr. Bernard Nathanson (co-founder of NARAL) and Norma McCorvey (the "Jane Roe" of Roe vs. Wade). For a few examples, see: http://prolifeaction.org/providers/
We as pro-lifers believe that God does not desire the death of the sinner, but that he repent and live (Ezekiel 18:32; 33:11)
We do not fight violence with violence or murder with murder. We are committed to fighting the culture of death through prayer and through education. That has been the constant message of pro-lifer leaders and advocates for decades.
It is wrong for people who oppose pro-lifers to use this as an opportunity to accuse us with the false sweeping generalization that "pro-lifers" are violence. It is a well documented fact that "pro-choicers" commit more acts of violence compared to pro-lifers. http://abortionviolence.com/
Finally, I will keep George Tiller and his family in my thoughts and prayers. My heart is saddened for them as they face this tragedy. May they find joy and peace in the love and forgiveness of our Blessed Lord and Savior Christ Jesus.
This is not an issue of Politics certainly not all Democrats are pro choice and not all Republicans are Pro life. And Murder is wrong and I think everyone here would agree. But, this was a terrible man who did very late term abortions nearly full term pregnancies. I would think the most people would also agree that is wrong also! I am a pro choice person. But I do not think a full term babies should be aborted to me that is murder.
To Annalouise...
Hmmm...How Christian of you. Rather than judge him, some who felt he was taking lives would be saddened that his life was taken prematurely... by another human being, who put himself in the place of judgement. How do you know the plans God had for him?
GaLiberal Your statement is ridiculous!
I think the killer should be prosecuted and sent to jail just like any other murderer. I don't believe the government should kill citizens so prison would be my choice. I can't speak for God on any of the important issues, I am not so sure anyone can.
Roy Wilson - most of your post is wrong - late term abortions are illegal without specific medical reasons, so he was not performing them for anyone and everyone who could pay.
I'll bet this seed (and ones on the same topic) will get the most action of any seed this year.
That being said, I am glad to know that Tiller, the serial killer, has been brought to vigilante justice. Yes, the shooter will be tried, likely convicted and punished, but that is because of a "choice" he made. I'm reasonably certain that he weighed the consequences and still chose to abort Tiller's life.
What comes around, goes around. Perhaps this will serve as a deterrent for med students who are wondering if they should provide abortions.
Those of you who think abortion is legal are right, it IS legal. However, it being legal does in no way make killing babies 'right'.
A major question I have is how Tillman has kids and grandkids since his whole livelyhood was based on killing babies. I know if I'd been his child I'd have kept my bedroom door lock, bolted and braced!!!
Actually the killer, no doubt a Christian, was just doing what a good Christian is instructed to do by their leader, a terrorist named Jesus. The bible is in fact a nasty, evil, barbaric work of pure fiction conjured up by a bunch of superstitious bronze-age tribesmen.
Now before anyone objects to this I have proof, sourced from the bible noted below:
If ANYONE can deny the words mentioned below as not being truthful then please have at ‘er. Some of the material comes from the old testament which Jesus fully supported and here is proof of that:
Matthew 5:17" Do not think that I have come to abolish the law or the prophets. I have come not to abolish but to fulfill. Amen, I say to you, until heaven and earth pass away, not the smallest part or the smallest part of a letter will pass from the law, until all things have taken place."
Now that I have that out of the way, people always say “what would Jesus do?” Let's take a look shall we?
Punishment for disrespecting ones parents:
Matthew 15:4 Because God said, 'Honor your father and your mother,' and 'Whoever curses father or mother must certainly be put to death.'
Punishment for working on Sunday:
Exodus 31:15 'For six days work may be done, but on the seventh day there is a sabbath of complete rest, holy to the LORD; whoever does any work on the sabbath day shall surely be put to death.
Punishment for those who are the enemy of Jesus:
Luke 19:27 But as for these enemies of mine who did not want me to be king over them—bring them here and slaughter them in my presence (spoken by Jesus).
What to do with young women who have been raped:
Deuteronomy 22:28-29 “If a man is caught in the act of raping a young woman who is not engaged, he must pay fifty pieces of silver to her father. Then he must marry the young woman because he violated her, and he will never be allowed to divorce her.”
Jesus teachings regarding slaves:
Luke 12:47 "And that slave who knew his master's will and did not get ready or act in accord with his will, will receive many lashes”
What an assh#le.
hey, you play with FIRE, you get BURNED..just thank God, you never became a victim of these atrocities...the sensible solution to all this is; EDUCATION and PREVENTION..it should be remedial in early education, and more progressive as years go by..please, if humanity is smart about this dilemma, we would not have to end up so brutal and unsophisticated about all this..
One more bit of proof as evidence of just how nasty and hypocritical Christians truly are.
Please read the post noted above by micrometer. The standards of a good Christian.
What ever happened to Matthew 5:44: "But I say to you, love your enemies, and pray for those who persecute you"
But then hell if your master Jesus doesn't even live up to thse fine words why then should those mental-cowards who follow in his footsteps?
tiller the Killer reaps his rewards.
Violence begets violence. The shooter is a murderer and so is the "doctor" How sad. And so is the fact that in this day and age of hard core sexuality on the tube and sex ed in school, yet abortion and teen pregnancies still continue
btw, Everyone...view a late term abortion lately? Hopefully you won't soon.
I've seen the results of late-term abortions, college students at my old high school would protest with pictures of late-term abortion babies in front of the school cafeteria.
Our local news reported the man arrested has priors for possession of explosives, and said to have ties to some militia group. Where is Homeland Security when you need them? Oh yeah, frisking 80-year-old ladies in wheel chairs at the airport. (I actually have witnessed that twice.)
Another Timothy McVeigh.
I remember noticing after 9-11 that our domestic abortion clinic evangelical bombers slowed or stopped the acts of terror. They're baaaaa-aaack. Jesus Camp 101
Capt Tripps
"Roy Wilson - most of your post is wrong - late term abortions are illegal without specific medical reasons, so he was not performing them for anyone and everyone who could pay."
Dr. Tiller had a reputation for being willing to perform late-term abortions for specious reasons - hence the trial against him.
I am willing to bet that some group that is against abortion is involved. What does it take, some minister to say this man should not live? I am sure that many have already said it to some one at some time. It took them three times, but they finally got him. Flat out premeditated murder!
I am outraged over the amount of Comments collapsed by the community. I want to read everyones opinion.
Are you talking about the doctor who killed full term babies? or the guy who killed the guy who killed full term babies.
I condone this behavior however lets talk about a baby that is over 5 months old and this man sucked their brains out so they would die........can we have that discussion or is it too sickening???????
Sam...very truthfully, you do not even deserve a reply, but as you have choose to take verses out of context, and misquote and misinterpret, I have this to say,
The law, is the ten commandments, one of which is "Thou shall not kill".
The quote is, "For God commanded 'Honor your father and your mother,' and, 'He who speaks evil of father or mother, let him surely die'. But you say, 'If any one tells his father or his mother, What you would have gained from me is given to God, he need not honor his father.' So for the sake of your tradition, you have made void the word of God. You hypocrites! Well did Isaiah prophesy of you when he said; 'This people honors me with their lips, but their heart is far from me; in vain do they worship me, teaching as doctrines the precepts of men'" Matthew 15; 4-9 Speaking "evil" would be speaking lies, deception, dishonesty...and "let him surely die" refers to spiritual death that person would bring upon himself... not murder. The message Jesus was giving was the hypocrisy that "men's religious rules" sometimes carried within them...and in actuality, those rules (or traditions) were in direct conflict with God's Will and Law (the commandments) for His people.
That quote is the end of a parable, (a story used for instructing...to draw a comparison...used to teach a deeper moral or spiritual truth). Thus, it is open for interpretation...and not all Christians understand it to be showing the "nobleman" who speaks the words you quote (and whom is also refered to in the parable as, "a severe man, who take what you did not lay down, and reap what you did not sow"), to be representative of God. Some see this "nobleman", to be representative of those men/women in power, who exploit and mistreat those under their authority.
The quote (which is also part of a parable spoken by Jesus), in further context is (Jesus said), "But if that servant says to himself, 'My master is delayed in coming,' and begins to beat the menservants and the maidservants, and to eat and drink and get drunk, the master of that servant will come on a day when he does not expect him and at an hour he does not know, and will punish him, and put him with the unfaithful. And that servant who knew his master's will, but did not make ready or act according to his will, shall recieve a severe beating." Luke 12; 45-47 It is related to the "we reap what we sow" teaching...sin brings suffering upon ourselves and sometimes others...that is due to our poor choices...and that is not God's Will for us.
Since Jesus came to reveal God's Truth, and you have chosen to attempt to attack and defame Him, I am only addressing your comments and scriptual quotes concerning His teachings. You should not open your mouth about things that you have no understanding of, and if you choose not to believe, you do not have to attempt to attack and offend those of us who do.
Are you talking about the full term abortion doctor?
Yes Dave, they are talking about the late term abortion Doctor. The thing I find interesting is was he was a leader in his church. It just strikes me as odd he would even want to be a member of any organized religion. Most Churches don't believe in abortion, they consider it murder. I don't agree with what he did, just like I don't believe he should have been to be gunned down. That has always been an emotional debate between People who agree with it or not. I think it makes no since to kill someone that your upset with for killing. It's pretty two faced.
I can see were these stupid things go on with both sides you'll always have these morons that go to Soldiers funerals and hold up signs protesting them. They call them baby killers and rapist, it's just wrong and people need to realize just because you don't agree with someone It gives you one right to hurt them physically or mentally.
It's kind of like that Code Pink and how they act like a bunch of morons, I believe in freedom of speech but I don't believe they have a right to invade on a private ceremony. There are so many cicvil ways to show your disapproval.
KJR,
Where do I begin? You are attempting to do what most Christians who follow this work of fiction are forced to do, reinterpret the teachings of Jesus, modify these instructions so as to make them appear less barbaric.
Let's start with your "let him surely die" ploy. According to the New American Bible the exact wording is: 'Whoever curses father or mother shall die.' But for the sake of fairness, fine, then we'll also take into consideration your version. I ask why would a loving God wish death on someone for simply disagreeing with their parents? Would any of us today wish death as punishment for their child's disobedience? And as for your “spiritual death” ploy, nice one, the only problem is that Matthew 15:4 is specific, it is about punishment according to the will of God – period.
Next in regards to your massively modified interpretation of Luke 19:27 again, the teachings of Jesus are specific here; he wants his enemies murdered in front of him. Deeper moral and spiritual truth?!? Your Arial font generated diarrhea is truly magnificent. You would have had better luck trying to peddle that when Jesus said slaughter he was really talking in code and that “slaughter” was really a secret code to instruct his followers to hand out Twinkies to his enemies.
As for Matthew 5:17 and the ten commandments, thanks for pointing out the fact that the bible is chock full of contradictions, in fact a page cannot be turned without one contradiction or another. The ten commandments; that even though #6 states “Thou shalt not kill, #4 condones the murder of those who would dare work on Sunday.
But most important, why would God, the creator of this Universe with 400+ billions stars & 200 sextillion planets chose one paperback book ($5 buys you the hardback version) as proof of his existence, his will and then (truly ridiculous) allow different versions with different wordings to exist? You would think the all powerful creator of the Universe, of stars, planets, galaxies etc. would be powerful enough to prevent this from happening.
Enough said.
As a solution, both Pro-life and Pro-choice are unsustainable. Both arguments, being temporal and also binary do not have basis in Truth with a capital "T". That is, depending on your point of view you can argue for either side and be both correct and wrong at the same time. Look at this sad example of Dr. Tiller's murder. A Pro-lifer took the life of a human while trying to defend his/her viewpoint on abortion. Tried to justify the taking of a life to save another life. Isn't he/she now just as guilty? Totally hypocritical and therefore unsustainable. Let's say we outlaw abortion, how will we handle an overcrowded Earth in a few centuries? Who will be chosen to die and who will live when the Earth's resources no longer support our biology? We need to STOP trying to legislate based on binary and temporal arguments and instead look toward the Eternal solutions. The religious should return to their roots where Jesus instructed us to "seek ye first the Kingdom of God." That is, the unarguable Truths which are Eternal. Kind of like the writings of our Constitution and our Bill of Rights. They are written in UNARGUABLE language and their Truths will hold (sustain) until the end of times. Also, the religious should try to remember that Jesus Christ triumphed over death. That is, if you really believe in Jesus Christ than death is not a problem, am I correct? Then we should just accept death within the reality of life as just another stage and forget about the timing. What we are really argueing here is the timing of death and not death in itself. Could it not be that soon to be aborted fetuses only come into this plane of existence in order to teach their parents something about life? And if so, who are we to negate the lesson? The parent(s), having learned their error from a prior abortion, wouldn't they be more receptive and caring of the gift of life in the future?
He should be treated as a murder, no more no less. Here endeth the lesson.
debrarescuesdogs
The righteous compassionate conservatives have raised their ugly heads again.
Why does this have to be about politics? Why must the leftist make this a right or left political statement.. This man was killed by someone who had a problem with him and what he did..
It is somewhat disturbing to me that the media is using the phrase "abortion doctor" as though that is all he did -- perform abortions. Don't know if this is true and his website doesn't seem to be working, but I suspect he was operating a full-service women's health clinic, in which case, not only has the killer stopped him performing abortions, but he has stopped him providing ANY healthcare to women.
100% agree with you!!!
In my opinion, I hope the FBI investigates every pro life group. And if they find evidence of wrong doing, file charges against them.
And what could we possiably charge these groups with? Some possiable charges could be, Accessory to Murder, Conspiracy, terrorism, Hate Crimes, these are a few suggestions and opinions.
It amazes me that you a lot of you assume that this person is a Christian or even claims to be. Attending church every Sunday doesn't make you a Christian anymore than sleeping in your garage makes you a car... And you quoting the Bible to me is like me picking up a text book on nuclear physics and trying to tell you what it is all about without reading, studying, or taking classes. So I would appreciate not showing your lack of understanding... And let’s talk about the percentage of women who make the "choice" to use abortion as "birth control", to terminate "kill" a perfectly healthy baby because it’s not convenient for their lifestyle...
It amazes me that you a lot of you assume that this person is a Christian or even claims to be. Attending church every Sunday doesn't make you a Christian anymore than sleeping in your garage makes you a car... And you quoting the Bible to me is like me picking up a text book on nuclear physics and trying to tell you what it is all about without reading, studying, or taking classes. So I would appreciate not showing your lack of understanding... And let’s talk about the percentage of women who make the "choice" to use abortion as "birth control", to terminate "kill" a perfectly healthy baby because it’s not convenient for their lifestyle...
What a fantastic Christian. Pro-life groups ought to be proud of the Frankenstein's monster they've helped to create. Of course they'll trip over themselves to put some distance between their fiery language and harrassment of people who disagree with them on an issue that depends less on evidence and fact than each person's internal belief system, but if violence can be blamed on secular video games, movies and TV (e.g. Columbine was Marilyn Manson's fault, etc.), then it seems appropriate to question whether the same standard should apply to right wing sources that deliberately use incendiary images and language to arouse passions. Not to say that they should be censored...just that the next time the holier than thou crowd whines about something stupid like Grand Theft Auto, they should have to answer for incidents like this.
Wow, gloating over someone's murder- nice! I'm sure Jesus would be proud.
What clinic did you attend to have your conscience aborted?
Now that's just funny!
I have to admit that's one of the few times I have read a comment on NV that made me laugh
You don't mind if I borrow it do you?
How ironic ... a "pro-life" killing spree.
These terrorists are to Christianity as Osama Bin Laden is to Islam. Lets hope they all end up in prison where they belong.
Murder is wrong anytime. Abortion is wrong anytime.
Sam...your first quote in your comment #2.48, says
Then in your second comment, you say...
"be put to death" and "shall die" can have very different meanings. My comment's quote of "let him surely die", seems closer to your corrected quote in your response posting of, "shall die", than your original "be put to death". And so, my point...translations are imperfect...we may not have the exact words in English to fully convey the original (language) message's full meaning. We look at the whole...not taking small verses out of context, as you attempt to. Also, when Jesus is telling a parable, He is giving a hidden message, that can have many interpretations and meanings for us, and He is "meeting people where they are at"...in other words, His teachings were put in the context of man's ability to comprehend and understand the message at their present time...within their culture and society of the time.
Regardless of what you choose to believe, and how you may attempt to twist scripture, or call Jesus "a terrorist" and an "assh#le"...the truth is, Jesus never killed anyone, but He gave life and healing to many. I think you are a coward to attempt to use this message board to manipulate and deceive others...and thus try to destroy faith in some reading this, who may not have ever read the scriptures or do not have understanding of the Bible and Jesus message.
Sure, no problem.
Funny, here I was thinking maybe I need to go back to school so I can become an abortionist. Do you think I am afraid of being killed by some uneducated-should-have-been-aborted piece of excrement? I fear the loss of rights over my own body, as well as there not being enough doctors with character who will provide this medical procedure. Yep, medical procedure.
He acknowledged abortion was as socially divisive as slavery or prohibition but said the issue was about giving women a choice when dealing with technology that can diagnose severe fetal abnormalities before a baby is born.
The problem is of course, this is NOT what Tiller was doing. He would do late term abortions for any one coming to him. It was about the money
Obama said he was shocked at the killing and yet he would have prevented any aborted baby that had survived the abortion procedure even the most rudimentary care. Note, he was the only person in the Ill state house that voted that way. He says the same thing Clinton did, make it legal but rare, but this of course is nothing more than a pandering lie by a politician trying to have it both ways.
Hopefully the FCC is paying attention to years of hate speech spewed by Bill O'Reilly in relationship to the murder of Dr. Tiller. The FCC needs to wake up and protect consumers from fraud and abuse and take action against hate mongers like O'Reilly and Limbaugh. O'Reilly should be held accountabile for the murder that he inspired and promoted by his disgusting hate speech......and the FCC should be held accountable for refusing to take action to protect the public from hate speech that ultimately leads to terrorist acts.
The murder of this man at this place of worship is a horrible incident.
I would also like to comment that I am against abortion and only believe in peaceful non-violent observance. An eye for an eye is not the way of GOD. Two wrongs, do not make a right.
I will pray for the Doctor, his family and the shooter. GOD BLESS AMERICA and help us return to your ways and teaching.
don't know if I would call the murderer a terrorist, but he committed first degree murder and should be locked up for life without parole.
With respect to all you picketers out there - YOU DO ABSOLUTELY NOTHING to change anyone's opinion on abortion.
All you do is HARRASS which is illegal too.
To let you know, ROE V WADE WILL NEVER BE OVERTURNED because of me and others like me to believe that the only person who can make a decision on what to with their body IS THAT PERSON and THAT PERSON ALONE.
Karen, AMEN! I agree with you 100% on this in that each person should be able to make decisions concerning their own body.
What if, on this particular Sunday, this Doctor had gone to church to "change his ways" and stop abortions and ask God for forgiveness, but died knowing he wasn't able to clear his conscience?
Who in the world are we to judge the others? Fine if we want to have opinions, but we don't go around killing people. Period.
A murderer kills 1 or 2 people, many times a specific person. A terrorist kills as many as he can randomly.
A murderer still gets due process. Terrorists should not get due process because they are usually not citizens or resident aliens and because they are a threat to all in society.
It is important for you to get your facts straight and not react emotianally, because our Republic is diminished by a lack of logic and common sense.
Karen-
Perfectly worded. Thank you. I wish these pro-lifers would "get a life" and stay out of everyone's business.
I was just thinking. What would be happening right now if Obama's Mama would have had an abortion when she got knocked up.
Treated as a terrorist? Are you kidding me? Do you people say that every murderer should be treated as a terrorist, or only the ones who kill abortion doctors? I don't condone murder in any situation, and his killer should be prosecuted for his crime, but this doctor was a baby killer, plain and simple. He didn't just perform abortions, he killed as many as he could possibly get his hands on....or scalpel/vacuum/forceps in. If anyone was a terrorist, it was Butcher Tiller. Gimme a break.
Just a reminder that it's not about a specific religion, but it's about fundamentalist extremist. Be it Islamic or Christian, our society has no room for these extremists.
The full extent of the law should be applied against these domestic terrorists, just as much as we go after the Taliban.
There's no difference between these so-called "Christian" fundamentalist and those Islamic extremist with strapped on bombs. They are both equally a threat to our American-way of life and our Constitution.
The problem of course, is religion to begin with, but that's a whole new argument.
I didn't see anyone mention the babies rights? The ones that he killed daily. I'm shocked that no one considers that an act of violence. Murder is wrong in any situation, whether is be shooting someone over something you disagree with or taking the life of children; yes, they are alive in the womb....don't forget. Women's rights start with the decision to not concieve if they don't want to deal with all possibilities.
I see all these comments trying to spin this situation one way or the other and just have to wonder. It looks like this killer was a confirmed nut case and his actions are about as meaningful and responsible as you normally see with such a person and only other equally moronic types will try to divine some meaning to his actions.
The miracle here is that Tiller lived as long as he did. Continuing his practice of late term abortions instead of sticking to normal OB/GYN after what had happened in the past is testimony to his own lack of touch with reality...sort of the same mentality as those who seek restraining orders against nutcases and expect to be protected. The thing to be thankful for is that no one else will die as a result of their proximity or association with Tiller...other than this killer who took him down. Let's hope that Kansas has a death penalty and that the ACLU doesn't get him off as insane or underprivileged or get to drag out his execution like they do for all these other losers. Maybe they'll make an exception and back off their own nutcase behavior in view of the fact that this guy took down one of their heroes. Even the darkest cloud can have a silver lining.
I would rather see the person who commited this murder (in church of all places) treated as they treat terrorists in Saudi Arabia - on prime time TV.
Cincinnati Rick, if you can find ANYTHING EVEN THE SLIGHTEST TO BE THANKFUL IN THIS, means there is a fine line between you and this murderer. No matter how anyone feels about abortion, THERE IS NOTING POSITIVE IN ANY WAY, IN THE FARTHEST STRETCH OF THE MOST WARPED IMAGINATION, that can be found in this. if you feel the slightest movement towards that, you should search your own soul.
Hope (Msg. #2.27), that is the most broadly intelligent commentary I think I've ever read on "Newsvine". You give me "hope" for the human race (admittedly, it's a limited hope, given the other 89 posts on this particular thread).
I'm just curious about something. If it's every woman's right to choose whether or not she has an abortion then why is it that men don't have a choice in these matters? If a woman chooses to have a child then the male responsible for making that child with her just has to grin and bear it, so to speak. If a woman has the right then a man should have the right as well to choose whether or not his child is born. With that being said, each "right" is wrong. You can't have your cake and eat it too. This is a huge double standard and it's ridiculous that we even discuss it. The man who shot the doctor needs to be prosecuted and punished. Murder is murder, whether it's commited by a gunman or a doctor claiming to be offering "health services". Doesn't sound too healthy for the unborn child.
By the way, Mr Rogers, I completely agree with you.
Sorry Ron but I have no dog in this fight. I am not anti-abortion. But I do condone the right of those who are to stop it by whatever legal means. And I do understand but not condone that when legal means are not available some will seek vigilante means.
What Tiller was doing knowingly endangered himself and everyone around him. That's his own prerogative where his own safety is concerned but not others. All too often these situations end up with innocent bystanders being killed as well and if you can't be happy that did not occur here, then it is you that has a problem.
That said, we need to put the mad dog down. And hopefully the people who usually obstruct justice will be too tied up in their political correctness to intervene this time. And that would also be something to be grateful for...even if their failure to intervene is for the wrong reasons.
I've read enough of these posts to come to the conclusion that most of the people here are morons. First of all...the real crux of the argument here is when does life actually begin? When is it "murder"? Science has yet to prove this point. Whilst a baby is attached to the mother via an umbilical cord and a placenta, it is in fact, by definition, a parasite. Yes, a parasite. It cannot live without the host. Here is the definition for those who would disagree: "Biology. An organism that grows, feeds, and is sheltered on or in a different organism while contributing nothing to the survival of its host." Aborions are illegal past the point of viability;when the fetus would be able to maintain life on it's own without the host. It is and should remain a woman's right to decide to deliver a baby. Society should have no say on this choice. Now, after the fetus is delivered, then societies laws and conventions do apply. The fetus is now an individual. Dr. Tiller went to trial not because he was performing late term abortions, but because it was thought that he was seeking the mandatory second opinion from another doctor that was an employee of his. A second opinion needs to be obtained by another separate doctor before a late term abortion can be performed. Dr. Tiller was acquitted of these charges. My history...I am a Christian and proud of my faith. I have had two abortions, one when I was young and used poor judgement and the other was a late term abortion when I was married. The fetus was found to be deformed due to X0 syndrome and the chromosomal tests confirmed the case. I chose not to go through with the pregnancy and terminated late. Do I have any regrets or guilt feelings? Not one. It was my choice. When I went to the clinic to have my abortion, I was harassed by protesters, none of whom took me up on my offer to give the fetus to them if they wanted me to go full term...I went on to have four wonderful, healthy children. Dr. Tiller was not a murderer. The person that killed him is. Dr. Tiller probably brought much relief and compassion into the lives of the women and families he helped during a difficult time. The murderer of Dr. Tiller just set back women's rights...
oldefarte
Hope (Msg. #2.27), that is the most broadly intelligent commentary I think I've ever read on "Newsvine". You give me "hope" for the human race (admittedly, it's a limited hope, given the other 89 posts on this particular thread).
{"commentId":7394546,"threadId":"591917","contentId":"2882901","authorDomain":"hsp"}
#2.94 - Mon Jun 1, 2009 12:44 PM CDT
Thanks alot oldefarte. Knowing you're out there gives me some hope too. At least there's a couple of people who can think independently of the rabble and dust clouds. I can't help but wonder what's going on behind the scenes when everyone's attention is captured by these 'events.' There are critical things going down and most of us are looking the wrong way.
I personally disagree with abortions, would never seek one. At the same time, I'm not qualified as a meager human being to force another to give birth, and raise their child. After all, all they did was have sex. Birth Control is not 100%.
I have always felt that those who take pro-life to an extreme, have as much of a problem with the act of casual sex, as they do "protecting" the unborn potential life.
Roe v Wade prevented 45- 50,000,000 unwanted births.
That's a powerful fact. To some, "50 million" is the keyword. To me, the keyword is "unwanted".
We get all riled up complaining about the "costs" of 10 million "unwanted" Mexicans (who work their collective arses off) in America. Do the math, what would we do with those 50,000,000 who weren't even wanted by their mother?
If you don't like what Howard Stern says, change the channel. If you are against abortions, don't get one. Isn't life that simple?
LOL.. come on.. are you serious? BY FAR MOST ABORTIONS occur because people were not careful in sex and simply do not want the baby.
Now I would not judge someone in a case of medical issues for life and death, but these are less than 1% of all abortions...
Finally, I never said abortion should be made ILLEGAL just that I can understand why people oppose it strongly seeing it as murder.
Lets get some facts straight here.
First of all it's not pro-life it's ANTI-CHOICE. These people often believe in the death penalty which is actually pro-death.
I myself could say I'm pro-life. I'm all for living, it's pretty great sometimes. I'm all for each individual enjoying their own life. But I would never want to lose or to take away the right to have an abortion to anyone. I would never want anyone to lose their power of free will (to make educated decisions) or for the government to have the power to control our bodies. So I'm a pro-life, pro-choicer. (just try to expand your definitions here, there can't ever be one right answer)
Secondly who is breaking in to medical dumps, digging through biological waste, finding aborted fetuses and taking pictures of them for anti-choice protests? Not a sane person. The kind of person who would bomb a women’s health clinic were there’s a good chance living babies may be present. So killing people is supposed to prove that killing people is wrong? How does that make any sense? (even if you’ve been digging through body parts and used needles all night this can’t be logical)
Taking away the option of abortion for everyone for any reason is taking away a woman’s right to make her own decisions. If you don't trust that women can make educated decisions why are you letting them vote?
Take away women’s reproductive rights and soon we'll be taking away all women’s rights. And why stop there who else can't we trust to think for themselves? Who doesn't deserve to be in control of their lives?
It's a kick in the pants to see so many women supporting the anti-choice movement. Are you going to vote for burquas next?
1 Corinthians 11:6 (New International Version)
6If a woman does not cover her head, she should have her hair cut off; and if it is a disgrace for a woman to have her hair cut or shaved off, she should cover her head.
If you're going to quote the bible to back your opinions up you should at lest follow the whole thing. So why aren't you good God fearing women wearing headscarves?
women should remain silent in the churches. They are not allowed to speak, but must be in submission, as the Law says.
So ladies follow the good book and remain in submission. After all you aren't allowed to speak so just let your religion do it for you.
Once again the fringe takes center stage.
The righteous compassionate conservatives have raised their ugly heads again.
And dear person where is you compassion for the aborted babies that could have survived given just a few more days in some of the cases? It is not a good thing that the Dr was murdered but that criminal will be caught and brought to justice.
They are not babies until they are born under law get over it. Laws protect all living humans that can live ourtside the wounb. Before that they are just a developing fetus and there is no gurantee they will make it to term.
Hey, I consider myself a liberal. I just believe there is a better way to do things than the way they are being done. I am definitely uncommon, but consider myself a rational human being. I'm a Christian, Democrat, and a pacifist. I don't believe in maintaining abortion clinics. If it weren't for the pure profit in it, they wouldn't exist. The legalization of abortion was an issue with doctors, not the women, because long before it was legal doctors were performing abortions all the time. If they got caught, it meant jail time. If doctors did abortions along with their normal practice, would they be targeted? No, it's only those doctors who run clinics especially for that purpose. And their reason? The money, of course. Do you think that if abortion was a free service of a socialized medical service that there would be any problem like this? Why can't we respect the patient's "right to privacy" when it comes to abortions? If there was any disclosure in any other case everybody would be fired! REMEMBER THE NURSES WHO TOLD ON BRITTANY? WELL?
there is no guarantee you will make it to work every morning. Should someone have the choice of terminating you?
When does life begin?
When did life begin? Was it a single celled amoeba type blob? was that life?
If so, what is the difference, as to what life is, between that first single celled protoplasmic blob and an unborn child? Other than one is studied and hailed as ..."the origin of life..." and the other is tossed into a wastebasket because it is just a mass of tissue. (?)
Logic defies
CJ 66. If people tried to keep up hope in societies throughout the centuries what makes you think profit is the motive?
I don't believe you are who you say you are because profit is not the reason for making churches, spiritualism is.
Profit is not the reason for teaching a neighborhood child to to catch a ball, fun and interest is. Profit is not the reason to have a public swimming pool in the neighborhood, community is. For visiting your sick aunt or mom or dad? Opening the door for someone else? Cooking a meal at your boat club???, profit is not money.
Midwives and doctors help people for one reason only...to help people.
CJ 66
Profit?
America isn't the world. Abortion is happening around the globe. Look just north of us to Canada. Their social medicare system means their isn't really any profit in abortion. How can anyone think they have thought seriously on an issue when they haven't even thought outside their own borders? The giant landmass above is a giant refutation to your "prfot" motive.
Dr. Tiller believed in a women's right to choose to the point he was willing risk his own life. How many of us have such serious convinctions?
To say he performed abortions was a ridiculous, offensive comment. Dr. Tiller has spent years being threatened, falsely accused, harassed and even previously shot. He has bullet-proof windows in the clinic and a bodyguard.
I live in Wichita. I know of some of the harassment he endured. However he believed in what he was doing. He could have made money as a regular ob/gyn, however he believed that women have the right to choose.
God Bless You, Dr. Tiller. I hope your family finds some comfort in knowing how many of us respected him.
It isnt the womans right. Maybe in some stupid court of law. How about the moral law. That is what this doctor is being held accountable to today and so will everyone else that murders the helpless babies in the womb.
CJ66: It had nothing to do with women going to get back alley abortions?It had nothing to do that women were using coat hangers instead of the proper medical equipment?It had nothing to do with women dying for these reasons?
If it was all for profit then what about prohibition. Alcohol is a huge money maker. Just ask the bootleggers and Joe Kennedy about all the money they made during prohibition. Here you have people passing laws and trying to push their morality on others. How did Prohibition go? Not too well. AL Capone and other gangsters got rich from this. Gang wars erupted all over the country. Americans do not like to be told not to do something because it goes against someone else's morals. Some examples of this are: prohibition, abortion, the war on drugs. Now that we have a war on drugs there is an epidemic in this country. Marijuana was not illegal till the 1920s. LSD was not illegal until the mid-1960s. Hell the CIA used it for mind control experiments. I don't remember reading about huge drug epidemics before these drugs were made illegal. I am not saying drugs should be made illegal. I am just using them as an example of how Americans do not like to be told not to do something because of someone else's morals. Plus drug dealers make huge amounts of money. By your theory then we would make it legal just to all by Hummers.
If you are a conservative then you are against big ggovernment. What is an bigger example of the government interfering in on our privacy than tellinga women what she can or can't do with her body. Hell China did this and told women how many babies they were allowed to have. Do we want it to get to that point? We have to be careful it is a very slippery slope once we allow the government to tell women what they can and can't do with their bodies. If you are a Conservative you probably already know this.
As for the murder of this doctor he should be put in prison. Fundamentilist really are scary.
Phugoid:
It's not the women's right to choose what happens to her body? Who's is it then? Yours? Mine? The Governments? Remember we are a society of laws. If you get caught speeding you have to go to that stupid court of law to plead your case. Why should your morals be forced on someone else. There is a reason the church and state was separated. Maybe I don't believe in your religion. Why should laws be passed to support your beliefs. If you are Christian does that mean we should start passing Muslim laws? Jewish laws? Buddhist laws? Hindu laws? Then every group I mentioned above would be upset.
This country goes by the Constitution. According to the Supreme Court abortion is Constitutional. Until you can prove it is unconstitutional then it will stay a law. It has nothing to do with what particular religion you subscribe to. So it was your God that had this doctor killed huh? He seems a very angry and spiteful God. It's funny when I was growing up and going to Sunday school Jesus did not strike me as a mean, vengeful person. Is that how God and Jesus work (or whoever you believe in)? They wait till the man is in their house of worship to take him? A place that is suppose to be peaceful? How about the fundamentalist that bombed other clinics. What about if an innocent mother and her baby were walking by on the side walk and were killed by the bomb. I guess that is all part of your spiteful Gods plan right. Or maybe this was just some whacked out fundamentalist that decided to act out on his own. You know that whole free will thing.
You don't read and someone wrote aand thought this up for you.
Why did Jesus cure the sick and heal the blind?
God wanted them to have this disease and not have a choice? God made that lesion so don't cure it? It would be immoral and furthermore...it could grow up to be a healthy human being?
No lesions don't grow up, woman don't survive late term problems and severe hydrocephalics dont grow brains back.
NOW, Number two: who are you going to shoot because they are not doing what you want?
Number 3: I say your child must be pregnant..it will be immoral if she is NOT pregnant! Do You believe me? I don't believe you either!
Greetings! V
JustThinkin - In addition to your comments, Dr. Tiller operated within the law.
phugoid - Dr. Tiller operated within the law. Therefore, he is not a murderer. The U.S. Justice System has provisions to make and modify laws, voted on by society in the best interest of society. The laws are not perfect but continually evolve to better serve society. "Moral law", as you say, should be decreed by who? A group of people or just a select few?
dacincykid
This doctor did Abortions on full term babies most would have survived outside the womb! Kansas procecutors were going to press charges because he was performing Abortions at 8 and 9 Months for reasons like the mother felt depress or said she was stressed. Those are not valid reasons to perform an abortion. Don't get me wrong murdering the doctor was wrong and evil. But this doctor was an evil man I would have prefered he went to jail.
...and the score at the end of the period...
Abortionists: 55 million
Anti-abortionists: 7
There is nothing in the Constitution that even comes close to saying abortion is right. To get to that point, some judges had to twist several times and then say "Because of 'A', then 'B' is probably intended and because of 'B' then 'C' is intended and because of that abortion is Constitutional." I challenge anyone to show anywhere in any of the Founding Documents or any of the writtings of the Founders where abortion is even mentioned, let alone stated as Constitutional.
Just because a bunch of activist left-wing judges voted to make it legal does not make it right, but it does show how depraved people can get with a bit of power.
micrometer and JB, you are not making sense.
There is nothing in the Constitution that says anything about abortion period.
14th admendment:
Section 1. All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside. No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.
9th amendment: The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people.
The issue that the Supreme Court looked at is the right to privacy. Does the government (local or federal) have a right to tell a women what she can or can't do with her body? Does that not interfere with her right to privacy and to make a decision with her doctor? Like I said before if the government can tell a women what she can and can't do with her body what is stopping them from telling her how many children she can have? Or that she can only have a boy or a girl? Where does it end? What happens when a women dies from child birth and the government made abortion illegal or a child is born without a brain and cannot live on it's own. Does that mean that the said women or family can now sue the government for passing these laws? These amendment I listed above pretty much says the government cannot make laws that take away peoples right. If a law was passed banning abortion isn't the government taking a women's right away to choose what she wants to do with her body? Smoking is bad for you. It kills people. Smoking when your pregnant can kill a baby. Does that mean we should pass laws to make cigarettes illegal. Drinking can kill you. Drinking while your pregnant can kill a baby. Does that mean we should pass laws banning alcohol. Driving and getting in an accident can kill you. A pregnant woman could get killed in a car crash does that mean we should make driving illegal? We choose what to do with our bodies everyday. We choose to smoke and take the chance of getting Cancer. We choose to drink and hope not to have complications. We choose to drive and hope we do not get in a car crash. I really hope a pregnant women does not drink or smoke. Why is it any different that we decide that we can tell women what to do with their bodies? A man cannot have a baby. He does not take the risk of dying during birth. Unless you are that women you do not take the chance of dying during birth. If a baby is born without a brain or its organ are outside its body when it is born are you the one that has to go through that? If a women is raped or a victim of incest are you the one that has to carry that baby to term? It is a private choice. No one should be able to tell a women what to do with her body. Just like I should not be able to tell you not to smoke or drink anymore.
You can not tell me that in this country there were 55 million babies that HAD to be terminated! Abortion as birth control is what it should be called. We have killed almost 2 generations for convenience. We are seeing young girls encouraged to abort their babies by their 19 year old boyfriends so that the boyfriend gets rid of the evidence that would cause them to be convicted of rape. I have only known two families who were told by doctors that the babies they were having would die soon after they were born due to birth defects. Both mothers continued the pregnancies. One baby died within 2 hours of birth. The second baby died 30 days after birth. Both were loved and held. Both mothers wanted to give their babies a chance just incase the doctors were wrong. Both are glad they didn't kill their babies. I worked with a young woman who was having a problem with her boyfriend. She was 6 + months pregnant with a little boy. She decided to break up with him and she went to an abortion clinic, paid them $1,200 and aborted the baby. We were all grief stricken-stunned. She wanted to make sure she had a clean break with the boyfriend she said. Two weeks later she realized what she had done and had a nervous breakdown and had to be committed. Point is their is a big difference between a doctor and a abortionist. Hopefully both the abortionist and his killer will have made their peace. We need to educate our young people that STD's, HIVAIDS are much worse then getting pregnant. If you aren't protecting yourself from getting pregnant then you aren't protecting yourself from all these deceases. The pill isn't protection. We need to make sure young women know that they can give that baby to someone. The gift of life! Someone out there wants that baby and it's okay to give that baby away. Don't kill it, don't leave it in a trash dump or a box on the side of the road. Someone wants that baby! We need to provide care for the mothers to be. When there is a problem it should be handled by a doctor not an abortionist with a drive-in clinic. This whole problem wouldn't have happened if abortion wasn't murder and big money!
Yeah I'm sure they do it for the money. They couldn't be any other kind of doctor and make money. Your right we should educate the children. That means teach them the proper way to use a condom and to always use a condom. Not this no sex at all stuff cause guess what that is not working. Kids are having sex anyway.
debrarescuesdogs and kills babies. What a screwed up head. That's liberals for you.
Hey wac left wing lib.......if a muslim cuts a head off then do all muslims cuts heads off???? If a black person kills another are all black people bad?????
So if a Christian shot this man in cold blood does this mean all Christians are bad????
So we can lump all liberals together right??????
I think Tiller sucked your brains out and you lived. Your BOY obama was shocked and outraged because he is also a baby killer, he voted to kill them once they are out of the womb.......he is an evil person.
Why does this have to be about politics?
debrarescuesdogs
The righteous compassionate conservatives have raised their ugly heads again.
dacincykid
They are not babies until they are born under law get over it.SO then why do you charge somoeone who kills a pregnant woman with 2 counts of murder? One for her and one for her unborn CHILD? Laws protect all living humans that can live ourtside the wounb. Before that they are just a developing fetus and there is no gurantee they will make it to Hey kid your argument does not hold water.. I feel nothing for the loss of this man.. He was who he was and that is that.. I had to laugh at obama who was outraged outraged I tell you over this.,.. LOL hey pal get outraged over your country getting the shaft. Get outraged over the price of gas and oil going up over 50 cents in 2 months. Get outraged over things that matter, Like this country going into bankruptcy itself..
JB-784265
I think someone as intelligent and far-thinking as Jefferson envisioned a legal system that was adaptable, not one locked in a literal-minded vise by the social constructs, mores, or even technology of his day.
"All men are created equal" doesn't mention women, either, but we as philosophical human beings take it to mean all human beings and therefore that women deserve the same rights, such as the right to vote, which they didn't actually receive until 1920! Would you argue that we shouldn't interpret that founding document in that fashion?
BTW, assault weapons aren't mentioned in the Constitution but right-wing activists (to borrow your left-wing phrase) seem to think they are covered by "the right to keep and bear arms." Funny, how one person's "juducal activism" is another person's common sense.
Dave, thanks for the compliment. I am a liberal. I am PRO CHOICE and proud.
It's going to be political because a)this topic is a hot topic politically and, b) everything is political.
The right (GOP)) of course doesn't want this to be political because it shows what nutcases are running around in that party. With all the happy peppy people dancing on this doctor's grave, you guys will go nowhere politically. Go back to your churches and leave the government alone.
And don't talk to me about paying for abortions with your precious tax dollars. I pay for a war in Iraq which i dont support. Until you tell me how not to pay for that, comments like that have no merit.
Manawar
You don't have the authority to kill anyone for performing abortions and your attitude that the unborn baby was more important is abhorant to me.
There is a reason why most people do not agree with you.
Look in the mirror.
After stating during his campaign that he wouldn’t support late term abortions for women with mere “mental distress,” Obama has appointed someone who is arguable the highest profile, late term abortion advocate in the entire U.S., Kansas Governor Kathleen Sebelius to Health and Human Services Secretary of all positions.
-
-
You see Gov. Sebelius, even threw a party for the infamous Tiller the Baby Killer (George Tiller) as a show of support for abortionists and to thank Tiller for his sizable blood money donations to her campaign. You see, Tiller the Baby Killer isn’t just your run of the mill abortionist. He is responsible for perhaps thousands of Late and Near Term abortions. His efforts are so well known that women will travel world to come see the ‘physician’ that will pluck the dead remains of a fully developed baby at 9 months, simply because the mother complains that she is a little depressed. Yep, when you read Obama’s quote above about Near Term abortions for ”mental distress,” he is speaking almost directly about Tiller the Baby Killer.
Sucks to be in the minority.
The majority has clearly voted for choice and the majority voted for Obama.
dacicnykid:
Can you quote me the actual law that backs up your statement. I don't believe there is a law. Merely a Supreme court ruling. The truth is abortion is only "legal" because it's not specifically "illegal". Congress has abrogated their responsibility for making laws (one way or the other) to the Supreme Court because 1) The Supremes do not have to stand for re-election, and 2) Congress does.
Good place for him to have been killed.
Maybe he was praying for forgivness for all his abortions when he got what he gave to his many unborns.
I don't think I will be weeping for him.
God's punishment.
People like you are exactly why I am a born again athiest!! Religion is a gateway psychosis.
This logic confuses me. Some folks out there oppose abortion because they think it's murder (late term or not)....apparently their answer to the problem is murder. Seems a bit hypocritical to me....but I dunno.
killing in the name of god is what sick, demented, delusional criminals do, with rightous indignation...screw your god if he condones this type of violence...killing is killing
God was invented on the battle field to give men a reason to kill each other. What is god's punishment for the innocent women, elders and children, who die in Iraq, Afghanistan, Syria, and Pakistan, when our drones target terrorists and jets follow up with missiles... collateral damage? 9-11 was done in the name of god...this is no different, just a different version of god.
The point is, we have to have law and order and civility in this World. Hairless apes like the one making this comment are an argument for abortion.
You F*#@kin leftist libreal you should be shot.
Rather, love your enemies, help them, and lend to them without expecting to get anything back. Then you will have a great reward. You will be the children of the Most High God. After all, he is kind to unthankful and evil people. Be merciful as your Father is merciful.
Matt. 7:1 "Do not judge, or you too will be judged."
Well, technically it is the same god, just a slightly different viewpoint.
The Lord is weeping........and the devil is in control of the right wingnuts and their "church". These people.......are domestic terriorists........
Aryan Nation and their Church of Christ..................is just a DEVIL WORSHIPPING CHURCH. The Lord Jesus Christ........was the most inclusive man......he loved everything and everybody.............He said not to judge......less you be judged!
Why do these crazies........try and play GOD! What a person does is between them and GOD.
God is sickened by this more than we are... why do you think he gave us way to escape this never ending cycle of hate. Hating God does not solve this problem. Learning to live a God centered life is the first step. We all need work there.
The difference is the court found Dr. Tiller "not guilty" and he was operating within the law. The people harrassing him and the murderer that killed him were not.
You think it was all right for somebody to end his life because he helped women who were likely being killed by their fetuses anyway? FYI, this is why late-term abortions are typically performed. Congratulations. Stay classy.
Go ahead and cling to your guns, religion, and your backwards beliefs you white trash POS redneck!! Don't you have a megachurch gathering to be attending? F off!!
the logic you are confused by when it comes to the right. is the same logic that confuses me when it comes to the left. the left say's they want to save lives in iraq and stop the war, yet they kill millions of baby's in abortion clinics daily. the hiporisy is much much worse.
jcd and rob:
The face of the "christian" conservatives.
NO this is NOT! This is the face of a terrorist.
Technically, it's just another late-term abortion. What's the big deal? Dr. Tiller would be proud. Well said jcd- I don't think I'll be weeping for him either.
As there is a good likelihood there isn't a god, this is a civil act of murder. Trying to justify it as doing god's will is akin to Hitler saying disposing of the Jews was the work of the lord. This murderer has put his face on the anti-abortion banner, like it or not, and the so-called pro-life movement will suffer greatly for his act.
you're absolutely disgusting. I'm ashamed such extreme pro-life people are even walking this earth.
To murder a man in the church no less demonstrates a much more significant problem than whatever that man was doing. I do realize that this act is not representative of the majority of people that were against him but it does show how anger turns into hate quickly and is dangerous.
seems that if you live by the sword, you ,,,,,,, ! murder was his line of work and thats how he went out, its wrong on both accounts but its hard to feel sorry for him.
Nuff said
"I like your Christ, I do not like your Christians.
Your Christians are so unlike your Christ."
~Gandhi
And apparently this was not the first act of violence against him:
Bob, you stop reading at the old testament. The new one said turn the other cheek. "Christians" like you are the reason I go mountain biking on Sunday mornings.
BOB D - Like it or not, his line of work is legal, as decreed by law. What was and had been done to him was not.
There are lots of legalized things that are immoral, corrupt and rerpehensible in this country: Everything listed below used to be a crime a few decades ago.
Abortion is legalized murder of an innocent baby.
Your credit card company can legally charge any interest rate they want on your credit cards.
Lobbying is legalized bribary.
Having your car towed away for being illegally parked and charged rates that far exceed the normal towing rates to have your car released is legalized extortion.
Do you see the irony? Someone murdered the doctot to save lives of unborn children. You can apply the same logic to justify stem dell research. That is, killing one person to save the loves of many. Christianity isn't a beautiful religion, it's a mental disorder!
Kierra.......Christ must be weeping. These right wingnuts........belong to the church of the devil. My Lord Jesus Christ.....said : Judge not lest ye be Judged!
My Lord........wants me to come to HIM to be judged. "Right Wing Christian Churches"....are taking the Lord's purpose away. They have become the American Taliban............period!!
Marcia: The people who did this, contrary to what some of the hate-filled apologists would have us believe, are right-wing fundamentalist terrorists who label themselves with the ironic "pro-life" name. They are home grown terrorists who are absolutely the epitome of American Taliban. I agree with you on that.
However, until this country stops condoning religious ignorance, there will be no ridding ourselves of such fundamentalist nutcases. Even the doctor himself was attending a Christian church. Promoting and tolerating religion is not the answer to religious terrorism regardless of which religion they use to condone acts of terrorism.
When are we going to notice that all, ALL, terrorists use a god to justify their actions? There are those in this very forum who say it's okay if you just think about it as a late-term abortion yet they are perfectly willing to incite violence while calling late-term abortion evil. Do they even see that their argument is not only circular and illogical it is hypocrisy at its most vile? No, they don't because just aren't that bright. Sad.
Its her body, her choice.
Ok, So why do I need to wear a seat belt? Isn't it my body, my choice? Motorcycle helmets the same thing. Somebody just thinks they know better for me then I do.
yeah montana @ 7.2, the only bright people are those who believe like you, think like you, vote like you, and golly gee, probably look like you too, right?
no room for any difference of opinion.
who are the hate-monger, wing nuts?
who was the first to start striking out with hate filled speech.
hate-speech? does that fall under the "hate crimes" legislation? oh, thats right that only applies to someone who may be considered a conservative or Christian right?
khollo4:
Who was the first to start shooting?
My church counts so greatly, and your church counts so little, that I can come and shoot you in yours.
Mrtvol...
The difference is the women take responsibility for themselves....we have to wear seat belts and helmets so ems and other service don't have to clean up your brains off the road..
Kansas.....
....which isn't that far from Texas....
Nuff said.
greg...
????
oklahoma is not that far from texas, nor louisiana, nor new mexico, nor mexico, nor arkansas...
nuff said!!!!
Mary, I am talking choice, not consequences here. If you want to talk consequences- Abortion = death. Me not wearing a helmet does not mean that I die today. Even if I wreck, it does not mean I die today.
It should be MY choice to wear seat belts or helmets. It is personal freedom. How can you erode one person's freedoms and fight for another?
My wearing a seat belt or a helmet does not make you safer going down the street. Me obeying a stop sign does. Pass laws that protect me from you, or you from me, do not pass laws that protect me from myself, you from yourself. If you want to put 30 piercings in your eyebrow, good for you. I don't like it, but it is your choice.
Going on the consequences theme.
A woman will always have a choice, as does a man. To have sex in the first place. To wear a condom, take the pill, spermicides, pull-out, any number of safe guards against getting with child in the first place. Getting pregnant is a consequences of those choices. As contraception, I am against abortion. In the event of rape or life threatening harm to the mother, I understand. I am sorry if you think that all kids should be perfect when born. They are not and never will be. Bad things happen to good people every now and again. It is what builds their character.
Note: Just because I don't like abortion does not mean that I will dictate to you that you can't get one. I don't like it, but it is your choice.
How many innocent human being did this doctor kill?
You are an argument for abortion.
the government, god and other humans, have no right to decide what a woman does inside her own womb..."Woman's right to choose", is the law. All you religious freaks are using god to justify your own opinions. You think your belief makes you better.
So David,You've just justified murder.So your objection to abortion is moral vanity?Which,in my opinion sums up all religion. Hell is only for those who believe in it.
So if a woman drinks and spontaneously aborts not even knowing she was pregnant is a murderer? I don't condone late term abortions, but saying it's murder is just a way to provoke violence and condone these kinds of activities. Love the fetus, hate the adult.
It was not an unborn child it was an nonviable hunk of flesh that had no chance of surviving or living a normal life. That's why the procedure was being done.
Late term abortions are not done on healthy fetus'. Get a grip on your knowledge and common sense about the issues. Stop letting unreasonable emotions that don't even pertain to the situation run away with you.
"Late term abortions are not done on healthy fetus'."
They aren't? Your certainty scares me.
JoMan you really need to watch the flick "The Silent Scream"
Not enough. You seem to have missed the vaccum.
None, you fool. You don't even know the circumstance of the procedures he performed. Many late-term abortions are done because the fetus is so damaged that any quality of life they may ever hope for would be nothing you would wish for anyone to experience even in your mythical hell. Late-term abortions, contrary to the hype by the hypocritical "pro-life" terrorists, are not performed for the purpose of birth control. I hope one day someone you love will be faced with this decision.
Unless "David" has become a femine name, you'll never have to make this decision for yourself. May it be your wife, sister or lover then. A pox upon your ignorance and a hex on your house. I'm not superstitious, but if you are you can believe that I'm a witch and just cast a spell on you. Boo!
WCE: You need to Google the responses to that stupid tripe, "The Silent Scream." It's put together to impress the brainless. Apparently it's working.
Joman you are truly being foolish I used to think that late term abortions were not performed but they are and He was one of the more prolific cases. You could go into his office and get an abortion the day of your presumed labor. Get a grip you have been lied to by the media that only tells have truths about anything. I am saddened that he was murdered but that is over now!!!!!! I gave it as much thought as he did snuffing the life out of our future.
coloradovet must refer to him picking up dog crap at the pound.Another liberal jerk.
Horrors such as this will happen with Gingrich, Rove, Limbaugh, and all the other right wing radicals begin to "fire" folks up.
STOP, stop it now. It must stop. What they are doing is way too close to yelling "fire" in a theatre and NOT freedom of speech. It's hate speech, absolutely
Good old GOP won't tell them to stop, so they are partially to fault for this man's death, no matter the side you believe in. Is this what "pro-life" is about? If the main leaders of the GOP had a backbone they could stop this
"When fascism comes to America, it will be wrapped in the flag and carrying the cross." -- Sinclair Lewis
Fascism IS here (Obama running GM).
I listen to Limbaugh fairly regulary...sometimes I'm even a bit right of him. I do not, however, condone this murder in any fashion. Your attempt to politicize an act of terroism is offensive. Let's pray for healing, especially for the Tillman family.
Spewing hate toward the conservatives does not help.
Shewolf..........very true!
My brother-in-law works at Pelican Bay Prison in California...........He says.....The Aryan Brotherhood........listens to Rush Limbaugh and cheer and scream Yes! Yes! at everything he says. And there is a newletter called Storm Watch.....that is mailed to these wacko's..........and he says Rush Limbaugh sends monies to this neo-nazi newsletter to help support it. We have terrorist.........right here in the U.S.A. Right Wing = The American Taliban!
Why is there no regulation for radio and television like there is for newspapers?
When a newspaper prints something untrue they have to print a retraction, but people can get on the TV and radio and say things that they know are not true or that they don't care are not true and it's OK???
I'd like to see some regulation in this area.
A lie is not an "opinion", it's a lie.
Bear Fan: Fascism is here in the form of Obama? No, that would be socialism, remember? John McCain even said so. The rightwing has become so confused they don't know the difference. Fascism was George W. Bush's forte. Fascists are far right, socialists are far left. Obama is neither.
What was it when Bush took over AIG? Socialism, Fascism, or something in between? You really need to pull your dittoheads out of Rush's butt and try to jumpstart your brains, if you have any left that haven't turned to mush from listening to the mindnumbing nonsense gushing from the rightwing terrormongers' pieholes.
Lu404506 What you are talking about is ccensorship and I am completely against it. By letting a complete idiot like Rush say whatever he wants is the only way I can say whatever I want. The first amendment protects us all and we all have to be smart enough to recognize an idiot like Rush when we hear one.
Oh, so now this guy is the poster child for the pro-life movement??? Get a grip!! That's like calling the deceased the poster child for the pro-death movement, when in reality the majority of doctors whom perform abortions would'nt even consider doing a late term abortion.
Such typical left wing crap. Any speech you disagree with you immediately label hate speech and seek to silence. It all about shouting down the right for you... THe speech of the right is nothing compared with the hate filled venom that flows from the left. Look at the hateful, mean, and spiteful things that were heaped upon Miss CA recently for honestly (and tactfully) answering a question regarding her opinion on marriage. Now THAT was hate speech.
What are you talking about? Have you not forgotten all the hate from the left over the last 8 years? Who were you asking to quiet then? What liberal leaders? Just because we stand for different things, does not mean we hate. The actions of one crazy man does not mean that any and all pro-life people are haters or terrorists, ready to kill like he did. Please give me a break. Being passionate about something you believe does not necessarily mean that one is full of hate.
I almost totally agree with your sentiments! I saw the headlines on this report by MSNBC and was blown away!
The writer and editor here in this article have been condemning the doctor and making it up that he should have been shot!!! This article was billboarding "controversial" and "abortionist"!! Instead of "heinous act" and "terrorist"!
Who was going to help these women needing late help, MSNBC?
So MSNBC would you say you would report Former President Kennedy's killing as "Controversial, non-Baptist polititian gets himself shot while freewheeling down public thoroughfare with top down!...Downtown traffic held up for hours!! Police costs drain coffers" ??? MSNBC headlines are now softening up because of so many replies deploring this murder? Done in a church?? (another church murder being ...what 18 weeks in a row?)
I don't know. But the for profit media is so into whipping up everything in the wrong direction it upsets me!!! It is like they have no values!
DON"T get me wrong! I don't want you,msnbc, out of reporting but you don't have to act like Newt Gingrich or rush Limbaugh or the other wackos looking to promote murders!
The controversy on this man is from the anti's point of view on this doctor NOT the courts, the legal medical profession or ordinary folk!
Montana Atheist-
Thank you for all the insults and derision. It must be nice having a conversation with you in person.
Fascism is when the government directs what the private sector does. Socialism is when the government takes it over. GM will become a socialist experiment is the short term but the long term solution as it stands now will make its relationship much more fascist in nature. Believe me, W's moves left me just as concerned as BHO's. None of it will help in the long run. Capitalism has died a quick, painless death.
It sure would be nice to just have a conversation.
Shewolf you need help!
Montana Atheist:
Socialism = government ownership of business
Fascism = private ownership with government telling them how to run it
Obama = FASCISM plain and simple.
no, thats not what the taliban use, your weekend assignment is to become educated and not a blind follower of the left wing establishment.
Speaking of education...
thats should be that's, a contraction of "that is"
Since you have joined two independent clauses together, you should either add a coordinating conjunction between them or replace the comma after your first predicate with a semicolon or period.
left wing is a single adjective modifying establishment, and thus requires a hyphen: left-wing.
Since the weekend is all but over, your assignment for the coming week is to avoid lecturing others on their need for an education until you can demonstrate that you have one at all.
Bob,people don't follow the "left wing" they simply exercise there freedom of thought and find it best represented by other liberals.Liberal! As in lberated ! As in Free!Conservatives are followers of pablum much like religious pablum.They generally subscribe to such mob thought because they're cowardly and dull.Like zombies.Like you.
You're all a bunch of idiots. Do you not realize that to the rest of the world, the term liberal is equal to the meaing of conservative ideology in the U.S., and the liberal ideology of the U.S. is called social democracy elsewhere? Don't play semantics, the words have absolutely nothing to do with it here and are just inflammatory labels.
BOB D.-1073837
Always blame the left when the right's philosophy is screwed up. Nice.
Another justified killing in the name of god. Do you see the irony? Killing one person to save the lives of many. That logic can now be justified for stem cell research. As I believe: Christianity isn't a beautiful religion, it's a mental disorder!
I LOVE your statement. It is the Most Truthful thing I've heard in a long time.
Chiritianity isn't a beautiful religion, it's a mental disorder!
Religion is full of brain washed people with nothing better to do with their pathetic lives!
You sound like some very hurt, bitter people. I'm sorry for the misconceptions you've been led to believe. Grouping together a large group of people and stero-typing them ins't helpful or honest. I am very opposed to the killing of unborn children but I would never condone what happened this morning.
Actually, Christianity as taught by Jesus is very rare. You aren't criticizing real Christians. You are criticizing all those who pretend to be Christians. No, I wouldn't have killed that man, but I think he signed his own death warrant.
My Dad was a doctor who performed abortions. That doesn't make me exactly a neutral bystander. But I will say, I think abortion is being pushed on women because it is a lucrative practice, there are people who want to use aborted fetuses for experimentation and exploitation. It is still the bottom line we are talking about here. I feel women are being just used badly by doctors and a lot of other people.
If we really practiced Christianity(love thy neighbor as thyself) we wouldn't even be discussing this, would we? If everybody kept the commandments, there would be no need for abortions.
Why aren't Christians (and other delusional factions) intelligent enough to realize there are more pressing issues than abortion?? Do you really want people who don't want a child to then be responsible for the physical, mental and emotional well being on that child? Do you not understand that the world is disgustingly overpopulated and there are millions of children starving to death and dying of preventable illness every day?? Why do you worry about abortion when in the parts of the world there are children wandering around orphaned from AIDS and other illnesses, walking skeletons who will surely join the millions of dead children soon? Get off you f-ing asses and do something to help them, instead of bitching about pro-life and hating Bono. Until you accomplish feeding and nurturing the children that are actually on the planet and have the capacity to process suffering, hold off on worrying about a mere potential for life.
Oh, I see. Real Christians wouldn't kill him, but instead would let his murderer off the hook because, heck, he signed his own death warrant.
Fake religious "pregnancy crisis centers" are even more lucrative, as they allow preachers to preach medical lies and religious bigotries under the guise of medical aid.
Hahaha, really? Abroted fetuses are used for "experimentation and exploitation"? I'd love to see you support that tripe with evidence.
We get it. You have daddy issues. However, it's laughable to think that abortion doctors are somehow magically coercing women off the street into abortions they don't want.
And if everybody kept the commandments, the US would be a theocracy.
I didn't say the man who murdered the doctor should "get off the hook". I think they caught him, already, didn't they? And, of course, he will stand trial and get whatever the court deals out. I just said that the doctor was putting himself in a position to be killed. "He signed his own death warrant." He was injured years earlier by anti-abortionists, and his clinic was bombed. A prudent man would have gotten out of the business.
CJ66, #12.3:
Sure, all those unseemly medical emergencies and health issues would simply cease to be, it'd be Paradise.
CJ66, #12.6:
Spoken like a true coward in heart and in mind.
Just need to point out that I've been to a few crisis pregnancy centers and they are not lucrative. (see above comment) None of those volunteers are making any kind of money. They are always low on funds and materials and to accuse them of being in it for the money is absurd.
Right, because everyone should simply bow to terrorism.
I'm sure after this person is convicted of MURDER. They will receive the DEATH PENALTY!!
another reason why dames need to keep silent!!!!!
Bill O'Reilly and his ilk have a lot to answer for. O'Reilly kept calling him "Tiller the Baby Killer" on his TV show, which was libel...and he didn't seem to know or care that people might believe him. I just wonder what he will have to say about it now on his show. And then I wonder what he say when the doctor's family sues him.
And as for the people on this site who are justifying the shooting...well, all I can say is that you are not doing your cause any good...because you are making all anti-abortion activists sound like homocidal maniacs.
Walks like a duck, talks like a duck... ?
ORIELLY, is culpable for inciting hate and murder (yelling fire in a crowded theater).
Just another reason the thumpers and repigs DO NOT want A HATE SPEECH LAW.
Would you be able to make your statement if there was a hate speech law? You sound like a hater to me.
Thank you bear fan, for at least trying to convince these haters that the vast majority of pro-lifers (myself included) find this act to be just as apalling as late-term abortion.
What Tiller was getting rid of was not a baby. It was nonviable. Late term abortions are not done on healthy fetus'. He was cleared of any wrong doing, and he was harassed and abused by radical crazy pro-lifers that have no common sense.
Tiller was indeed a baby killer, and O'Reilly's statements are not libel (look up the definition). I am pro-choice when it comes to early pregnancy, rape, incest, life of mother, and birth defects. However, late-term abortions are performed when the baby is capable of living outside the womb. That said, murdering Tiller is abhorrent, and sets back the pro-life cause by rallying pro-late-term-abortion supporters to their cause. Likewise, the Iraq war was unjustified, killing civilians unintentionally is still killing them.
outdoor
"Bear Fan" never said "vast majority"
I will admit though that he did make some of the more reasonable and compassionate appeals...
however, it is always interesting to me when people find it so easy to use "haters" against people who merely disagree with "your" point of view......as opposed to those who truly challenge those who spew hate...
Bear Fan
would you agree there is a difference between "Hate Speech" and one voicing ones opinion?
Although I like to comment on many topics, I stay away from the Abortion issue as I take the viewpoint that is considered "naive" by many, that it is a Womans Body and she has the right to choose.
I am saddened by this event, first for the family, but also because it will detract and distract from the true issue, which seems we have not made any progress on in decades.
I also hope when the killer is found that he/she is just a loner who has no affilitations or ties with any active Pro Life group. That whatever statement they felt they needed to make was a singular action.
This will become a heated vine, I trust many/most will take Bear Fans approach.
O'reilly and Limbaugh are proven hypocrits who obviously think they are morally superior even when they make 'mistakes' that they would crucify others for. Don't doubt for a minute that O'Reilly would be pro-choice if he was in a bind that could hurt him financially. He's already shown himself to be a pervert, mpsogynist, and incapable of controlling himself beyond the level of a two year old child.
I know he never said "vast majority", but I AM saying it. Also I am not branding those who respectfully disagree with me as haters, only those who use violent, offensive, and hateful language when doing so.
JoMan-
I should have been more clear; I wasn't referring to any specific act of his but the idea of late-term abortion in general.
Tiller was just late term aborted!
Outdoorlover - no problem I was just making a gerneral statement about the truth of late term abortions. People are calling them "babies" and they are horribly deformed and nonviable. It is very sad.
NU Wildcat fan - You are wrong - It is illegal to preform a late term abortion on a healthy fetus. See link below on that facts and what late term abortions are for, and for worse circumstances. Stop being swayed by false emotional stories of healthy bouncing babies that don't exist - these late term abortion babies don't have brains, limbs or intestines, or the mother's life is in danger. Get the facts. You choose between your fetus or spouse if you want - that should be the families choice!
http://www.boston.com/news/globe/magazine/articles/2004/01/25/my_late_term_abortion/
NO ONE Pro life would condone this behavior...murder is murder....and the nut case that did this should be prosecuted for a horrible crime.
But murder is murder and this "Dr" Tiller knew exactly what that was. Hundreds of babies were murdered by his hands and the God who created him will be his judge..
Pro choice is a sugar coated name for murder and slaughter of the innocent.....late term fetuses if born can live and grow to becoming healthy HUMAN beings......I know I'm a neo-natal nurse ...
While I dont condone murder on any level.....at least Dr Tiller had a life ..
He choose to take away that right from hundreds of babies...
Actually Bridget, THE MOTHER'S MADE THE CHOICE!!!
Bridget M:
(!?!) Ah, have you read this thread?! Not only do many of your compatriots, if I may sully the name patriot so, condone this crime: many are celebrating it! For that matter, you yourself went on to say in the very same missive:
Now, maybe it's because I'm a Liberal and given to liberal interpretations... but to my thinking you've just gone ahead and rationalised- nay, condoned!- this assassination yourself.
You're correct, NU Wildcat Fan. O'Reilly's statements are not libel. They're slander.
JoMan - The article you cite states the law in Massachusetts. In Kansas, the law is different. According to Dr. Tiller's own statistics, about 75% of his late-term abortions were in healthy fetuses when the life of the woman, rape, incest, etc. were not issues. Often, the "medical" reason for the procedure was the mental health of the woman. To me, this means the abortion was done out of convenience. If the abortion is done before the baby is viable outside the womb (i.e. after 24 weeks), that's much different than in early pregnancy.
To O'Reilly critics, yes he's got a big ego and is full of himself, but how many of you actually watch his show and listen to what he actually says? Don't twist his words. The liberal left want free speech, except when it comes to conservative opinions.
My concern with everyone blasting Limbaugh is they are attempting to connect a person they do not like to an event he has nothing to do with...I am a fairly regular listener of his and have yet to hear him "order" his listeners to kill anyone. I consider that hateful and well as deceitful. We all have the right to free speech. We have the right to stand for life. We do not have the right to take it. Tiller's murder sickens me... especially if we find out the murderer is pro-life.
What we need to do is pray for healing...for the nation and Tiller's family
NU Wildcat Fan
How many watch the OReilly show you ask....more then MSNBC....but much less then WWE or SpongeBob Sqaure Pants.....and half of who watched Jon/Kate Plus 8.......
as a side note - no ones needs to twist OReillys words - he does a pretty good job on his own, along with Rush, Hannity, Newt, Coulter, Beck - splitting the Republican Party even further.
It's called freedom of speech even though it's not to your taste.
Randall Terry, Operation Rescue founder, weighs in:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2009/05/31/randall-terry-operation-r_n_209531.html
Nah. Nobody "pro-life" is condoning this assassination... nobody.
Ohh thats rich.. Blame O Reilly and anyone else.. Have you listened to OLBERMAN and MADDCOW on MSNBC? The loud mouth and the dike who think their opinions are the only ones that matter all the while they have ratings lower than a re run of Gilligans Island..
"And it came to pass, that at midnight the LORD smote all the firstborn in the land of Egypt, from the firstborn of Pharaoh that sat on his throne unto the firstborn of the captive that was in the dungeon; and all the firstborn of cattle. And Pharaoh rose up in the night, he, and all his servants, and all the Egyptians; and there was a great cry in Egypt; for there was not a house where there was not one dead." Exodus 12:29-30.
Pharaoh called this upon his own people.. God was only doing what the Pharaoh had asked him to do..
Before it was legal, the profit was even higher -- it was being made by a smaller pool of legitimate providers in states where it was legal or, closer to home, by illegal practitioners, providing in many cases dangerous and unregulated services.
As to your claim that they wouldn't exist w/o profit motive, I think you'll find that non-profit women's health clinics also do abortions -- because, for those of us who belive in women's individual rights, abortion is one of the health options a woman should have.
Bill called him what he was...A baby killer !!
You people play on words, that is what an abortionist is, a child murder!! Killing the most innocent of human life...before it has a chance to know it's rights. Could have been you aborted would that be all good and what you would have wanted. For your own mother to not even give you a chance to have a life.
Oh, I'm such a geek for history; author Cristina Page has a warning:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/cristina-page/the-murder-of-dr-tiller-a_b_209562.html
There is a pattern emerging, and it isn't encouraging for the rights of the free-thinking individual...
Can this be considered a "Late Term Abortion"?
No.
Idiot
Only to someone who is mentally ill.
This once again proves that Christianity is a doctrinal license to kill. The murderer is no doubt one of those Christian fanatics who believes he has performed a Divine service. In reality, he or she is nothing but a worthless and despicable murderer.
I feel for people of reason who must live among these fools who, just like the Islamic fanatics, seek to drag the country into their Medieval way of looking at the world.
They use their religion to justify murdering these doctors and hating other people who just want to live and love peacefully.
There's nothing in their Bible proscribing abortion, btw. As far as Scripture is concerned, life begins when the first breath is taken. All of these Christian hate groups and leaders know how to speak for G-d. They certainly know how to lie, torture, murder and start illegal wars.
They are truly the Evil Ones!
In actuality, there are a number of pacifist Christian groups who do not think Christianity is a license to kill. I am a pro-life Christian. Pro-life, which means not killing people.
You are right about the Hebrew Bible and the New Testament, as well, not proscribing abortion as such, but I think the ethos of the Bible does call it strongly into question. The earliest Catechism of the church, the Didache, does proscribe abortion.
The Bible does mention several times (most notably in the Psalms) how God sees us and knows us while we are in the womb. It very clearly teaches that unborn babies are human beings who are important and loved by God. Now, if you chose to not belive in and follow the Bible, that is your choice. But claiming to follow Christ means that you cannot support abortion any more than any other form of homicide.
Oh please, we have christians who are gung ho for torture of the so called enemy and support war like it's their favorite hobby. Yet it's these same christians that harp the loudest about abortion. I went to church with these inconsistent feel good agenda pushers for years.
The christians who do support non-violence in all ways are few and far between and hide it when they are in their churches, while the pastor is preaching political right-wing aggressive agendas
Why do you stereotype ALL Christians? It's like stereotyping ALL Muslims or ALL Jews. I would say that the vast majority of all religions is peaceful, and that only a few radicals hijack religion for their selfish agendas. And don't tell me that ALL atheists are peaceful.
Tiller is wrong for killing fetuses that could survive outside the womb (as if women couldn't make decisions earlier in pregnancy). Tiller's killer is wrong and should be prosecuted (life in prison, minimum).
but it is o.k. of course to stereotype all dems and all repubs and all Pro Choice and all Pro Life?
(not that you did)
Of course Christianity condones abortion. Their god himself killed many a baby after it was born, which could be called late-term abortion, I suppose. Since god didn't have the technology to kill babies before they were born in those days, he had to kill them in infancy.
"And it came to pass, that at midnight the LORD smote all the firstborn in the land of Egypt, from the firstborn of Pharaoh that sat on his throne unto the firstborn of the captive that was in the dungeon; and all the firstborn of cattle. And Pharaoh rose up in the night, he, and all his servants, and all the Egyptians; and there was a great cry in Egypt; for there was not a house where there was not one dead." Exodus 12:29-30.
Why do you point the finger at Christians? There are many non-believers who think abortion is the wrong way to deal with things. The truth is that most fetuses that are aborted are perfectly healthy. There is good evidence that the infant in the womb knows what is happening and really does feel pain. Hey, what if there is such a thing as reincarnation?(I happen to believe there is) Would you want to come back as a fetus that will be aborted? Just what does anyone really KNOW?
It was Pharaoh who spoke the curse. There are steep consequences for defying God that can last generations. It is no different today.
Also, sure God in the OT seems a bit harsh and often times doesn't gel with your 21st century reasoning, but get this. If there was a God, and he was infinitely more superior than man, what are the odds He would make perfect "since" to us and our way of thinking?
Pro-lifers are the most radical and violent of the christians I know of. They are political and radical, and that leads them far more than what God says to do. It's very easy to stereotype them and they give me no reason not to. Can you give me a reason not to?
You are speaking of short term abortion here, not long term, and so far that is legal and a woman's rightful choice. God willing it will stay that way, or there will be more crime and deaths because of it.
I don't see lumping all Christians into one group. There are some who sit down and talk about all the issues, and I think one of those is the promotion of war and military service. Talk about brainwashed!For God and my country I'm going to believe every lie I'm told by the greedy swine running the government and go kill hundreds of thousands of innocent civilians in some foreign war that hasn't got anything to do with protecting US from ANYTHING?
Don't believe all the lies about God in the Bible, either. God is Love. People are the screwed-up ones that wrote all that stupid stuff about God.
This country is filled with blind hate and divisive politics. Every couple years our country gets caught up in hate. spewing baseless and sterotypical claims about people who do not agree with your point of view.
I find it amazing how much democrats and republicans, religious people and rationalist agree on. Yet, they focus on issues like abortion, like gun control, like God to divide people.
If our country would take all the energy that is spent on hate mongering and use it to better our country, our planet, and our lives, we would all be much better off. Fighting with people who's views are not going to change is a waste of energy. We would be better off accepting other people's differences and focusing on what makes us the same.
Our politicians are in large part responsible. Did you catch the last election ;-)
Joe, are all Muslims terrorists? Think about it, if you can.
Interesting: God was a royal douchebag because he's way, way smarter than you.
That makes sense.
You know, abortion was around in Jesus's day; women have found ways to end pregnancies for millenium... if not through surgery, through herbs, teas, roots, etc.
However, Jesus never went there.
You'd think his followers would take the hint...
awfton,
You say years ago doctors and midwives would take still born or severely disabled babies and kill them. Um, do you know what a still born baby is? They are born dead, you cannot kill a stillborn baby.
Secondly, who are we to judge that a baby with disabilities or deformaties are not worthy of living? I am not some holy roller bible thumper, but I believe if the child wasn't meant to be on this earth, he/she would have died in the womb....you pro-choice people say we shouldn't judge those who chose to have an abortion, but who are you to judge if a baby lives or dies?
My dad's girlfriend's daughter has cerebral palsy....by the definition of disabilities, she probably would be a candidate for abortion by most of you. She is legally blind, is 37 years old but had the mental capacity of a 7 year old, has no impulse control and has to have a sitter if left alone for longer than an hour or two. But does she enjoy life? You better believe she does. She has happy times and sad and mad times just like everyone else, she loves country music and spending time with family. Who is anyone but God to judge whether or not she would have a quality life?
Yes she is a handful and I am certain there are times that her mom is very stressed out and wishes her daughter didn't have this disability. But she loves her daughter and wouldn't trade her for the world. It's rough, but those are the cards she was dealt and she lives her life and takes care of her daughter as best she can. I am sure she sometimes wishes she had a healthy daughter, but for every difficulty she deals with her, there is someone out there who is worse off.
When are you pro-choice people going to get out of your delusioned world and admit the truth. Yes, SOME abortions are due to health problems for the baby or mother, but MOST of the time when someone gets an abortion, it's because they simply do not want the child....they are an inconvenience to their life and they can't be bothered with a baby. So don't stand there and defend it saying it's needed for medical reasons, because everyone knows the majority of abortions are for people's own selfish reasons.
And this crap about trying this guy as a domestic terrorists kills me. I won't defend what he did because murder is murder.....two wrongs don't make a right. But people kill people everyday for some crazy reason or another and they are never justified unless it's self defense. This man is a murderer, he deserves to be tried as such....he is no worse and no better than any other person who has killed someone, so get off your high horse about this domestic terrorist crap.
I am sure my 5 year old thinks I am cruel when I don't let her play in the front yard unsupervised.
kit-744420 and amers:
During the last election campaign, McCain (much to my surprise) did state, point blank, that people who bomb abortion clinics and threaten, harrass, or murder doctors and nurses who work in reproductive health facilities ARE in fact terrorists. I got a hoot out of the look on Palin's face, who is just as crazy as the nutjob in Kansas, because she does feel that it is justifiable homicide. Of course this is one of the few things I like about McCain. According to the definition of terrorism (attempting to invoke social or political change through acts of violence) Roeder is a terrorist as surely as Eric Randall Rudolph, Timothy McVeigh, and all of the rest of the right-wing, ultra-conservative white male christian terrorists out there.
well, obamanationites fire up the doctors to kill the babies so I guess its the same on both sides of the spectrum,,PERHAPS THIS EXPERIMENT IN FREE SPEECH SHOULD END SO THE LIBERALS CAN JUST "DO IT" because when it comes to killing the libs know their chit
HYPOCRITE: puppet georgie W signed MORE death warrants as TexaSS gov. So ALL life is not sacred to you only the unborn?
Exactly like George Carlin described, Americana2!
Even if you do not agree with the man's work, he was a human being and also a human life. Killing for disagreement is not ok. Can I shoot my neighbor that does not agree with my views? We need to agree that all life is important. It is a shame that someone has done this, it only makes the abortion opponents look bad.
NO ONE Pro life would condone this behavior...murder is murder....and the nut case that did this should be prosecuted for a horrible crime.
But murder is murder and this "Dr" Tiller knew exactly what that was. Hundreds of babies were murdered by his hands and the God who created him will be his judge..
Pro choice is a sugar coated name for murder and slaughter of the innocent.....late term fetuses if born can live and grow to becoming healthy HUMAN beings......I know I'm a neo-natal nurse ...
While I dont condone murder on any level.....at least Dr Tiller had a life ..
He choose to take away that right from hundreds of babies
If a baby is not a baby, only a fetus until born, why was scott peterson charged and condemmed for killing his wife AND BABY, and they said BABY not fetus. so apparently it's only a baby when it suits you.when you can see a BABY on a sonagram and hear its heart beat, i think that would be called a baby even tho its still in the mothers body. CAN'T HAVE IT BOTH WAYS.
If your neighbors killing babies, shoot him. i'll vote not guilty
One "Wacko" does not represent those who are anti-abortion. I don't know where you get your information from, but you are way off base. Those who would want "radio" talk show hosts silenced, are looking to be silenced, themselves (remember Freedom of Speech, guaranteed by the Constitution, which also protects YOUR right to say what you like?) It amazes me, that so much is being made by men on this site, over a "womans right to abortion" when they don't have to ask a soul if they can have a vasectomy performed on themselves.
Those males, who have never carried a baby, but are great a "making them" and leaving the entire burden on the woman, have no room to even say a word about abortion. Were it not for their promiscuity, and lack of precaution, while they "enjoy themselves" women would not have to seek abortion at all. Remember, both sexes are equally responsible for creating a new life, yet it's always the woman who either has to have her tubes tied, or undergo abortion, or use birth control, while men believe it is their "right" to enjoy as much sex as they can cram into a lifetime, without any thought (and there are some of them out there, who are decent, and moral, who share in the raising of a child they helped to create, but they are few, in today's society) of the consequences of their lack of restraint or respect.
So, until the men out there, who are guilty of casual sex, "get it" we will continue to have unwanted pregnancies. More women need to learn to use the word " NO" so that they excercise their right to CHOICE, then we won't be keeping these doctors in business, they will have to "retrain" into some other specialty, in order to earn a living, and the endless murdering or unborn babies, may slow down, or come to a halt. It's all about THINKING, people, before you act. Common sense, and discipline, whether you are Religious or not. Period.
cassandra ever here of KARMA? its the law of moral causation, think about it!
The only "karma" in play in this action is that of the killer. His now really sucks.
Ever heard of MURDER? its the law... and that's that.
Maybe the one that killed him is one of those aborted fetuses that was reincarnated? Who knows? I believe in karma, or "what goes around, comes around", or "you get what you got coming to you", or, and this is my favorite, "Nobody gets away with anything!" Oh, and that's what the Bible really teaches us. So think about it.
Actually, the Bible teaches either (depending on what kind of Christian you are): 1. forgiveness and fairness, or 2. God will f--- you up if you don't listen to everything he says.
Men, such as Bob, who will never face the agony of an unplanned pregnancy have no right to sit in judgment on women....and the few doctors left who will assist them. By his incoherent rants he demonstrates that he's on the lunatic fringe.
This doctor didn't just perform abortions, he performed them late term and when the babies were born alive he sucked their brains out to kill them. This is a barbaric act. I do not agree with his murder - his judgement is not up to us but God. And I am sure God's judgement will be far worse than than anything man could do to him.
As far as unplanned pregnancy - women need to realize that any time they have sex there is a chance they may become pregnant even with birth control. Therefore they need to take responsibility for their actions. Rape and incest are a very small percentage of unplanned pregnancies. There is no moral excuse for murdering an unborn baby!
YOU flowerlady, are an ignorant judgmental bigmouth
I found out at 22 weeks that my child had only a brainstem. Do you even understand what that means???? Look it up. I found a clinic in Fla, but if it had been one week later in the pregnancy, I would have gone to Dr. Tiller. I have friends whose child had Turner Syndrome. (again, Google it) Dr. Tiller was the most compassionate man that ever lived. He understood what it does to a woman to be carrying a child that is wanted and loved, yet does not have a chance at any life. Due to people like you, a woman in this position is treated worse then you would treat your dog. You know NOTHING of the circumstances and NOTHING of the heartbreak that comes with it.
You opinions are your right. it is NOT your right, however, to impose your beliefs on me, or anyone else. Get off your bible, and actually read some facts for a change.
It is against the law to kill a viable baby. Late-term abortions are only allowed in cases where the baby is brain dead and/or so severely malformed that it would not survive after birth. The alternative would be forcing the mother to carry to term & then suffer the pain of labor, all for a baby that would either be stillborn or would die soon after birth.
In cases where the baby is viable but the pregnancy must end prematurely to save the mother's life (such as uterine bleeding or severely high blood pressure), emergency
C-sections are performed to save both mother & baby.
It is a key component of Roe v. Wade that abortions in the third trimester are very strictly limited to cases in which there are severe health issues. They are NOT allowed in cases in which a mother simply decides that she doesn't want to have a child.
Dawn, as a physician, I understand where you are coming from. But most ultrasounds done for anatomy are obtained around 18 weeks gestation, giving the woman 6 weeks to make a decision. But the majority of late-term abortions are not done for birth defects (e.g. Turner's, anencephaly, Down's), rape, incest, life of mother, etc. If the baby can live a healthy life outside the womb (e.g. 24 weeks and later), I oppose these late-term abortions. Likewise, I hope they catch Tiller's killer and prosecute, life in prison.
Not true. At 16 weeks my U/S was normal. At 20 weeks my BP went up. At 21 weeks my level 2 U/S showed some echogenic fetal bowel. At 22 weeks I had an amnio. My peri was pro-life, and he knew that if my child had any of the issues he suspected I would terminate. So he refused to discuss it with me until 24 weeks. (after the legal limit in Fla) After I spoke to my OB, he got me in with a friend who went over everything. They not only gave me my diagnosis, they got together the 3" thick file I needed to get a legal termination. hydroencephaly, spina biffida, nothing but a brain stem, the list went on,
A majority of late term abortions are performed where for any other reason? Not in the US. ONLY the life of the mother and the viability of the fetus are considered after 18 weeks. Late term abortion only consists of 18% of all legal abortions.
And the doctor I went to most of these fanatics would have loved. He treated me worse then an animal, charged me $3600 cash up front, my husband and I were the only one permitted to be there. Her grandmother and great grandmother never got to see her. I was not allowed to bury her. But when these fanatics run the country, doctors that will help women like me are very few and far between. Bullet proof glass, vests, etc. I was left in the parking lot throwing up for hours after the procedure was started. I was not allowed to stay inside until after 7PM.
If these religious right wing nutcases would just realize that it's NONE OF THEIR BUSINESS........
None of them have any idea what it's like to have a nurse hold your hand and cry with you wishing she could do something to end the pain I was in. They wouldn't stop it if I went into labor, but they couldn't help me end the pregnancy, even though they knew I was doing the right thing. Instead I had to go to a clinic three days later.
Why in the world would anyone abort a fetus with Turner's Syndrome? They are not born human blobs. They are functioning members of society when given appropriate care and treatment. Same goes for Down's Syndrome.
In society's narcissistic drive for perfection, we are increasingly using abortion to insure perfect offspring. This sounds suspiciously like eugenics, one of whose proponents was Margaret Sanger, founder of Planned Parenthood.
What's next? Do we abort if we know the child will develop juvenile diabetes? Epilepsy? And eventually, if it is not the preferred gender?
The slope is, indeed, slippery.
I'm so sorry you had to go through this experience. I wonder how many of the so-called "pro-lifers" on this vine have any compassion for you? The doctor who didn't give you the choice should have been prosecuted and put in jail for the pain and suffering he caused you.
When are we going to start feeling compassion for people who already exist and stop the crocodile tears for the nonexistent? It's so easy for them to love someone who only had the potential of existence than it is to love those of us who do exist. Funny, that. Their god isn't any better, either.
"And that prophet, or that dreamer of dreams, shall be put to death; because he hath spoken to turn you away from the LORD your God...If thy brother, the son of thy mother, or thy son, or thy daughter, or the wife of thy bosom, or thy friend, which is as thine own soul, entice thee secretly, saying, Let us go and serve other gods, which thou hast not known, thou, nor thy fathers ... Thou shalt not consent unto him, nor hearken unto him; neither shall thine eye pity him, neither shalt thou spare, neither shalt thou conceal him: But thou shalt surely kill him; thine hand shall be first upon him to put him to death, and afterwards the hand of all the people." Deuteronomy 13:5-6, 8-9
The Christian god is telling his followers to kill people who don't believe that he's the only god. The god of the Islamic believers orders them to kill anyone who doesn't believe in him, too. Wouldn't it be nice to put them all in a room together and let them follow the orders if their respective gods?
A lot of the reason why women "suffer" from an "unplanned" pregnancy is because we have so many false mores in this country. If everybody would just learn to play the hand they are dealt, we would all be happier. And no one should judge the "unwed" mother or make life hard for the kid who hasn't got a father.
Ah yes, if only pregnant women would just suck it up and deal, they'd be happier.
That totally makes sense.
CJ66:
I hate- well, love- to quibble with folks' spelling, but shouldn't mores be spelled Moors, as in "those big black Moors are so seductive and so very potent that they just knock everybody up and then they just go their way"?
Well, I am Nasty after all...
...uh, I am an intelligent human being. I, like other humans, will not 'just deal with it' if there are alternative choices I prefer, of which an intelligent human being will seek.
Dawn, I'm sorry for your horrific experience. And your OB doctor should not have withheld info from you. Physicians like myself are supposed to present all options, and let the patient decide. That's what I do. I also would not have done your ultrasound until 18 weeks (16 weeks is too early to be entirely accurate). I really only have an objection to abortions done on healthy fetuses for "convenience" after they are viable outside the womb (24 weeks gestation).
Dawn- Give me a break with all your excuses of why its okay to kill your baby. You people started aborting babies long before ultrasound or any other types of scans were invented. The fact of the matter is abortion is a matter of convenience. There wouldn't be a need for pro-lifers if the rights of the unborn were respected. Of course, if there's no one around to MAKE you respect them, you'll just toss their little corpses in the trash. In other words, you guys started it. All the killing is on the heads of those who abort innocent babies.
unplanned pregnancies happen because some pro abortion women are really to stupid to pre-plan theirsexual liasons properly. Do these women go brain dead the minute they spread their legs and let the male of the species penetrate them ? The women bares all the responsibility in a pregnancy if does not take the necessary precautions. What the hell is wrong with beingro-life. If all these people who are anti-pro-life would do us all a favor and just jump off a tall building then we would all believe what they are saying. Hollacaust, abortion, hollacaust, abortion some one explain to me the difference. You reap what you sow.
Dawn I am so sorry for all of your pain. Bless you. I know the emotional hell you must have endured. Please don't give any credence to the judgemental ignorant posts from people that don't have a clue to the reality of someone that was in your position or the procedure. I cringe when anti-choice people try and make their opinions hold more weight by making the actual procedure far more barbaric then it actually is.
As far as Dr. Tiller and his family they are all in my prayers. He provided a much needed and appreciated service to women and their families.
My concern is for the safety of the other abortion providers. They are constantly being harassed and threatened by a sick side of humanity.
I find the statements about this career choice being lucrative...laughable. Did you know that the health professionals in this area make about half of what others do? Why do they work in this field? Because of their belief in the right for women to choose. They are the hero's, they are willing to go to work each day knowing some nutbag could have them in their gun sites.
I have driven through Kansas and for miles and miles there is anti-choice billboards regurgitating garbage, sign after sign.
As far as all the Christians spewing their judgements and hate and quoting scriptures you need to go back to your bibles. There are quotes to back up the thought that until a fetus takes its first breath it is not yet alive. There are also quotes where women and children were ordered to be murdered.
Bottom line if you don't believe in having an abortion (anti-choice) don't get one and don't have premarital sex......MEN!
I am PROCHOICE which equates to PROLIFE in my book.
Murder is also a choice. Pro-choice=Pro-murder. You can dress it up with all the euphamisms you want. When you stop murdering the most innocent and helpless of all people on the planet, the pro-lifers will thankfully fade into the sunset of a new world. Think about something besides yourselves for once in your life. This cycle of pathetic selfishness must end. Boo-hoo, I'm an unfit mother. Boo-hoo, I'm not ready to give up my personal time. Boo-hoo, the child will be better off dead. Just listen to yourselves. Disgraceful, pathetic.
Neil Young wept.
"And once your gone, you can never come back"- Neil Young
pro- life ? yeah right ! these crazy christians are every bit as dangerous as the radical islamists. and they are so certain that they are right , that they will kill just whom ever they need too to prove it . fortunately for the rest of us most of them are to weak and cowardly to act out the sickness in their hearts and minds
NO ONE Pro life would condone this behavior...murder is murder....and the nut case that did this should be prosecuted for a horrible crime.
But murder is murder and this "Dr" Tiller knew exactly what that was. Hundreds of babies were murdered by his hands and the God who created him will be his judge..
Pro choice is a sugar coated name for murder and slaughter of the innocent.....late term fetuses if born can live and grow to becoming healthy HUMAN beings......I know I'm a neo-natal nurse ...
While I dont condone murder on any level.....at least Dr Tiller had a life ..
He choose to take away that right from hundreds of babies
I respect you for your choice of helping people as a nurse BUT you did not read these messages nor the article.
WHO is going to help these women that have embryos and fetuses with no brains? Why test for problems if you can't abort?
My sister, for instance has a 17 fear old with 1/3 of a brain (internal hydrosyphalic) and did NOT get amniosyntesis done becuse of some religious whacked neo new age belief it hurts a fetus to get amnio. (she was ACTUALLY terrified of being religiously ostrasized for things being wrong) Now she complains how she goes no where and her back hurts from lugging her 140 pound baby around. My sister got 4.4 gpa in nursing school and has a 154 IQ but her religion kept her from getting help. Funny she complains none of the church goers will help either.
You know, if Christ would not have healed the leper or given the blind back their sight those people could have "lived and grown up to be healthy human beings".
You are not responsible for my sister's actions nor choices. I hope you all the talents in the world Bridget! Really!
oh it was a cowardly act that was as sinful as the doctors daily killings, it just that HOW CAN SOMEONE FEEL BAD HE WAS KILLED AND NOT CARE THAT BABIES ARE KILLED EVERYDAY? seems like selective application of their sense of outrage.
The difference is the court found Dr. Tiller "not guilty" and he was operating within the law. The people harrassing him and the murderer that killed him were not.
That's not the issue, sir. ("HOW CAN SOMEONE FEEL BAD HE WAS KILLED AND NOT CARE THAT BABIES ARE KILLED EVERYDAY?") We live in a land of laws. Those laws describe, among other things, what is held as criminal action and the way to address those actions. The person who killed Tillman acted as a criminal. Tillman's actions, were within current the definition of legal. If we , as a society governed by laws, change the laws to criminalize Tillman's actions, then going forward, those who perform those actions will be considered criminals. I'm not advocating (here) for change or status quo. I'm pointing out the difference between government and anarchy. It is a clear-cut issue and one cannot be on both sides at the same time.
It appears from your posts that you have divined the nation's feeling or lack of feeling about Tillman's murder. My opinion is that most Americans would "feel bad " for anyone who contemplated having an abortion and would also "feel bad" for the family members of someone who was murdered. That said, the current laws are clear; feelings are not legislated.
Not everything that is immoral is illegal.
NU Wildcat Fan Who are you to judge what is morally right for me?
Maybe our laws should better reflect our feelings. Lots of laws are written that are "bad laws", and most are eventually repealed. Abortion laws may have a flaw in them, but it isn't likely that people will ever want to go skulking off to a back alley abortionist again. That's why it is legal, and likely to remain so. If we should do anything about abortion, it should be to make sure that we maintain attitudes that allow people to make real choices, and not be pressured into something. I understand that most women who choose abortion eventually regret that choice, and if they had it to do over, would have chosen otherwise. Abortion has become all too "fashionable". It is not really a solution to any problems associated with a normal healthy pregnancy.
Laws do not reflect feelings, or they shouldn't, for a good reason - we're irrational beings in the short term and our capacity for attrocities is endless.
I'm pro legalized abortions - because I believe that having a child without means or support is a great recipe for poverty, ignorance, illness, and crime. I also believe that there are very few women who walk into an abortion thinking that they are out for a Sunday picnic, and boy, just wait until the girls down at the office hear you did over the weekend - won't they be envious!
If you want fewer abortions, then educate young people about their bodies, sex, and provide easy, cheap or free access to birth control - spice it up with a solid education and a good foundation in critical thinking and philosophy and WAH-LAH!
A brand new generation of people who will very carefully think out their actions and the consequences that follow, utilize proper health care, and DON'T OFTEN GET ABORTIONS.
cuz ur a man and dont understand
Actually CJ, research has found almost no women 'regret' their abortions, and wouldn't change a thing if they could go back. I've never heard it as 'fashionable'....WHERE are you getting this information???
Whoever killed him needs to die a horrible death. They had no right. I wish people would get off of their 'holier than thou' trips. Who appointed you??? I hope Karma gets whoever it is and those who think like them. So sad for this Dr and his wife. People just need to mind their own business and get a life and stop trying to control everyone else's.
Diddo. Sad that this doctor was murdered. Who ever killed him had no right to kill another human being. Even if it was out of hate and anger. This was premeditated murder which can carry the death penalty. Hope who ever did this, gets caught soon.
Tiller is wrong for killing babies that could lead healthy lives outside the womb. Tiller's killer is wrong for killing Tiller. Society should not kill Tiller's killer because that is wrong too.
Tiller did not kill babies that could "lead healthy lives outside the womb." You don't know anything about late-term abortions or the decisions women who get them are faced with at all. You claim to be a doctor? I'd like to see that medical degree. Did it come from Jerry Falwell's Liberty University, perhaps? Are you the doctor who didn't tell that woman about her baby's disorder until it was almost too late for her to obtain an abortion?
At least as a pro-lifer you're against the death penalty. That's a new one for your type.
MontanaAtheist, it is likely that tiller killed any baby he could make a buck off. he reminds me of the BTK Killer who was hiding in the church for many years too. eeeeeek!
Montana Atheist - as a physician it is my duty to be honest with patients and present all information, not hide things from patients. I never withheld info from a patient. There is propaganda on both sides, but on multiple different news channels (including liberal MSNBC, I have heard that about 75% of Tiller's late-term abortions are for reasons other than birth defects, health of the mother, rape, incest, etc. I wouldn't have a problem if these were the only reasons.
Again, it is against the law to abort a viable baby, for ANY reason.
"Viable" would mean: Able to sustain life outside the womb without life support. That would not include babies that requires lifelong support (tubes for feeding, breathing, elimination, etc.).
And no, it is not up to outside people (and/or the govenment) to tell a family that they must bring such a child into the world, and then spend millions (their own insurance money or your tax dollars) sustaining a child that has little chance of a meaningful life.
Why should other people (or the government) have any role in this kind of private family decision?
Who the he11 decides a meaningfull life!!! You stupid 8itch!
Won't kill a fetus, but will kill a walking, talking, breathing human being!
We shouldn't kill anyone except in self defense
Just think how many babies might be saved by this!
Just think how many babies might be saved by this!
Absolutely none. There's other doctors.
Can we round up all the newly "saved" babies and drop 'em off at your house for you to take care of and pay for? If you could shell out for the pregnancy vitamins and expectant mother yoga classes to ensure a healthy baby for all those unhappy moms who didn't want to go through that in the first place, that would be great. Thanks.
NO ONE Pro life would condone this behavior...murder is murder....and the nut case that did this should be prosecuted for a horrible crime.
But murder is murder and this "Dr" Tiller knew exactly what that was. Hundreds of babies were murdered by his hands and the God who created him will be his judge..
Pro choice is a sugar coated name for murder and slaughter of the innocent.....late term fetuses if born can live and grow to becoming healthy HUMAN beings......I know I'm a neo-natal nurse ...
While I dont condone murder on any level.....at least Dr Tiller had a life ..
He choose to take away that right from hundreds of babies
Its called ......you ready? BIRTH CONTROL.......don't GET pregnant to begin with UNLESS you are READY and ABLE (ever how you determine that, financially, mentally, ect) to deal with a baby.....AND/OR the possibility it may not be a "perfect" pregnancy or birth.
Also...whether "for abortion" or "against it".....there is NO NEED to wait up till the baby in nearly BORN to abort.....WHICH is what this doctor would do.....that is just immoral and sick. You will never see a list of all the babies he KILLED in the newspapers....but you will see this story....how....some nutcase went off and killed the doctor. People go "off" and kill people daily....even INNOCENT people they don't even know.....there are "nuts" everywhere. The guy who killed this doctor may or may not even have "an issue" with him....some of these "nuts" just want to go down in history books or something, who knows? I don't advocate killing anyone.....but the doctor WAS WHO HE WAS.....and that IS a "baby killer" and worse than that....one who would kill them full term. THERE IS NO EXCUSE FOR THAT.
Condolenscences go out to friends and family of the doctor.....but there are "consequences" for everything we do in life.....there are "choices" that we make.....and some are NOT "good ones"......killing full term babies is one of those EXTREMES....and this doctor "went there". That incited alot of hate and anger, he knew that......he chose to continue doing it.....from that point forward......it was a "job hazard" as far as I am concerned. You knew the "risks"....you knew what you were doing "was wrong" (I am assuming you had to, since you were killed in church?) and yet.....you CHOSE to continue.
From that point I can only sit here thinking....more or less.....you died "doing what you believed in, felt was right, or loved".......just as they say when a skydiver or something meets their deaths.....hard to feel sorry for anyone like that. The families ect , yes....them personally, no.
Condolenscences go out to friends and family of the doctor.....but there are "consequences" for everything we do in life.....there are "choices" that we make.....and some are NOT "good ones"......
SO you are saying the man should be shot and it was because he went to church.
Memo to me: I will NEVER help another human being and I wil NEVER go to church because char in ohio judges that is risky behavior and I should get shot for it.
Bridget M - Dr. Tiller was operating within the law. Therefore his actions were not murder, regardless of how you feel about it.
It's murder.
So, genocide when it is sanctioned/allowed by the government is not murder? Well, I guess the National Socialists (Nazis) were decent folks after all.
DavePeroia - The law says different. If you don't agree with the law, there are channels to change laws. Murdering a doctor is not the answer.
AmericanLiberty - All war, for reasons other than true defense, is murder. But you are straying away from the topic. This is about the murder of a doctor that was working within the law, not Nazis.
Hitler worked within the law. Killing full term babies will never be nothing more than murder. Americas shame.
Oh Dave you sanctimonious piece of crap....are you willing to take on the care of those babies that aren't aborted??? Let me guess and predict that you are one of those people that don't acknowledge them once they come out of the womb. You are probably one of the most vociferous individuals in protesting any kind of aid for them...heaven forbid that your taxes would be increased!!!
Hitler created his own laws to serve his purposes, which were internationally recognized as crimes against humanity. But this isn't about Hitler. This is about murdering a doctor that operated within the law.
Late-term abortions (not "full term" as you said) were legally performed in cases of birth defects, rape and when the health of the mother was at risk. You can call it what you want but the law calls it legal. If you feel abortion is wrong, don't have one. If you don't agree with the law, there are channels to change laws but murdering the doctor is definitely wrong and illegal.
Judgement is coming, and imminent, most assuredly... and those who are most self-assured of their standing are those who will be most shocked and dismayed, and just plain surprised at the verdict they face.
Behold, I come as a thief in the night...
Don't say you haven't been warned, you sanctimonious and self-righteous unfaithful (infidel) ones.
I think the government should provide free birth control and sterilizations. That might help with the infanticide-er, abortion rates.
" face the agony of an unplanned pregnancy " WTF? please spare me your agony, you clearly are a person who has had an abortion trying to justify your actions to humans, GOD will be the one you will need to convince that your " face the agony of an unplanned pregnancy" justified the death of your child.
If people like you would get a vasectomy, then there would be no problem with the agony of an unplanned pregancy. I guess I have to ask you, WTF? Who died and left you in charge? The brainwashers called religion?
Bob, it's time for your medication.
Hi. I'd like to introduce you to the idea that not everybody in the world is a Christian or believes in god. You can think whatever you want, I suppose, but if you live your life in a "moral" way, what the hell do you care about what the rest of us do? Your sanctimonious attitude only serves to make YOU feel better, it doesn't do the rest of the world any @!$%#ing good. Shut up.
Bob is not capable of empathy, but does believe that he has the right and the direction from God to make my decisions about my body for me. The only way to prevent "unplanned pregnancies" is abstinence. Maybe the men who think they should be able to make this decision for us should try abstinence. Problem solved.
"Stop judging, and you will not be judged.
Stop condemning, and you will not be condemned.
Forgive, and you will be forgiven."
GOD will be the one you will need to convince
Oh, please. Use of 'god' in this issue is absurd. 60-80% of fertilized eggs don't implant; one-third of those naturally abort. That makes your ""god"" the biggest abortionist around. It clearly shows their value to the divine.
Bob - The bible also states that judgement is for God alone; not you and not the murderer that operated outside the law.
good one way2go, love it
That's right Bob...God will be the one to decide...not you! Lose the god-complex because that job is taken. You will never face the complex situation of having an unplanned pregnancy and should not presume to understand. I am pro-life AND pro-choice simply because my beliefs have no part in the debate. Our constitution guarantees the right to privacy and that is the issue upon which Roe V Wade was decided. Reversing Roe V Wade will not stop abortions. Killing doctors who perform abortions will not stop abortions. When my 13 year-old daughter was raped by a neighbor, we were faced with the most horrible decision imaginable. My daughter had a very serious medical condition that, had she carried the fetus to term, would have killed her. What choice would you make? And, is it any business of yours what choice we, her parents, made?
Bob and Flowerlady. The both of you are total idiots. I had a late term abortion and I would do it again. I found I out I was carrying a "lethal dwarf" a horrible genetic mutation where the baby( very deformed) would have died during birth or quickly afterwards. Why in hell should I be forced to continue to carry to term to appease people like you? Women take abortion very seriously. We are not stupid! You are so black and white and are truly clueless about why a woman would get a late term abortion.
ITA, Montanagirl- they would treat their dogs with more humanity- of course their dogs are smarter then they are
I'm sorry for your loss.
montanagirl - The people that don't understand about late term abortions are caught up in political and radical religious retoric. We can't expect any logical thought from them, or any true compassion.
Your compassion and understanding is real - theirs is just a front or a hobby to make themselves look important. Kind of like belonging to a country club.
Liberals make me sick. I'm a union electrician and a reg. dem. But life has to start somewhere, who are we to decide at what point in human developement we can or connot kill them. Any abortion IS murder, and if the law will not prosecute and give justice to the babies then we should. This animal got what he deserved.
No, not god. Sounds as though you've decided who's in charge here, BOB. BOB's ten commandments state...
Didn't mean to spark such a nerve, but enough is enough! Abortions have been going on since the beginning of time and will continue until the end of time. I think these 'God complex' brain washed people come along and suddenly feel the fricken urge to tell the rest of the world what they "need" to be doing and how they "need" to be acting. Most of the time, it is someone who doesn't have all the facts, only knows what someone else has put in their head and surely couldn't imagine thinking for themselves. I don't agree with everything that others do, but maybe through education, etc. then people can have the brains to figure it out for themselves.
Meanwhile, let God do his work and you keep your damn day job, that is if you are lucky enough to have one!
Women in China abort girl fetuses preferentially. How is that taking abortion seriously?
Catechisms are doctrines of Man, an interpretation of the Bible, not the Bible itself. Of course, no one's actually READ the Bible except for the small number of folks that can actually read archaic Hebrew and Aramaic.
All of this we're debating is based on a translation of a translation of a translation of a translation of a book written in the Bronze/Iron Age (nod to Bill Maher). And it was men of that age that decided which ancient writings would be included in the "Bible" and which would not. I wonder what's in the "deleted scenes"....
Have some fun with this notion: go to Babelfish and translate the phrase "I love you" from English to French, French to German, etc through 4 or 5 different languages. Then translate that result back to English. It's a hoot.
Yet some Christian extremists are comfortable with killing those they disgree with based on their interpretations of this translation. And many mainstream Christians are comfortable with passing laws restricting the rights of women they don't know and will never be involved with based on THEIR interpretations of this translation. Because of course the BELIEVE in their interpretations of this translation, they have FAITH, and faith trumps all reason and logic.
With the exception of publically funded abortions (and that's a subject we SHOULD have a debate on), abortion is the business of the individuals involved, and whatever god(s) they choose to believe/disbelieve in. AND NO ONE ELSE'S! If you believe abortion is wrong (as do I):
A. Don't get one
B. Teach your children it's wrong
And leave it at that! Keep your nose out of other people's business, like my folks taught me!
For crying out loud, don't we have more important concerns as a nation?
Once again, they do this in the name of the Lord! Did you read the 10 Commandments one of which says "Thou shalt not Kill." And in the Drs. place of worship no less. This is one of the reasons, that those of us, that are prochoice, not proabortion, will never hook up with you anti abortion nutcases. To take the life of a Physician, is no less wrong than taking the life of a embryo. I will never understand their reasoning, oh forgot, they do not reason, they hate!!!!
Murder is never condoned, that is why ppl. try to save the unborn, who never got a chance to breathe. How can you justify your anger for the doctor, yet dismiss his victims. He was shot in both arms in 1991 yet he was willing to die, to continue to kill. I know I know, the debate is still out there about when a baby becomes a baby. But you believe in fairytales if you think that most abortions are for deformed children. That is a lie.
If a mother gives birth in her bathtub and then drowns her baby, she is charged with murder. If a doctor performs an abortion on a baby 9 months along, even on the day it is to be born, it is considered okay. And according to Obama, it the baby survives that abortion attempt, then it is okay to set it aside, until he or she dies.
Next, will come the holocaust of the elderly, as well. People say that we have to many humans on earth. They praise abortion for the extermination of silence humans, next inconvenient group targeted to die, will be grandma and then us as we age, after all it is good for society if we don't have the cost of the elderly. See what logic and reasoning can do?
It is better to protect the sanctity of life, no matter how small.
Too bad he didn't hit Bob.
So any woman who miscarries should be charged with manslaughter, right?
After all, your "if we don't know for sure, then life has to start where I say it starts" schtick puts criminal prosecution of killing at "anything after conception."
Once again, "Compassionate Conservatives" care only about a blob of cells.
Actual people exist to be murdered when they don't agree with Conservatives, subject to diminished welfare state spending, or sent overseas to fight illegal wars...preferably if they are brown and poor.
Is it finally clear why the world is sick of the conservative, American Taliban?
NO ONE Pro life would condone this behavior...murder is murder....and the nut case that did this should be prosecuted for a horrible crime.
But murder is murder and this "Dr" Tiller knew exactly what that was. Hundreds of babies were murdered by his hands and the God who created him will be his judge..
Pro choice is a sugar coated name for murder and slaughter of the innocent.....late term fetuses if born can live and grow to becoming healthy HUMAN beings......I know I'm a neo-natal nurse ...
While I dont condone murder on any level.....at least Dr Tiller had a life ..
He choose to take away that right from hundreds of babies
STRANGE BEDFELLOWS
Politics makes strange bedfellows, but the union between Conservatives: who staunchly believe that Government should stay the hell out of our lives as much as possible, and Right-to-Lifers: who believe that Government should FORCE unwilling mothers to harbor and sustain a life within their flesh for the nine months of their pregnancy, that union between two opposing extremes is the strangest to me of all.
My view is simple. Abortion is wrong but it is not illegal. We have to make a clear distinction between what is wrong and what is illegal.
Meanwhile the law itself traditionally believes that life begins when a human being draws its first breath. Just as reasonable is to believe that a baby is protected by the law from the moment the placenta is separated from the mother's blood supply. The law can go no further than that without infringing on the constitutional rights of the mother.
Clearly there is a grey area which occurs in the birthing room where post-partum babies may be allowed to die, purportedly because they are not viable as human beings. Yet, this is the same reason that Mike Tyson's 4 year old baby was legally separated from her life support system, because she was no longer viable as a human being. Physicians, as professionals, are trusted to make this call every day throughout the nations. The opportunity for abuse exists for a 80 year old just as it does for an 8 second year old. To a physician the area of decision is not a grey area at all. We trust them, with only a few exceptions to make this call. Where they breach this trust they should have to answer for it and that is as it should be.
But it appears to me that this grey area is not the real bone of contention here. It is clear to all supporters of choice that the activist foes of abortion, (as opposed to those who simply believe it is wrong,) are really seeking for an ultimate ban on abortions of all kinds. This is clearly an extremist view and unsupportable because of the tremendous advances in medical technology which are now able to achieve much that is possible but pragmatically unsustainable for mass applications. The so called Octo-Mom is a case in point.
This is why although I vehemently believe that all abortion is wrong, and although I pray forgiveness that my youthful unwillingness to accept responsibility for my actions did once result in my condoning such an act, I still cannot support legislation banning all abortions. There are many sins which cannot be sanctioned by the law and I believe that abortion is one of them.
nick-1132575......
Since your radical philosophy is inconsistent with any religion I know of,
it must be based on something else. Maybe, however, it is merely your
own convoluted idea of vigilante justice. There are already a number of
"freemen" behind bars. I'm sure there's room for you should you, also,
decide to take the law into your own hands. Isn't it interesting that those
who loudly trumpet their concern for life are the ones most willing to
take it?
You did get something in your post right. You are indeed "sick".
What's everybody so upset about ? This is nothing but a late,late term abortion.
you piece of garbage
Hey now, don't insult garbage, even it wouldn't want something this poisonous around.
You mean like the garbage where the fetuses are thrown ?
You support abortion, what's the difference when it's done? Opps, I forgot, you set the rules on when the termination takes place to justify your guilt. If somebody were to do to your pets what these abortion hacks do to the fetus, you would be screaming about it.
Are you talking about those fetuses from the litter-makers? You know, those fetuses we weren't allowed to use for stem cell research by Prez Bush? Those were the fetuses that are created so infertile good Christians can have their "own" baby instead of utilizing adoption. You know those "good" Christians? The ones whose god chose to make infertile and so they need science to help them make a baby (or 8) and throw away the fetuses they didn't want in the process.
Old, you're not just old, you've got dementia if you can't see the double-standard in your statements. Of course you can't. You poor man. Maybe I shouldn't presume you're a man just because you sound so ignorant on this topic. But I think the odds are with that bet. Anyone care to bet if Old409 is a man or a woman?
Your very statement proves that you have no value for human life. You would have made a great concentration camp guard. If you need a job I hear the Taliban is looking for a few good men.
an absolute outrage. find the terrorist thug who did this, charge him, convict him and then kill him.
even this will not be adaquate punishment for this sub-human.
Rob,
Are you talking about the full termabortion doctor?